

|
Loading... The Hemlock Cup: Socrates, Athens and the Search for the Good Lifeby Bettany Hughes
None. Though the copious details are at times overwhelming, Hughes does a beautiful job depicting the ancient Athens of Socrates and renders a superb portrait of the philosopher. Vivid and fascinating. ( )Washington Post likes this; while I'm not direly in need of another Socrates bio, having read the excellent [b:Why Socrates Died|6321023|Why Socrates Died|Robin Waterfield|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1266637140s/6321023.jpg|6506375] a couple years back, I find him - and the necessity of his execution - wicked interesting. Check out her other books, too. She wrote a bio of Helen of Troy?! I had no idea she was a reliably real person. NY Times also likes this: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/20/books/review/Isaacson-t.html?pagewanted=2&... The Hemlock Cup is actually three narratives in one book: the physicality and history of Athens during Socrates' life, a largely-guesswork biography of Socrates, and a guided tour through the digs in modern Greece that resulted in the foundations for a lot of Bettany Hughes' supposition. Each chapter is riveting, engaging, and makes me want to look things up so that I can know more. Taken as a whole, the piece is disjointed and jumpy, uneasily sitting between the history of Athens and the after-image of Socrates. It's odd the things she explains to her readers and the things she doesn't, often seeming as if she's forgotten to put in a parenthetic statement or footnote in a number of passages (the introduction of Alcibiades was particularly frustrating to me). I was left with the feeling that she wrote some chapters with an academic audience in mind, and others with a popular audience in mind. A bit of a curate's egg ~ constructed in the same manner as her 'Helen of Troy': pulling in the threads of evidence from archaeology, literature and history but (IMO) relies slightly too much on speculation and leaps of faith. Dr Hughes is also manifestly anti- Alkibiades and ~ without overtly saying so ~ appears to blame the Athenian aristocrat for much of what caused Sokrates' (eventual) downfall. However, it's a well-produced volume and an entertaining read ~ and you can't say that about all books on ancient history!
There can't be, from my point of view, too many books about Socrates, so I am not complaining at the appearance of this one. It is less than 18 months, however, since I reviewed in these pages an excellent book by Robin Waterfield, Why Socrates Died, on very much this topic. To be fair to Bettany Hughes, though, she was at work on her equally fine version of the theme for at least 10 years, long before Waterfield’s book appeared.
References to this work on external resources.
|
Google Books — Loading...RatingAverage: (3.8)
Is this you?Become a LibraryThing Author. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||