On This Page
Description
Jack Tamerlaine hasn't stepped foot on Cadence in ten long years, content to study music at the mainland university. But when young girls start disappearing from the isle, Jack is summoned home to help find them. Enchantments run deep on Cadence: gossip is carried by the wind, plaid shawls can be as strong as armor, and the smallest cut of a knife can instill fathomless fear. The capricious spirits that rule the isle by fire, water, earth, and wind find mirth in the lives of the humans who show more call the land home. Adaira, heiress of the east and Jack's childhood enemy, knows the spirits only answer to a bard's music, and she hopes Jack can draw them forth by song, enticing them to return the missing girls. As Jack and Adaira reluctantly work together, they find they make better allies than rivals as their partnership turns into something more. But with each passing song, it becomes apparent the trouble with the spirits is far more sinister than they first expected, and an older, darker secret about Cadence lurks beneath the surface, threatening to undo them all. -- show lessTags
Recommendations
Member Recommendations
Member Reviews
{first in [[[Elements of Cadence]]] duology; fantasy, elemental spirits, romance, YA, adult, magic, enchantment, music, bard, laird}(2022)
Jack Tamerlaine is called back to the isle of Cadence after ten years of exile, learning music at the university on the mainland. He feels that he was banished at the age of eleven but the islanders on the east side of Cadence have been waiting for him to return to them as their bard to play for the elemental spirits which only live on Cadence. The spirits are capricious; they can compress four hills into one and five miles into one as you travel, if they're feeling benevolent - or the other way round for their own amusement.
Now his laird has requested his return, with his harp, as Jack is the only show more one who can play to summon the spirits; two little girls have gone missing, literally disappeared into thin air with no trace for trackers to find, and only the mischievous spirits could do that. The laird is in failing health and Jack has to work with the laird's daughter Adaira, Heiress of the East and his childhood nemesis, to call up the spirits.
I enjoyed this story which was somewhat reminiscent of [[Susan Dexter]]'s writing - one of my favourite authors. It is the first half of a duology but it ended at a natural pause and not on a cliff-hanger. I liked the gentle, sweet romances (yes, more than one) and appreciated there not being spicy scenes in my fantasy reading (but do be aware that there are a couple of bedroom scenes, though not steamy). I felt that the outline of the plot, though executed differently, was similar to that of [Divine Rivals], also by Ross; two young people who have traditionally been enemies find common ground (and romance) and have to work together (but then find that there are otherworldly powers and a larger picture involved).
I'm looking forward to the second book in this duology.
(August 2025)
4.5 stars show less
Jack Tamerlaine is called back to the isle of Cadence after ten years of exile, learning music at the university on the mainland. He feels that he was banished at the age of eleven but the islanders on the east side of Cadence have been waiting for him to return to them as their bard to play for the elemental spirits which only live on Cadence. The spirits are capricious; they can compress four hills into one and five miles into one as you travel, if they're feeling benevolent - or the other way round for their own amusement.
Now his laird has requested his return, with his harp, as Jack is the only show more one who can play to summon the spirits; two little girls have gone missing, literally disappeared into thin air with no trace for trackers to find, and only the mischievous spirits could do that. The laird is in failing health and Jack has to work with the laird's daughter Adaira, Heiress of the East and his childhood nemesis, to call up the spirits.
Adaira glanced across the room, her face solemn. “Two weeks ago, eight-year-old Eliza Elliott went missing on her walk home from school. We searched acres of land, from the school to her family’s croft, but we found little trace of her. Only a few places in the grass and heather, where it looked like she walked, only to vanish.” She paused, her eyes returning to his. “I’m sure you remember the ways of the isle, Jack.”In all these years Jack hasn't seen his mum, Mirin, who lives by herself near the clan line which divides the east side of Cadence from the west. Due to a long ago curse, in the east any magic done comes with a cost to the wielder's health but the west suffers from poor harvests and hard winters and so the Breccans of the west raid across the clan line for food for their families.
He did.
