Miss Silver Comes to Stay

My second Miss Silver and it's another perfectly constructed mystery. One of my big bugbears of classic cosy private detective mysteries is that often the big reveal depended on a clue that was completely hidden from the reader and not even hinted at. Like, you're just supposed guess at this backstory of this side character that no one has ever even slightly referenced. You often get those stories, and then there's this Miss Silver mystery.

The story lets you know firsthand that it's deliberately shielding clues from you. It gives you a conversation from one perspective in one chapter, and then rehashes the exact same conversation from another perspective with different tags and descriptions. Not only that, it switches viewpoints every show more chapter, providing such insights into relationships from both those in it and those perceiving it from outside. I felt spoilt from such richly layered storytelling.

Miss Silver herself is used sparingly, with the rest of the cast allowed their turns in centre stage. Wentworth also managed to walk that line between hard noir and happy resolution village mystery, producing a sharply refined mystery worthy of the golden age. show less

This was my second Miss Silver mystery; the first one I read was the first in the series, and frankly, it left me dubious about reading the rest, but I found this and one other on the bottom shelf at a local used book store and threw caution to the wind.

My brief googling has this book at either 15 or 16 in the series, and it shows. It was so much better! 90% less sappy puppy romance, 100% better plotting and characterisations. And the writing... the writing felt fresh and a little edgy, in that way that third person POV does when it's done correctly. An occasional and very subtle breaking of the fourth wall added to that feeling that I was reading a very accomplished writer's work.

I've heard that Wentworth was rather fond of using show more wills in her story lines, and this one doesn't disprove the rumour, but ... no, I'm not going to go further - I'm not sure it doesn't skirt the boundaries of spoiler-ville.

The mystery plotting... masterful. I was sucked into the story thoroughly; totally hooked and I missed it all, until it was so late in the game that it made no difference. I like Miss Silver; she's Miss Marple without the pretence of fluffiness and helplessness, so losing to her didn't bother me in the least. I only wish she'd stop coughing all the time. Someone ought to give that woman a cough drop.

I hope the other Miss Silver book I grabbed at the same time is as good, and I'll definitely be taking the time to look at the series' books again, though I might completely break rank with my life long habits and skip the first few books. Now I know how good she can be, I'd rather not suffer through Wentworth's growing pains if I can avoid it. show less

Apparently, I like cozy mysteries! Who knew? Typically they bore me to tears but these are different.

I started falling for the idea of this series when I saw one of the 40s-style covers on a friend's "currently reading" update. Then that friend started posting quotes from the books and I was completely taken in. Patricia Wentworth is a brilliant writer. But she doesn't try to bludgeon you with her brilliance. I've now read several of these and they are all lovely. They make me happy while I'm reading them and they end just right. The author doesn't jerk you around or try to make you feel miserable or anxious. Everything is prim and oh so English in a tea-and-cakes sort of way while just beneath the surface, all manner of smut is show more alluded to with a wink and a smile and a biting wit.

"Her name is Maud Silver. Louisa says she has solved many difficult cases besides being an extremely expert knitter."
[b:The Benevent Treasure|184889|The Benevent Treasure (A Miss Silver Mystery)|Patricia Wentworth|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1172523637s/184889.jpg|1708377]


"She wondered, as she always wondered about any new young man, whether he could dance. Such a lot of nice boys couldn't, and the boys that could weren't always the nice ones."
[b:Miss Silver Comes to Stay|660272|Miss Silver Comes to Stay|Patricia Wentworth|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1176851803s/660272.jpg|646347]

"It could have been Joseph. When had she ever heard him come or go? He walked like a cat - an admirable thing in a butler, but not if he used it to prowl in secret passages and come drifting through one's bedroom at dead of night."
[b:The Benevent Treasure|184889|The Benevent Treasure (A Miss Silver Mystery)|Patricia Wentworth|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1172523637s/184889.jpg|1708377]

"One bar of an electric fire burned on a hearth which had been built for better things. In front of it, with that air of despising his surroundings which is peculiar to his race, sat the cat Mactavish. He had just completed a meticulous toilet. His orange coat recalled the best Dundee marmalade. He looked down at the electric fire which he despised and waited for Felix or Penny to come and bone a herring for him. He had a passion for herrings, but he did not consider that either of the two older ladies was to be trusted in the matter of bones. A saucer of fish prepared for him by Miss Cassy had already been rejected."
[b:Through the Wall|660271|Through the Wall (A Miss Silver Mystery)|Patricia Wentworth|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1176851802s/660271.jpg|1946658] show less

Really enjoyed Miss Silver Comes to Stay by Patricia Wentworth. Wentworth, a contemporary of Christie and Sayer, writes so well with her characters that you feel you've read the series even when it's the first one you've read. It was on my TBR and I picked it because I needed a W for the AlphaCat! Miss Silver is a knitting Miss Marple.

What's really funny is that the image on the cover of my copy is of a woman slapping a man. - Never happens.

After an absence of over twenty years, James Lessiter returns to his hometown to collect his inheritance. After discovering that the estate has been systematically ripped off, James is murdered and his old flame, Rietta, is wrongly suspected.

Another boring mystery that doesn't have a whole lot of detection going on. It's odd that James Lessiter is repeatedly referred to as despicable. Henrietta is the one who terminated their engagement and people are stealing from James--not the other way around. It makes no sense for Lessiter to be portrayed as a villain.

This book quickly found its way into the donate box.

A good instalment in the Miss Silver series. I particularly liked how Wentworth sets the scene for the crime, setting up a number of suspects in the process, but also manages to rapidly eliminate some. Fortunately Miss Silver is on the scene, staying with an old friend, and is called in by one of the police’s main suspects to find out who murdered James Lassiter. Miss Silver solves the crime using her observational and deductive skills and knitting. Fantastic.

My first time reading about Miss Silver but easy enough to pick up the character even starting with book 16. In the Miss Marple vein with a notable difference--this old lady is a professional enquiry agent. Don't let her knitting fool you, she's a sharp old bird. Enjoyed it though spotted the murderer before all was revealed. Still a good read and looking for more in the series.