The Sisters of Book Row

3.5

I really wanted to enjoy this one—the historical context was clearly well-researched and added an interesting backdrop to the story. I also love stories about sisters and how important family is to overcome life's difficulties. Unfortunately, it ultimately fell flat for me. I struggled to connect with the characters, which made it difficult to fully invest in their journeys or root for any particular outcome.

The pacing was also a challenge. For much of the book, I found myself unsure of where the plot was heading, and around the 40% mark, I seriously considered putting it down altogether because it felt like the story wasn’t progressing in a meaningful way. At times, the writing itself pulled me out of the story. It almost felt show more like watching a video that suddenly turns into an ad—you start to notice the buzzwords and phrasing, and it feels more forced than natural. Instead of enhancing the narrative, those moments made it harder to stay immersed and connected. I honestly think it would be a been a better book if it just focused on one sister instead of trying to have an equal narrative about each of them.

While there were elements of promise, especially in the setting and historical details, the lack of strong character connection, clear direction, and authentic voice made this a lackluster read overall.

I received a copy from William Morrow via NetGalley. A positive review is not required & all opinions are my own. show less

This was one of those books that I fell into, and really struggled to put down. The story of three young adult sisters running a bookshelf in New York City in the midst of the Comstock era grabbed my attention, especially with the parallels to things going on in the US today. I devoured the book within a few days, and would love to see a sequel that continues their stories. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the free e-book in exchange for an honest review.

It was pretty difficult to have a bookstore with the Comstock Act of 1873 that restricted literature that was "obscene," "lewd," or "lascivious."

They would conduct raids on bookstores to see if there was anything that should be published or sold.

The Applebaum sisters had their bookstore since they were children and inherited it from their father. Their bookstore was in Book Row in Manhattan, New York, a few blocks from Union Square and Astor Place.

Each sister had her job in the store, but Celia had a secret one that could get her and her sisters in trouble.

Celia was working with an underground press, and was always on edge.

Can they keep their bookstore safe?

I was not aware of this act and looked up information about it.

Book lovers and show more historical fiction readers will enjoy this book and will also enjoy the characters. 4/5

Thank you to the publisher for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own. show less