Caroline Hardaker
Author of Composite Creatures
Works by Caroline Hardaker
Associated Works
Tagged
Common Knowledge
Members
Reviews
This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader.
---
"THE BACK OF THE BOOK"
I'm pretty sure I'd end up ruining something if I tried to summarize this myself, so let's use the description from the Publisher's site:
THE WORLD BUILDING
This is a terrifying look at an entirely possible not-that-future world for us. I'm not going to get into the details, but this is an England (and we can assume the rest of the world is a lot like it) devastated by pollution, climate change, and humans messing around with genetics and other experimental medicine.
The effects of all that are seen in nature—flora and fauna—and in the health of just about everyone in the novel.
Some things never change, however, those with money—or a way to get it—have a better shot at whatever slim advantages there are to be had.
And Hardaker absolutely sells this world—the choices she made in constructing, depicting, and revealing the details of this world were perfect. I cannot say enough for the setting and the way she showed it.
SO, WHAT DID I THINK ABOUT COMPOSITE CREATURES?
Sadly, the world that Hardaker portrayed was the only part of this book that resonated with me.
I was pretty sure of two things within the first 50 pages (less than that, but I wasn't keeping score):
This wasn't a case of me disliking it—it was too good for that. But I just didn't care, I wasn't invested—I never got more than mildly curious. If I'd been forced to return this to the library before I finished, I don't know that I'd have bothered to check it out again. I did keep waiting for that moment—the one that changed everything and made the whole thing worthwhile—and it didn't come.
I'm giving this 3 stars—the writing/worldview/etc. deserves at least 4, but my experience was a big ol' "meh" and probably would've gotten a 2 if a lesser writer had been responsible for it. So we'll average the two.
Now, I think I'm the exception—Hardaker's a great writer and this combination of too-likely dystopia and environmental collapse is the kind of thing that I can see a lot of people really getting into. I'd recommend you do. When Paul recommended Composite Creatures to me, he said something like he couldn't stop thinking about it—I don't blame him, it's going to be a long time before I stop thinking about it. Incidentally, you should read Paul's post about the novel for a different and very positive take.… (more)
---
"THE BACK OF THE BOOK"
I'm pretty sure I'd end up ruining something if I tried to summarize this myself, so let's use the description from the Publisher's site:
In a society where self-preservation is as much an art as a science, Norah and Arthur are learning how to co-exist in domestic bliss. Though they hardly know each other, everything seems to be going perfectly – from the home they’re building together to the ring on Norah’s finger.
But survival in this world is a tricky thing, the air is thicker every day and illness creeps fast through the body. The earth is becoming increasingly hostile to live in.Fortunately, Easton Grove have the answer, a perfect little bundle of fur that Norah and Arthur can take home. All they have to do to live long, happy lives is keep it, or her, safe and close.
THE WORLD BUILDING
This is a terrifying look at an entirely possible not-that-future world for us. I'm not going to get into the details, but this is an England (and we can assume the rest of the world is a lot like it) devastated by pollution, climate change, and humans messing around with genetics and other experimental medicine.
The effects of all that are seen in nature—flora and fauna—and in the health of just about everyone in the novel.
Some things never change, however, those with money—or a way to get it—have a better shot at whatever slim advantages there are to be had.
And Hardaker absolutely sells this world—the choices she made in constructing, depicting, and revealing the details of this world were perfect. I cannot say enough for the setting and the way she showed it.
SO, WHAT DID I THINK ABOUT COMPOSITE CREATURES?
Sadly, the world that Hardaker portrayed was the only part of this book that resonated with me.
I was pretty sure of two things within the first 50 pages (less than that, but I wasn't keeping score):
- This was a fantastically written book, it's wonderfully conceived, prescient, and haunting.
- This was not a book for me.
This wasn't a case of me disliking it—it was too good for that. But I just didn't care, I wasn't invested—I never got more than mildly curious. If I'd been forced to return this to the library before I finished, I don't know that I'd have bothered to check it out again. I did keep waiting for that moment—the one that changed everything and made the whole thing worthwhile—and it didn't come.
I'm giving this 3 stars—the writing/worldview/etc. deserves at least 4, but my experience was a big ol' "meh" and probably would've gotten a 2 if a lesser writer had been responsible for it. So we'll average the two.
Now, I think I'm the exception—Hardaker's a great writer and this combination of too-likely dystopia and environmental collapse is the kind of thing that I can see a lot of people really getting into. I'd recommend you do. When Paul recommended Composite Creatures to me, he said something like he couldn't stop thinking about it—I don't blame him, it's going to be a long time before I stop thinking about it. Incidentally, you should read Paul's post about the novel for a different and very positive take.… (more)
Composite Creatures by Caroline Hardaker
I was unable to get interested in this novel. I tried multiple times, the description made it seem like something that I would enjoy, but it never engaged.
Basically, it's about a man and woman who move in together and live their lives. They adopt a pet that is some sort of genetically modified creature. Maybe resembling a cat, possibly has gray or purple fur. The book went on and on about their love and care for their pet.
I received a complimentary copy from #netgalley @netgalley of #compositecreatures and was under no obligation to post a review.… (more)
I was unable to get interested in this novel. I tried multiple times, the description made it seem like something that I would enjoy, but it never engaged.
Basically, it's about a man and woman who move in together and live their lives. They adopt a pet that is some sort of genetically modified creature. Maybe resembling a cat, possibly has gray or purple fur. The book went on and on about their love and care for their pet.
I received a complimentary copy from #netgalley @netgalley of #compositecreatures and was under no obligation to post a review.… (more)
Awards
Statistics
- Works
- 4
- Also by
- 1
- Members
- 71
- Popularity
- #245,552
- Rating
- 3.4
- Reviews
- 3
- ISBNs
- 9
Thoughts: I really wanted to like this more. The writing style is intriguing; a bit ambiguous but very viscerally descriptive and somehow strangely engaging.
The whole story alternates between "before" and "after". The "before" portions show our main protagonist, David, as he grows up from a boy to an adult. The "after" portions show him on a journey to a doorway. David is different than other people and was hugely affected by the disappearance of his grandfather. He is convinced his grandfather went away somewhere and is determined to find him.
My biggest issue with this story is you can't really figure out what is going on and I don't think you are supposed to. The story has a creepy vibe to it with disappearing people and things with wings in the shadows. However, you never really know in the end if David is suffering from mental illness, or if this is a world where people are falling into doorways.
Trying to piece this together was what propelled me through the story as a reader. However, I was left disappointed because I felt like the ending just got weirder and didn't provide any resolution.
If you enjoy ambiguous, creepy stories that are going to leave you completely confused about what actually happened, then you might really enjoy this. The writing is well done with a lot of description and it was intriguing and weird enough that I finished it. It didn't make me want to pick up any other books by Hardaker though.
My Summary (3/5): Overall I finished this but was left feeling disappointed that there wasn't better resolution to the story. The writing is visceral and engaging but the story left me feeling confused. I probably won't go out of my way to read anymore books by Hardaker. However, if you are looking for a creepy and odd story this might be interesting to you.… (more)