Search Site
This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.
Hide this

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.


Immortal Hulk Vol. 1: Or is he Both? (Immortal Hulk (2018))

by Al Ewing, Joe Bennett (Illustrator)

Other authors: See the other authors section.

Series: Immortal Hulk (Vol. 1 (1-5))

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingConversations
1115216,895 (3.83)None
THE RETURN OF BRUCE BANNER! You know Bruce Banner. He's quiet, calm, never complains. He's a man who believes he can use the darkest elements of his personality to do good in the world. If someone were to shoot him in the head... All he'd do is die. But the horror lives deeper. A horror that refuses to die. When night falls something other than the man gets up again. The horror is the Immortal Hulk. COLLECTING: IMMORTAL HULK 1-5, MATERIAL FROM AVENGERS: NO SURRENDER 684… (more)

Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

No current Talk conversations about this book.

Showing 5 of 5

Everyone I know told me how great this new series was, despite my apprehension at all the new powers the Hulk suddenly seems to have. Yes, I'm one of those assholes who's against classic superheroes suddenly leveling up to new powers.

But the Hulk's sudden Wolverine-like healing factor isn't even the thing that pissed me off here. No, it was the fact that they went back almost 60 years and retrofitted a mysterious green door into his history.

Sorry, but this, to me, is lazy-ass storytelling. Hey Marvel, I have a great way of expanding on the Hulk, but it does mean we have to go all the way back to the beginning and stick in this event that no one has ever mentioned a single time in six decades, but now we'll make it canon and we'll have to work on shoving it in where we can. Sounds great, huh?


At its base, the storytelling is okay. Not great, not terrible. Standard Marvel fare. The art is quite good, and the Hulk looks...well...hulking. I love the nods to Buscema and Trimpe, and I'm sure there's others I missed as I began to skim just to get to the end of this stupid storyline.

But overall, I was left feeling the same as I came in...why do they have to change the Hulk? Yes, characters should grow and change, but it's all these power changes, and rewritten history things that don't work for me.

I'm done. The Immortal Hulk is dead to me. ( )
  TobinElliott | Sep 3, 2021 |
Immortal Hulk, volume 1 - Or is he both?
Author: Ewing, Bennett, Jose, Mounts
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Publishing Date: 2019
Pgs: 128
Dewey: 741.5973 HUL V.1
Disposition: Irving Public Library - South Campus - Irving, TX

Quiet, calm, hidden, hiding...Bruce Banner. Shot in the head and taken to a morgue, left for dead. When night falls, something unquiet awakens. A horror that refuses to die.

The Immortal Hulk lives.

Marvel Comics
Graphic Novels

Why this book:
I prefer my Hulks raging and rampaging.
The Feel:
The Hulk meets Reanimator. Nice.

Least Favorite Character:
Brian Banner.

Favorite Scene:
That’s a helluva opening scene and definitely not what I expected. Our hero...well...our hero’s alter ego shot in the head and dead on Page 6.

Favorite Quote:
“I eat gamma” is one of my favorite Hulk lines.

Favorite Concept:
Hulk vs biker gang.

Hulk as a spirit of vengeance type.

The different art styles of each of the unreliable witnesses/narrators in the church hostage crisis. Though, I almost gagged with the Old Lady seeing it as a James Dean pastiche all about love.

Gamma junkies wanting a fix so they can be like the Hulk.

Hmm Moments:
Hmmm...Kind of a Doctor Phosphorus kind of vibe...only with Gamma Radiation and the glowind death. Doctor Frye...it’s his name, but a bit Silver Agey on point too.

Seems like there should be more gamma mutates in the Marvel Universe. This series seems to take a step in that way with Doctor Frye, whatever Frye’s son turns out to be, and Hotshot...and maybe more since this is only thru issue 2 of the trade paperback.

Meh / PFFT Moments:
Walter doesn’t look like Walter. Did they even look at the old Alpha Flights and previous appearances of Walter Langowski? Looks more like a skinny, knockoff Sabertooth...and I know that Wild Child is already a skinny, knockoff Sabertooth...so, same, but different.

The Sigh:
I’m not a fan of “daddy issues” Hulk. Trauma driven fine. But “daddy issues” Hulk has always been weak sauce to me. There was enough trauma in Bruce’s backstory before all of that crap was added. Reeks of the same crap that made Hank Pym an abuser and Janet Van Dyne his victim, a disservice to both characters.

Yeah...I don’t think that the Hulk is the “Devil Behind the Green Door/Below” that all these people seem to be seeing through their gamma powered dreams.

“Walter” telegraphed unreliable narrator a bit hard. He’s roses and wonderful and Banner was a basket case and unstable.

The Unexpected:
Again with the Green Door. And if Walter saw it, then it’s been around forever. Did Banner see the Green Door when he crossed the gamma barrier or is this a latter day occurrence? Is this a retcon pastiche? Or is this related to something else coming through that door?

Get Off My Lawn:
Were the writers and editorial even aware of “what goes on ‘Behind the Green Door’”? I can’t imagine that it was completely an accident. Some of these guys have to be old enough to be cognizant. Or have done some research.
It is well paced and flows well. Not nearly as dragging heels as too many TPBs are these days.