He remembered the perks as well as the dangers of straying from Cadence roads. The roads were pathways that resisted enchantments. The spirits couldn’t influence the roads, but they could toy with the grass and rocks and wind and water and trees of the isle. They could turn three hills into one, and one hill into four, but even then, there were ways of knowing the lay of the land, and which parts of it were prone to shift, and which landmarks remained fixed. Many children who didn’t know that secret map had gotten lost for hours if they wandered from the road.
“You believe the folk have tricked her?” Jack questioned.
Adaira nodded.
Jack could soon see firelight in the distance, escaping through closed shutters.There are multiple points of view in this story including that of Torin - nephew to Laird Alastair and captain of the East Guard who watch the clan line to defend the Tamerlaines from the Breccans - and of his wife, Sidra, who is a healer. This lets us see different facets of life on Cadence as well as the lives of different people while keeping the story flowing.
It drew him off the road, where he found the narrow path that wound to Mirin’s front yard as easily as if he had walked it yesterday, the grass whisking against his knees. The air smelled sweet from bog myrtle and sharp from smoke, which streamed from the chimney, smudging the stars.
All too soon, he reached the yard gate. Jack stepped inside it, his eyes sweeping the ground in the dim light. He could see row after row of vegetables, ripe from warm days. He remembered all the hours he had knelt in this soil as a boy, tilling and planting and harvesting. How he had complained about it, opposing everything Mirin had asked him to do.
He was stricken with nerves as he approached her door.
I enjoyed this story which was somewhat reminiscent of [[Susan Dexter]]'s writing - one of my favourite authors. It is the first half of a duology but it ended at a natural pause and not on a cliff-hanger. I liked the gentle, sweet romances (yes, more than one) and appreciated there not being spicy scenes in my fantasy reading (but do be aware that there are a couple of bedroom scenes, though not steamy). I felt that the outline of the plot, though executed differently, was similar to that of [Divine Rivals], also by Ross; two young people who have traditionally been enemies find common ground (and romance) and have to work together (but then find that there are otherworldly powers and a larger picture involved).
I'm looking forward to the second book in this duology.
(August 2025)
4.5 stars show less
Jack is from the magical isle of Cadence where the spirits empower the residents to create enchantments through their craft. Jack's mother was a weaver of some local fame but after Jack was born and no father was forthcoming, he grew up something of a social pariah. At the age of 10 he was sent away to the mainland to learn to be a bard. He came of age there isolated and embittered against his home, a place he was never fully accepted.
Now at the age of 20 he receives a summons from his Laird to return home. Once there he learns that young girls are being kidnapped and seem to be vanishing without a trace. Some fear that the faire folk have turned against the inhabitants of Cadence, but when it becomes clear that the abductor is mortal, show more suspicion turns to the age old rival clan from the West side of the island. Will Jack be able to help his old nemesis, Adaira, the Heiress of the East find the missing girls? And will Jack every be able to find a place in his troubled homeland? This is a beautiful and compelling story about secrets, feuds, bloodlines, and the true meaning of home.
The author has a rare gift to bring her characters to life. This is such a soft story about a people enslaved to their secrets. There is so much longing, regret and beauty in these pages. I found the story addictive even as I rolled my eyes in frustration at the character's inability to communicate. Although I can acknowledge some issues with the plotting, I still loved it and look forward to reading the next one. This would make a very satisfying beach read. show less
Now at the age of 20 he receives a summons from his Laird to return home. Once there he learns that young girls are being kidnapped and seem to be vanishing without a trace. Some fear that the faire folk have turned against the inhabitants of Cadence, but when it becomes clear that the abductor is mortal, show more suspicion turns to the age old rival clan from the West side of the island. Will Jack be able to help his old nemesis, Adaira, the Heiress of the East find the missing girls? And will Jack every be able to find a place in his troubled homeland? This is a beautiful and compelling story about secrets, feuds, bloodlines, and the true meaning of home.
