Harry Lachman (1886–1975)

You could almost feel the gentle trade winds of Hawaii during the 1920s in the first Charlie Chan novel by Earl Derr Biggers. Romantic and full of atmosphere, Biggers was always a great romance writer who simply incorporated mystery into his books to propel the story forward. His detective was wise and humorous, his take on American life sometimes a riot. Nothing got by Chan, however, and it was his intelligence which always brought justice in the end.

The adaptations to film lost some of the show more more romantic aspects of the early Chan novels, centering more on Chan as a detective, which was to be expected. Enough humor and atmosphere remained, however, to propel Chan into the top tier of film detectives.

Warner Oland’s Chan was more refined and subtle, Sidney Toler’s more outgoing and amused. Both were excellent. This set features Toler in the final “A” Charlie Chan mysteries before it became a “B” series which, while enjoyable at times, did not have the production values or stories to live up to the previous big-studio pictures.

Fox often liked to put Chan in exotic locations and settings. Charlie was in Panama, or on a cruise, or in Rio. One of his many offspring was always in tow trying to play detective and generally getting in the way. By the time Castle in the Desert was filmed, it almost felt like a high end "B" rather than the classy mystery series it had once been. All are great fun, however, and three films in the set in particular stand out.

CHARLIE CHAN AT THE WAX MUSEUM is a terrific entry, and one of the most atmospheric of the entire series at Fox. This one is centered on a live radio broadcast from the Museum of Crime, where notorious criminals have been immortalized in wax. Chan’s second son, Jimmy (Sen Yung), is on hand to help Pop solve an old crime, and avoid becoming a victim himself. Jimmy accepts the challenge for Charlie to appear on the Crime League’s weekly broadcast to clear the name of Joe Rocke, a man Chan has long believed was unfairly executed for a crime he did not commit.

But it is Chan’s suspicion that the wax museum and his invitation are tied to the recent escape of a man he helped convict of murder that prompts the detective to accept. Once he arrives on a rainy night the creepy fun begins. A botched attempt to electrocute Charlie, the murder of a scientific rival by poison blow dart, and a wax Charlie Chan all add up to mystery fun for Charlie Chan fans.

Marguerite Chapman as the young radio reporter hoping this night will be a great story and Joan Valerie as the pretty but slightly shady assistant, Lily, stand out from the rest in John Larkin’s screenplay. This one’s a real kick in the pants!

CHARLIE CHAN IN RIO is actually a fun and colorful remake of the very early Chan entry, The Black Camel. We get a big dose of Brazil right from the start with shots of Rio’s sunny beaches and the posh nightclub where Lola Dean (Jacqueline Dalya) sings the exotic, “They Met in Rio,” written by Mark Gordon and Harry Warren. Chan and his enthusiastic second son, Jimmy (Sen Yung), are there to arrest Lola for a murder which took place on Charlie’s turf in Honolulu. But before Lola can slip away to marry Clark Reynolds, she is murdered, leaving Charlie and son Jimmy with a new crime to solve.

Marybeth Hughes is the beautiful Joan Reynolds, who did not like Lola in the least. She had much company, however, including Grace Ellis (Cobina Wright Jr.) and an Indian mystic who may have discovered Lola’s secret past. Young Jimmy, always ready to jump to the wrong conclusion, is a hoot. There is a very funny scene where Charlie discovers the real reason Jimmy has been missing math classes back home while he is under a spell. Jimmy’s affections for Lola’s pretty Chinese maid, Lili (Iris Wong), keeps the atmosphere light as Charlie plays a long-shot in order to catch a killer.

The mystery is both fun to solve and watch. Charlie’s interactions with young son Jimmy are priceless, as is his cool demeanor under pressure. Kay Linaker, Victor Jory, and Ted North round out the cast for one of the most entertaining Charlie Chan films of the series.

MURDER OVER NEW YORK finds Charlie Chan knee deep in sabotage and murder at a convention for detectives. Chan’s enthusiastic offspring, Jimmy (Sen Yung), arrives in New York just in time to “help” Pop. Chan’s bemusement at Jimmy is quite evident in his comment to a fellow detective regarding his involvement in previous cases. A good screenplay from Lester Ziffren and some good pacing from director Harry Lachman makes the mystery as much fun as the look on Chan’s face when Jimmy solves the case every five seconds!

Flying to an annual convention of police detectives in New York, Chan meets his old friend Drake from Scotland Yard aboard the plane. Drake is now working for the military, trying to stem a rash of sabotage. Once on land, he turns up dead, the briefcase containing evidence that will help expose the man named Narvo behind it all, missing. Jimmy’s nose for chemistry helps uncover a new gas as the method for the murder, and Chan goes to work to uncover the killer of an old pal.

Donald MacBride is the New York detective, Inspector Vance, who lets Charlie guide the investigation. A pretty actress named June Preston (Joan Valerie) is missing a pearl from her necklace which turns up at the murder scene. A chemist named David Elliot (Robert Lowery) and a lovely girl named Patricia (Marjorie Weaver) trying to prove his innocence also figure into the mystery as Chan sifts through the clues. Shemp Howard of Three Stooges fame has a funny bit as a fake Hindu along the way.

Charlie Chan was bright and funny, and audiences loved him. If anything, his character helped elevate and give distinction to the perspective at the time of Chan’s race in general, especially with Charlie being honest, trustworthy, honorable, and by far the most clever guy in the room.

The Charlie Chan mysteries were fun films with a very wide appeal; so much so, that we are still watching and talking about them today. Sidney Toler happens to be my personal favorite to have portrayed the sleuth, though he was not Chinese. These films are a fabulous time at the movies for detective and mystery fans. show less

Charlie receives fourteen free passes to the circus for him and his entire family but soon realizes that there are strings attached as the big top's co-owner asks his guest to investigate threatening letters that he's received. Before the famous detective can, the man is murdered. Charlie soon finds out that the co-owner was not a particularly pleasant or well-liked individual, and among the many suspects are his partner, a snake charmer and the menagerie's gorilla. Son Lee, usually an show more enthusiastic assistant for his father, is distracted by the show's beautiful contortionist. Written by duke1029 show less

Eccentic, elderly matron Patience Nodbury has a treasure map she's inherited from Black Hook, her pirate ancestor. To foil a mysterious thief who has tried to steal it, she divides it into four pieces, three of which she gives to fellow passengers booked to sail on the Suva Star, an old wooden sailing ship chartered for a treasure hunt on an offshore island. She is convinced that, according to family tradition, Black Hook will visit her before she dies. When the peg-legged "ghost" does just show more that, and she suffers a fatal heart attack, Charlie and Jimmy are faced with a boatload of red herrings including Bill Lydig, an escaped convict, Gene LaFarge, a certifiable neurotic accompanied by a personal psychiatrist, and the embittered Captain Kane, who was marooned on a deserted island by his ex-partner and vows revenge. Written by (duke1029@aol.com) (IMdb) show less

Paul Manderley, eccentric historian, and his wife, descendant of the Borgias, live in an isolated castle-like mansion in the Mojave Desert. When a guest suddenly collapses, Charlie Chan is invited to stay. As the standard mystery-mansion props come into play, and all means of outside communication are sabotaged, it becomes evident that one of the inhabitants has access to poisons and is prepared to use them... Written by Rod Crawford