Last Page Sound:
Oh boy, more daddy issues stories. Hooray. [/snarcasm]
_________________________________________________ ( )
  texascheeseman | Sep 10, 2020 |
This takes the Hulk in a very awesome and interesting direction. I thought it was just going to be kinda like the whole Zombie Marvel run and just as fun, especially because the Hulk himself is all Freudian.

Listen, you know the whole thing about Id, Ego, and Superego? Hulk, (some strange mix of Banner and Hulk), and Banner? Add a little sex and a lot of the death wish?

Well now we've got a huge extra serving of the death wish and with it, an awesome new twist in the Ego.

Banner is less intelligent after his death. The Hulk now has it. Rage-filled intelligence. Immortality. And he's MEAN when he's intelligent. :) Scary.

Hulk comes out at night and stalks his prey. Banner is at the Hulk's mercy more than ever, but now he can listen to the Hulk prod him from inside. Reasoning for him. Pushing him ever on. The Hulk is now the driver. :)

Soooo cool. :) This is breathing a whole new life into the character. :) ( )
  bradleyhorner | Jun 1, 2020 |
Hulk lives! Now! Again! Forever! (Cue swelling dramatic music. Maestro, please!)

Another of the big dramatic moments of Civil War II is undone as the Bruce Banner Hulk returns to his own series. But this time, writer Al Ewing is going for a straight-up horror story as he uses the nocturnal nature of the Hulk in his earliest appearances to ascribe a supernatural element to the character. And, hey, it sorta works. Hulk has always had parallels to Robert Louis Stevenson's Mr. Hyde, but now he is all that crossed with Frankenstein, a werewolf, and a zombie to boot.

It's a bit cheesy, but definitely worth a second look. ( )
  villemezbrown | Mar 2, 2019 |
Bruce Banner supposedly died killing the Hulk with him. But there have been sightings of the Hulk around as Banner, who did not die after being shot in the skull and the heart with a special arrow by Hawkeye in an attempt to kill himself or see if he could be killed failed. There has been some damage done to his brain due to the arrow. He has a harder time putting the pieces together and must depend on the hunches given to him by the green guy to figure out what is going on in a given situation where he is trying to seek justice for a person or a town.

These are short tales pieced together by the common thread of a reporter Jackie Mcgee. First, there's the incident at the gas station where a twelve-year-old girl is gunned down in a robbery done for a local gang. Then there's a town with a mysterious wasting disease that claims those who greave for their family members who have died. Then a young man holes up in a church taking a priest hostage who happens to have special powers that lead investigators to a hotel room where there are a dead girl and a message about a green door.

Jackie feels she is on to something when Banner's old college roommate Walter Langkowski, who once worked for Alpha Flight as Sasquatch, a being similar to the Hulk in that he was created with gamma rays but he changes into an orange fur ball, reaches out to her. But what does he want with Banner or the Hulk and what is he hiding?

Also included in this comic is Avengers #684 opening sequence which recaps the recent events in the life and death of Bruce Banner that led to this comic. I'm not a huge Hulk fan, but I decided to give this comic a try and I really liked it. The author included quotations at the start of every new issue that I really enjoyed as I am a huge collector of quotations and added a few to my collection. But I really liked this Bruce Banner who is slightly damaged and must depend on the Hulk a little more than he likes in order to continue his mission to seek out justice in this world wherever he can. I will definitely be reading the next volume. I give it a four out of five stars.


Man is, on the whole, less good than he imagines himself or wants to be.

-Carl Gustav Jung (Psychology and Religion)

One always dies too soon—or too late.

-Jean Paul Sartre (No Exit)

My devil had been long caged, he came out roaring.

-Robert Louis Stephenson (The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde) ( )
  nicolewbrown | Feb 1, 2019 |
Showing 5 of 5
no reviews | add a review

» Add other authors (19 possible)

Author nameRoleType of authorWork?Status
Ewing, AlAuthorprimary authorall editionsconfirmed
Bennett, JoeIllustratormain authorall editionsconfirmed
Ross, AlexCover artistsecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed

Belongs to Series

Immortal Hulk (Vol. 1 (1-5))
You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Canonical title
Original title
Alternative titles
Original publication date
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Awards and honors
First words
There are two people in every mirror.
Last words
(Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)
Disambiguation notice
Contains material originally published in magazine form as Immortal Hulk (2018) #1-5. Do not combine with hardcover Vol. 1 containing issues #1-10.
Publisher's editors
Original language
Canonical DDC/MDS
Canonical LCC

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English


THE RETURN OF BRUCE BANNER! You know Bruce Banner. He's quiet, calm, never complains. He's a man who believes he can use the darkest elements of his personality to do good in the world. If someone were to shoot him in the head... All he'd do is die. But the horror lives deeper. A horror that refuses to die. When night falls something other than the man gets up again. The horror is the Immortal Hulk. COLLECTING: IMMORTAL HULK 1-5, MATERIAL FROM AVENGERS: NO SURRENDER 684

No library descriptions found.

Book description
Haiku summary

Popular covers

Quick Links


Average: (3.83)
1 1
2.5 1
3 8
3.5 1
4 17
4.5 2
5 6

Is this you?

Become a LibraryThing Author.


About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 180,225,080 books! | Top bar: Always visible