The author has a rare gift to bring her characters to life. This is such a soft story about a people enslaved to their secrets. There is so much longing, regret and beauty in these pages. I found the story addictive even as I rolled my eyes in frustration at the character's inability to communicate. Although I can acknowledge some issues with the plotting, I still loved it and look forward to reading the next one. This would make a very satisfying beach read. show less
Yay, 5 brilliant stars ✨ for A River Enchanted by Rebecca Ross!
First, I have to say I have been a fan of Ross' from the beginning. 🤩 I can remember reading The Queen's Rising Duology and wondering why it wasn't more popular. It was so good and original. 🙌 I have since read both of her standalone books, Dreams Lie Beneath and Sisters of Sword and Song. And Now… I am finally reading the Elements of Cadence Duology! I'm also super excited to read her latest series, Letters of Enchantment, too. I've been seeing the first book in the series all over BookTok, and I'm just so happy that she's getting well-deserved recognition. 🥰
Lastly, I have to say it was so refreshing to read a fantasy that had some romance, but it was tasteful show more and lacked all of the unnecessary details that so many other books in the fantasy genre seem to have. 🙄
Okay, rant over…
I was captivated from the start. The story immersed me in a spellbinding Scottish fantasy world rich with themes of duty, love, family, and the transformative power of unity. The story unfolds on the island of Cadence, where Jack, a gifted bard, returns after years on the mainland to solve the mystery of missing girls. He aligns with Adaira, the clan heir, as they seek the assistance of elemental spirits through enchanting songs. But, an unfolding deal with their rivals, the Breccan clan, brings a shocking revelation and adds layers to an already intense situation.
The character development is so great. Jack is a blend of intelligence, bravery, creativity, and kindness. His journey from feeling like an outsider to finding his place with his family is compelling and relatable. His interactions with his sister, Frae, are heartwarming, reflecting a deep, tender bond. ❤️ Adaira embodies strength, independence, and bravery. The dynamics between Jack and Adaira are sweet and lovely; their chemistry and understanding of each other evolve beautifully throughout the story. ❣️
Torin, Sidra, and Maisie are other notable characters, each bringing their own complexities and charms to the narrative. Torin's internal struggle with his past and his gentle nature towards his family add depth to his character. Sidra, with her kindness and patience, complements the cast well.
This enchanting tale is a must-read for fans of fantasy, Scottish folklore, and rich character development. I must know what happens to these beloved characters and their eastern clan. Starting A Fire Endless now! 🤩 show less
First, I have to say I have been a fan of Ross' from the beginning. 🤩 I can remember reading The Queen's Rising Duology and wondering why it wasn't more popular. It was so good and original. 🙌 I have since read both of her standalone books, Dreams Lie Beneath and Sisters of Sword and Song. And Now… I am finally reading the Elements of Cadence Duology! I'm also super excited to read her latest series, Letters of Enchantment, too. I've been seeing the first book in the series all over BookTok, and I'm just so happy that she's getting well-deserved recognition. 🥰
Lastly, I have to say it was so refreshing to read a fantasy that had some romance, but it was tasteful show more and lacked all of the unnecessary details that so many other books in the fantasy genre seem to have. 🙄
Okay, rant over…
I was captivated from the start. The story immersed me in a spellbinding Scottish fantasy world rich with themes of duty, love, family, and the transformative power of unity. The story unfolds on the island of Cadence, where Jack, a gifted bard, returns after years on the mainland to solve the mystery of missing girls. He aligns with Adaira, the clan heir, as they seek the assistance of elemental spirits through enchanting songs. But, an unfolding deal with their rivals, the Breccan clan, brings a shocking revelation and adds layers to an already intense situation.
The character development is so great. Jack is a blend of intelligence, bravery, creativity, and kindness. His journey from feeling like an outsider to finding his place with his family is compelling and relatable. His interactions with his sister, Frae, are heartwarming, reflecting a deep, tender bond. ❤️ Adaira embodies strength, independence, and bravery. The dynamics between Jack and Adaira are sweet and lovely; their chemistry and understanding of each other evolve beautifully throughout the story. ❣️
Torin, Sidra, and Maisie are other notable characters, each bringing their own complexities and charms to the narrative. Torin's internal struggle with his past and his gentle nature towards his family add depth to his character. Sidra, with her kindness and patience, complements the cast well.
