Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.
Loading... Human Diversity: The Biology of Gender, Race, and Class (edition 2020)by Charles Murray (Author)
Work InformationHuman Diversity: The Biology of Gender, Race, and Class by Charles Murray
None Loading...
Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. No current Talk conversations about this book. This is probably the book Charles Murray should have written, instead of The Bell Curve. It was basically a pretty reasonable introduction to modern genetics, combined with 10 basically uncontroversial assertions supported by evidence that there are sex and ancestral-population differences, and then reaffirmation that differences don't mean superiority, and that humans have value independent of their test scores, skin color, etc. If it had been written by anyone without the rather controversial background Murray now has, it would probably not get the same level of readership, but also wouldn't be hated. It's sad such a book has to be published and has to be so controversial. Are there biological differences in sex/gender? Are there biological differences between racial groups? These two questions should be easily answered. Differences in class caused by biology, a bit harder. But the science is there. Now, even though Murray is not asking for anything bad and never denounces the dignity of any group or promotes superiority of any group, don't worry: he's going to be labeled as a racist, bigot, misogynist, etc., etc., etc. I give it four stars because, despite its attempt to be intelligible to the average reader, it is still mathematically, statistically, and scientifically dense. Also, I hate the reference system, though I am happy there are endnotes, content notes, and a full bibliography. Murray provides an exhaustive coverage of current genetic and neuroscience research on the heritability of cognitive capacities and personality characteristics. The text is exemplary in its clarity, layout and explanatory apparatus. Extensive appendices provide a crash course in statistics for those who may need it. Murray is confident that the modern discipline of psychology informed by genetics, neuroscience and powered by computerised statistics has emerged as a quantitative and predictive science. The framework of the book is conservative in its adherence to western, capitalistic economics and ethics and evolutionist in its explanatory stance. Murray is understandably combative in his presentation of the case for the heritability of personality and cognitive capacities and their differential distribution among ancestral ethnicities, genders, social and economic classes and elites. Murray has been a lightning rod for vituperation from those who maintain that the central theses of his psychology are racist, illiberal and profoundly undemocratic. Wherever one stands in this divide, Human Diversity is invaluable for its charity and comprehensive coverage of the case for genetic heritability. *** Edited to add a TW: This review is apparently EXTREMELY triggering to racist white supremacist men. Proceed at your own risk: ~Current books which deals with this subject matter and the rise of racist pseudo science are: Superior: The Return of Race Science by Angela Saini & How to Argue With a Racist: History, Science, Race and Reality by Adam Rutherford. It explains the history of this unscientific viewpoint.~ Racism and transphobia passing as science. No surprise since this is the same racist that brought us The Bell Curve. This author is a conservative racist and white supremacist. no reviews | add a review
All people are equal but, as Human Diversity explores, all groups of people are not the same -- a fascinating investigation of the genetics and neuroscience of human differences. The thesis of Human Diversity is that advances in genetics and neuroscience are overthrowing an intellectual orthodoxy that has ruled the social sciences for decades. The core of the orthodoxy consists of three dogmas: gender is a social construct, race is a social construct, and class is a function of privilege. The problem is that all three dogmas are half-truths. They have stifled progress in understanding the rich texture that biology adds to our understanding of the social, political, and economic worlds we live in. It is not a story to be feared. "There are no monsters in the closet," Murray writes, "no dread doors we must fear opening." But it is a story that needs telling. Human Diversity does so without sensationalism, drawing on the most authoritative scientific findings, celebrating both our many differences and our common humanity. No library descriptions found. |
Current DiscussionsNonePopular covers
Google Books — Loading... GenresMelvil Decimal System (DDC)304.5Social sciences Social Sciences; Sociology and anthropology Factors affecting social behavior Genetic factorsLC ClassificationRatingAverage:
Is this you?Become a LibraryThing Author. |
As a politically liberal person, someone who thinks that it is wrong to beat-up those who think differently than you do, and a life scientist with some knowledge and interest in statistical analysis, genetics, and neuroscience, I don't see any problem with this book. It is an excellent survey of the data and it is punctuated by several very well done brief introductions to the terminology and basic ideas necessary to understand the discussions with statistics, genetics, and neuroanatomy in them. There is a short appendix that is an introduction to very basic statistical concepts. The author is even-handed and goes out of his way to include alternate points of view when he moves away from the data to their policy implications. He indicates the many areas where our knowledge is imperfect. He mentions his belief that any evaluation of human worth should be completely independent of the traits whose variance the book explicates and his support for universal basic income.
=====
[By the way, if you want to read another view of this kind of thing check: The Genetic Lottery by Kathryn Paige Harden. I gave it 5 stars.] ( )