The concept was much better than the execution. Pretty slow until Chapter 8 where the discussion becomes more philosophical. I liked Einstein's Dreams much better.

I liked Einstein's Dreams so much better. ( )

I feel like I hit the book lottery. I hate hyperbole, and perhaps after the book hangover has faded I'll find myself backtracking or offering qualifications, but as of right now, this last minute impulse buy, at a used book sale for $1, might be the best book I've ever read.

Ever.

I didn't think so when I started it, because the back-cover had me expecting an historical fiction; a what-if look back. I was not pleased to start that first chapter and find myself confronted with a speculative fantasy told in first person omnipresent POV. I found the narrative voice a bit condescending and supercilious and I didn't see how this was possibly going to be anything other than a pretentious attempt at literary fiction.

Thankfully that only lasted for 4 pages or so, before it became obvious what the author was setting up, and I suddenly found myself totally hooked.

Imagine the chance to step outside of time and place to have to opportunity to speak with one person in history; not only about themselves and their work, but about their entire field as it spans time and events; to be able to learn and explore ideas with a hero of the discipline, someone who changed the world.

This is the setup for the book. A nameless young woman 'finds' Einstein in a place that transcends time and she is gained admittance to his study for an 'interview'. What follows is a conversation to which we are invisible observers. This conversation spans all of Einstein's theories, what his work started; its repercussions; the emotional fall-out and the consequences of his overnight celebrity and the cost of his Jewish background.

What can I say? It's beautiful, this odd what-if of a book. The science isn't for those disinterested in physics but it isn't incomprehensible either. The personal element is ... the author made you feel like you were there and made you feel Einstein's wonder, amazement, melancholy, regret, betrayal and pensiveness; the 'doors' were an incredibly vivid way to bring the times and events to life, and a drop-in visit by Newton was both funny and heart-wrenching.

I loved this book, I loved it so much. It's so good I'm overlooking the times the author tried to argue against concepts by using the very same assumptions that he claims makes those concepts false. Everything else was so overwhelmingly good that the fallacy isn't worth a 1/2 star demerit. I closed the book wanting to hug it.

It's obviously a work of fiction but only in its construct; 85% of this book is factual representation of Einstein's and his contemporaries' theories, so if you're partial to science, philosophy, and think Einstein is a legend, definitely check this book out. I honestly just wanted to stay in that room with him forever.

(This is a English translation of the book Einstein, s'il vous plait.) ( )

Imagine you could visit Einstein and ask him questions about his theories and his life and physics and philosophy and war and many other subjects. In this book a young woman does that but the visit takes place 50 years after Einstein died. What an interesting idea and one that is pulled off quite well.
The young woman is nameless and the visit takes place in an apartment in some unidentified city which is probably somewhere in Europe where Einstein lived in his life. The woman had heard rumours that it was possible to contact Einstein and she tried several addresses before she happened on the right one. She was shown into a waiting room that contained a number of people including one who looked like Isaac Newton. She is not kept waiting too long before being shown in to the study where Einstein continues to exist and work. When she asks why she was shown in before the other people in the waiting room Einstein replies that it is because she is from the future which makes him glad because it means the world continued to exist despite the discovery of nuclear weapons. One of Einstein’s great regrets is that his theories led to the development of “weapons of mass destruction”. He was always a pacifist, protesting against the first and second world wars. Despite this philosophy he did write to President Roosevelt to urge him to commit the USA to developing an atomic bomb. That’s just one of the contradictions in Einstein’s life which this book explores. He was an atheist but he admits to believing in a great flautist that ensures the harmony of the Universe. If that’s not God (or a god) then I fail to see the difference.
There is a lot to assimilate in this little book as it explores physics from Galileo’s time to Higgs’ time (as in Higgs boson). However, there are also lots of anecdotes taken from Einstein’s life and if you have a high school knowledge of physics you will make it through the tougher bits with enjoyment. ( )

charming and highly perceptive pop discussion of particle physics, cosmology, the theory of relativity and the philosophy of modern science ( )