This enchanting tale is a must-read for fans of fantasy, Scottish folklore, and rich character development. I must know what happens to these beloved characters and their eastern clan. Starting A Fire Endless now! 🤩 show less
Let me preface this by saying that I have been in a reading slump for six months. Six. Months. And after picking up and putting down many books throughout the last few months, I finally thought I'd try a [a:Rebecca Ross|14926516|Rebecca Ross|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1655904642p2/14926516.jpg] novel. And I am so glad I did.
I have now picked up three of [a:Rebecca Ross|14926516|Rebecca Ross|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1655904642p2/14926516.jpg]'s novels. ([b:Dreams Lie Beneath|54557816|Dreams Lie Beneath|Rebecca show more Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1612846880l/54557816._SY75_.jpg|85125909], [b:The Queen's Rising|35098412|The Queen's Rising (The Queen’s Rising, #1)|Rebecca Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1498236653l/35098412._SY75_.jpg|46990492], and this one). While I ended up DNFing [b:The Queen's Rising|35098412|The Queen's Rising (The Queen’s Rising, #1)|Rebecca Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1498236653l/35098412._SY75_.jpg|46990492], [b:Dreams Lie Beneath|54557816|Dreams Lie Beneath|Rebecca Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1612846880l/54557816._SY75_.jpg|85125909] was a solid, four-star read. I finished this book, however, in five days, and it was an easy five-star. Every complaint I had about her first two books was fixed here. There were so many things about it that I loved.
1. THE ATMOSPHERE/WRITING
Atmosphere/setting will make or break a book for me. [b:A River Enchanted|58132544|A River Enchanted (Elements of Cadence, #1)|Rebecca Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1628605286l/58132544._SY75_.jpg|84776272] is easily one of the most romantic books I have read in a long time. Every time I opened this book, it felt like stepping into a lullaby: cozy, comforting, sweet, yet dark when necessary. Those are all things I love in books like this, and it was carried out in every area. Each and every character and landmark added to this feeling. Not to mention, the lore itself gave this book the energy of a Scottish folktale. And I loved it.
If you're confused at all about what I mean, take a journey over to Spotify and listen to the artist Eurielle, specifically her album "Arcadia". It felt a lot like that.
2. THE CHARACTERS
Each and every one of these characters was absolutely lovely. They all had unique voices, ambitions, dreams, and regrets. Though there were some I favored more than others, they all hold a special place in my heart now, and I can't wait to read more about them in [b:A Fire Endless|54326657|A Fire Endless (Elements of Cadence, #2)|Rebecca Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1665235394l/54326657._SY75_.jpg|84776444].
I can say without a doubt that Torin and Sidra were my two favorite characters in this book. Not because I relate to either of them at all, but because they felt the most real to me, the most personal. I was rooting for them every step of the way.
2. THE ROMANCES
HOOO BOY. THEY WERE SO GOOD. I couldn't get enough of these couples. Rarely do I see love portrayed in the quiet, sweet, yet persevering way it is here. I don't even know if that makes sense. But there was something about the way these characters related to each other, that made watching them fall in love even sweeter.
((Photo/Artistic credit: Flourishing Fables))
First of all, we have a classic "childhood enemies to lovers" romance. I am a sucker for tropes like this one, in which the characters have known each other for most of their lives, but do not fall in love until much later.
Now, Jack and Adaira were not my favorite romance in the book, but I was still rooting for them the whole way through. It was interesting to watch them fall in love, especially with the events of the book playing out the way they did.
My only complaint here is that it felt a little bit like Jack was far more in love with Adaira than she was with Jack... which I'd understand, but every time they had a **moment,** we were in his POV. So we never really got to see her in those situations.
