Cut from the Same Cloth: American Women of Myth, Legend, and Tall Tale

You've maybe heard the tall tales of Mike Fink, but how about Sal Fink? This is a wonderful, well-researched collection of 15 myths, legends, and tall tales, each featuring women of North America. Tales are categorized by region: Women of the Northeast, The South made up of three African American stories, The Midwest, The Southwest including a Pueblo and a Mexican American tale, and The West including a story from the Miwok nation, an Eskimo tale, and a Hawaiian story. Each story is just the right length for a quick story time sharing. Brian Pinkney's scratch board illustrations suit the feel of the collection beautifully. A wonderful choice for classrooms studying traditional literature while wanting to avoid an all-male representation show more of tall tale heroics. show less

Tbh, I'm personally not a fan of woodcut style art, or dialect. I'm not sure pourquoi stories were a good fit, either; I was hoping for a focus on the Tall Tale type of story like Annie Christmas. I appreciate the good intentions and the research that went into this, but it just doesn't quite work for me and I don't feel comfortable recommending it either... just like any sampler, there will be stronger and weaker pieces.

Cut From the Same Cloth features fifteen stories--myth, legend, and tall tale--about women from around the United States, (including the Arctic and Hawaii). The interesting consideration for this book is that American women are celebrated for their contribution of helping to settle this New World. Jane Yolen writes in the Introduction to the book, :We have all helped make [women] mute, forgetting to tell their magic stories or, even worse, gifting their fathers and brothers and sons with their heroic deeds. Robert San Souci, [the author], is one of a hardy band of pioneers who have been rescuing the silent women, giving them back their tongues." One story that caught my attention was Annie Christmas, an African American woman who owned show more and operated a keelboat on the Mississippi River. Annie was a big, strong woman, reminiscent of John Henry. In this story, Annie saves the passengers on a steamboat after much dialogue with the hard-headed captain. Her efforts, in the end, prove overtaxing to her heart and she dies the next day. The concept that grabs my attention is that a black woman, who throughout most of history is considered the low of the lows, is a heroine and savior of a group of wealthy, white people. show less

american tales of strong women, San Souci excellent storyteller

american tales