((Photo/Artistic credit: Flourishing Fables))
Sidra and Torin were not just my favorite characters, but my favorite romance as well. By a mile. I don't read a lot of adult fiction, so I haven't gotten the chance to read a romance like this before, in which the couple is already married. However, the progression of their marriage and the way it intertwined with their character arcs was beautiful. I loved the way Sidra and Torin's relationship so beautifully exemplified unconditional, sacrificial love. It was like a breath of fresh air. 10/10 would recommend.
3. THE WORLDBUILDING
I don't even know what to say, other than it was great. Like I said above, the whole book felt like a Scottish fairytale. Some of the best world-building elements included:
- The wind spirits love to gossip. So any private conversation has to take place indoors, with the windows shut. Otherwise, you run the risk of the winds carrying the conversation and other people hearing it. However, this also means you can call someone by simply saying their name, and the wind will carry your message to them.
- Secrets can be woven into clothing, in order to create enchanted garments.
- Water, fire, wind, and earth spirits. NEED I SAY MORE.
Bonus: THE AUTHOR
I know this is a different thing, but the more I learn about Rebecca Ross, the more I appreciate her work. Not only does she take the time to write a message to her readers in the Goodreads reviews, but she also has a page on her website which lists EVERY CONTENT WARNING IN THIS BOOK, as well as the page numbers associated with them. I have never seen an author do something like that before, but as someone who has some very specific content preferences/triggers, I am absolutely in love with it.
In addition and also on her website, she has the link to a Spotify playlist with songs that inspired this book. Now, this one is something I have seen authors do in the past (including [a:Marissa Meyer|4684322|Marissa Meyer|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1558121336p2/4684322.jpg] and [a:Veronica Roth|4039811|Veronica Roth|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1702319133p2/4039811.jpg]), but I'm still here for it.
Things like this tell me that the author cares a lot about her readers. And that just makes reading her books all the more enjoyable, because I know that I'm reading from an author I respect.
IN CONCLUSION
This book is phenomenal. The characters, plot, world-building, romances, and atmosphere make it utterly re-readable. I can't wait to continue on with the series, and learn more about this world and the characters that inhabit it.
5/5 STARS. show less
"If she had been listening to the wind that morning, she might have heard the gossip it bore over the fells.But she had been preoccupied with the ghost of Torin's first love. "
I have now picked up three of [a:Rebecca Ross|14926516|Rebecca Ross|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1655904642p2/14926516.jpg]'s novels. ([b:Dreams Lie Beneath|54557816|Dreams Lie Beneath|Rebecca show more Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1612846880l/54557816._SY75_.jpg|85125909], [b:The Queen's Rising|35098412|The Queen's Rising (The Queen’s Rising, #1)|Rebecca Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1498236653l/35098412._SY75_.jpg|46990492], and this one). While I ended up DNFing [b:The Queen's Rising|35098412|The Queen's Rising (The Queen’s Rising, #1)|Rebecca Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1498236653l/35098412._SY75_.jpg|46990492], [b:Dreams Lie Beneath|54557816|Dreams Lie Beneath|Rebecca Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1612846880l/54557816._SY75_.jpg|85125909] was a solid, four-star read. I finished this book, however, in five days, and it was an easy five-star. Every complaint I had about her first two books was fixed here. There were so many things about it that I loved.
1. THE ATMOSPHERE/WRITING
Atmosphere/setting will make or break a book for me. [b:A River Enchanted|58132544|A River Enchanted (Elements of Cadence, #1)|Rebecca Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1628605286l/58132544._SY75_.jpg|84776272] is easily one of the most romantic books I have read in a long time. Every time I opened this book, it felt like stepping into a lullaby: cozy, comforting, sweet, yet dark when necessary. Those are all things I love in books like this, and it was carried out in every area. Each and every character and landmark added to this feeling. Not to mention, the lore itself gave this book the energy of a Scottish folktale. And I loved it.
If you're confused at all about what I mean, take a journey over to Spotify and listen to the artist Eurielle, specifically her album "Arcadia". It felt a lot like that.
2. THE CHARACTERS
Each and every one of these characters was absolutely lovely. They all had unique voices, ambitions, dreams, and regrets. Though there were some I favored more than others, they all hold a special place in my heart now, and I can't wait to read more about them in [b:A Fire Endless|54326657|A Fire Endless (Elements of Cadence, #2)|Rebecca Ross|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1665235394l/54326657._SY75_.jpg|84776444].
"He had always desired to prove himself worthy... to be wanted, to feel as if he belonged. /Music had once given that to him. A home, a purpose."
I can say without a doubt that Torin and Sidra were my two favorite characters in this book. Not because I relate to either of them at all, but because they felt the most real to me, the most personal. I was rooting for them every step of the way.
2. THE ROMANCES
HOOO BOY. THEY WERE SO GOOD. I couldn't get enough of these couples. Rarely do I see love portrayed in the quiet, sweet, yet persevering way it is here. I don't even know if that makes sense. But there was something about the way these characters related to each other, that made watching them fall in love even sweeter.
((Photo/Artistic credit: Flourishing Fables))
"She had never seen this expression on Adaira's face before, as if all the longings within her had gathered into one place."
First of all, we have a classic "childhood enemies to lovers" romance. I am a sucker for tropes like this one, in which the characters have known each other for most of their lives, but do not fall in love until much later.
Now, Jack and Adaira were not my favorite romance in the book, but I was still rooting for them the whole way through. It was interesting to watch them fall in love, especially with the events of the book playing out the way they did.
My only complaint here is that it felt a little bit like Jack was far more in love with Adaira than she was with Jack... which I'd understand, but every time they had a **moment,** we were in his POV. So we never really got to see her in those situations.
((Photo/Artistic credit: Flourishing Fables))
"'I have been with you all this time,' she said, a soft answer that eased his rigid posture, 'The good as well as the bad. Once we were acquaintances sharing a vow. But you have become more to me than mere words spoken on a midsummer night. And I have never been one to love conditionally.'"
Sidra and Torin were not just my favorite characters, but my favorite romance as well. By a mile. I don't read a lot of adult fiction, so I haven't gotten the chance to read a romance like this before, in which the couple is already married. However, the progression of their marriage and the way it intertwined with their character arcs was beautiful. I loved the way Sidra and Torin's relationship so beautifully exemplified unconditional, sacrificial love. It was like a breath of fresh air. 10/10 would recommend.
3. THE WORLDBUILDING
I don't even know what to say, other than it was great. Like I said above, the whole book felt like a Scottish fairytale. Some of the best world-building elements included:
- The wind spirits love to gossip. So any private conversation has to take place indoors, with the windows shut. Otherwise, you run the risk of the winds carrying the conversation and other people hearing it. However, this also means you can call someone by simply saying their name, and the wind will carry your message to them.
- Secrets can be woven into clothing, in order to create enchanted garments.
- Water, fire, wind, and earth spirits. NEED I SAY MORE.
Bonus: THE AUTHOR
I know this is a different thing, but the more I learn about Rebecca Ross, the more I appreciate her work. Not only does she take the time to write a message to her readers in the Goodreads reviews, but she also has a page on her website which lists EVERY CONTENT WARNING IN THIS BOOK, as well as the page numbers associated with them. I have never seen an author do something like that before, but as someone who has some very specific content preferences/triggers, I am absolutely in love with it.
In addition and also on her website, she has the link to a Spotify playlist with songs that inspired this book. Now, this one is something I have seen authors do in the past (including [a:Marissa Meyer|4684322|Marissa Meyer|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1558121336p2/4684322.jpg] and [a:Veronica Roth|4039811|Veronica Roth|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1702319133p2/4039811.jpg]), but I'm still here for it.
Things like this tell me that the author cares a lot about her readers. And that just makes reading her books all the more enjoyable, because I know that I'm reading from an author I respect.
IN CONCLUSION
This book is phenomenal. The characters, plot, world-building, romances, and atmosphere make it utterly re-readable. I can't wait to continue on with the series, and learn more about this world and the characters that inhabit it.
5/5 STARS. show less
“Sometimes he imagined, becoming a traveling bard, who drank lore and spun it into song. He imagined gathering stories and reawakening places that were half dead and forgotten. And he wondered if remaining at the university, held within stone and glass and structure, was more akin to being a bird, held captive in an iron cage. But these were dangerous thoughts” (49).
This is a bewitching story full of lyrical, pretty prose and told in four elemental parts. It’s vividly enchanting, and as someone who’s drawn more to character development than to plot, I was certainly carried away by the captivating events that unfold—beginning with a fearful ferryman and a prodigal bard crossing the capricious sea at night “when the spirits of show more the water are easily appeased” (8). This has all the elements of an epic adventure, a true hero’s (and heroine’s) journey: magical artifacts and whimsical gods (or folk as they’re called) and historical feuds and well-kept secrets and complicated romance.
Jack, a bard who’s been studying on the mainland for a decade, returns to the isle of his childhood after an ambiguous summons from his Laird. As an only child to a single mother never knowing his father, Jack always felt like an outsider growing up on the Isle of Cadence, never feeling like he belonged. When he returns, though, and learns about the strange disappearance of young girls, he becomes the center of the island’s hope for their return and learns that maybe he’s belonged to these people and this place a little more than he once thought. Along the way and through their perspectives, Jack and Adaira (the Laird’s only heiress and Jack’s childhood nemesis), Torin (the captain of the guard and Adaira’s protective cousin) and Sidra (a natural healer and Torin’s second wife) all deal with the cycle of hate and violence that’s brought about these kidnappings, including coming to terms with the sins of their mothers and fathers, atoning for their part in the cycle of hate and violence, and hanging on to faith when it seems that all hope is lost.
This is a four-star read for me. I really didn’t know this was a duology, and I hate duologies. I want my full story in a single book. I can do a series if each book focuses on a different character. But cliffhangers? No thanks! If you’re good with a story continuation, and you like magical realism and adventure and lyrical prose, this might be the perfect January read for you. show less
This is a bewitching story full of lyrical, pretty prose and told in four elemental parts. It’s vividly enchanting, and as someone who’s drawn more to character development than to plot, I was certainly carried away by the captivating events that unfold—beginning with a fearful ferryman and a prodigal bard crossing the capricious sea at night “when the spirits of show more the water are easily appeased” (8). This has all the elements of an epic adventure, a true hero’s (and heroine’s) journey: magical artifacts and whimsical gods (or folk as they’re called) and historical feuds and well-kept secrets and complicated romance.
Jack, a bard who’s been studying on the mainland for a decade, returns to the isle of his childhood after an ambiguous summons from his Laird. As an only child to a single mother never knowing his father, Jack always felt like an outsider growing up on the Isle of Cadence, never feeling like he belonged. When he returns, though, and learns about the strange disappearance of young girls, he becomes the center of the island’s hope for their return and learns that maybe he’s belonged to these people and this place a little more than he once thought. Along the way and through their perspectives, Jack and Adaira (the Laird’s only heiress and Jack’s childhood nemesis), Torin (the captain of the guard and Adaira’s protective cousin) and Sidra (a natural healer and Torin’s second wife) all deal with the cycle of hate and violence that’s brought about these kidnappings, including coming to terms with the sins of their mothers and fathers, atoning for their part in the cycle of hate and violence, and hanging on to faith when it seems that all hope is lost.
This is a four-star read for me. I really didn’t know this was a duology, and I hate duologies. I want my full story in a single book. I can do a series if each book focuses on a different character. But cliffhangers? No thanks! If you’re good with a story continuation, and you like magical realism and adventure and lyrical prose, this might be the perfect January read for you. show less
Overall, a very sweet and enchanting story. This is for the girls who always thought Merida from Brave was an under-appreciated Disney princess. The main romance is very childhood rivals to begrudging allies to lovers, which is always fun, but the secondary characters, Torin and Sidra, really outshone the MCs. I felt they had a lot more depth to their history and their commitment to one another. Sidra is definitely my favorite character, and her arc is wonderful. Her relationship with the spirits and their dynamic with the world is fascinating, and I would love to see more of that.
This one is only shy of 5-stars because it lacked a certain tension to the plot? Everyone gets along for the most part, aside from the East/West conflict. And show more even that conflict is woefully binary and under-developed. I suspect the second novel in the series will further explore why the West is so violent, but even the twist ending didn't really explain the actions of some of the characters' from the West. But still an overall great read! show less
This one is only shy of 5-stars because it lacked a certain tension to the plot? Everyone gets along for the most part, aside from the East/West conflict. And show more even that conflict is woefully binary and under-developed. I suspect the second novel in the series will further explore why the West is so violent, but even the twist ending didn't really explain the actions of some of the characters' from the West. But still an overall great read! show less
I enjoyed this book; it’s atmospheric, set in an isolated island community where nature spirits are very present and affect the residents and the world around them. The island is divided in half due to a past tragedy, and those on either side are sworn enemies. When young girls start disappearing from the east, Jack is called home from the mainland where he’s studying music to help figure out the mystery.
The romance is an important plot point, but it’s not the main focus like a SJM or Yarros book – which I liked! If you want spicy adult fantasy this isn’t it, but it was sweet and whimsical and I thought it was perfect.
I would have enjoyed a bit deeper world building and it was pretty slow paced, but I overall I loved this show more first book in the duology. I think a lot of people went into this expecting enemies-to-lovers, fast pacing, adult romance, and that’s why some people came out of it feeling bored or dissatisfied. If you want a softer, more ethereal story, something that’s a bit more focused and intimate, slow pacing and sweet relationships and romances, then this is perfect.
Pros: Cozy, whimsical, atmospheric. Magic is a part of their lives but doesn’t rule them. Scottish inspired, makes you feel like the Highland mist is creeping across the moor.
Cons: World building seems to stop at the island’s edge. Also, how big is this island? Big enough to house two competing clans/societies, but it feels like characters can traverse the whole thing in a day?
A bit predictable but a very cozy read with light romance. I’d give this one a 3.75/5. show less
The romance is an important plot point, but it’s not the main focus like a SJM or Yarros book – which I liked! If you want spicy adult fantasy this isn’t it, but it was sweet and whimsical and I thought it was perfect.
I would have enjoyed a bit deeper world building and it was pretty slow paced, but I overall I loved this show more first book in the duology. I think a lot of people went into this expecting enemies-to-lovers, fast pacing, adult romance, and that’s why some people came out of it feeling bored or dissatisfied. If you want a softer, more ethereal story, something that’s a bit more focused and intimate, slow pacing and sweet relationships and romances, then this is perfect.
Pros: Cozy, whimsical, atmospheric. Magic is a part of their lives but doesn’t rule them. Scottish inspired, makes you feel like the Highland mist is creeping across the moor.
Cons: World building seems to stop at the island’s edge. Also, how big is this island? Big enough to house two competing clans/societies, but it feels like characters can traverse the whole thing in a day?
A bit predictable but a very cozy read with light romance. I’d give this one a 3.75/5. show less
Members
- Recently Added By
Lists
Books Read in 2022
5,164 works; 113 members
Books Read in 2023
5,547 works; 145 members
mom
729 works; 1 member
TBR of Books I Don't Own
132 works; 1 member
Author Information
Awards and Honors
Awards
Distinctions
Kirkus Reviews Starred Review (December 15 – 2021)
Booklist Starred Review (February 15 – 2022)
Series
Common Knowledge
- Canonical title
- A River Enchanted
Classifications
Statistics
- Members
- 2,285
- Popularity
- 8,670
- Reviews
- 34
- Rating
- (4.00)
- Languages
- 6 — English, French, German, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish
- Media
- Paper, Audiobook, Ebook
- ISBNs
- 21
- ASINs
- 6

























































