On This Page
Description
Francis Pettigrew travels to Exmoor for a holiday with his wife-an area in which as a young boy he was traumatized by coming across a dead body on the moor. In an attempt to exorcise this trauma, Pettigrew walks across the moor to the place where the incident occurred-only to find another dead body. Moreover, when he returns to the scene with the police, the body is gone. Did he really see a body, or is it a hallucination conjured up by his return to the scene of the crime that has haunted show more him since childhood? In Untimely Death, Cyril Hare conjures up an intriguing puzzle whose twists and turns will keep listeners on the edge of their seats until the final surprising resolution. show lessTags
Recommendations
Member Reviews
In an attempt to lay the ghost of a traumatic event in his childhood, Francis Pettigrew travels to Exmoor and the site where he found a dead body 50 years previously only to find another one. By the time he reaches help and returns to the spot with police, the body has gone. I found the book slow moving, and the humour was a tad annoying but overall I enjoyed it, particularly the legal aspect.
I can't remember why I picked this one up, especially seeing it's the end of the series. That said, it was a fun and quick murder mystery that largely takes place in a court room. I'd say the cover is a big spoiler though.
I didn't much care for this narrator. He didn't put much emotion into it and the straight read made it hard to determine who was who sometimes. Interesting mystery, with a great conclusion!
This is the last in the series and I'm getting the hang of 'Whodunnit' - I guessed the method and timing of the murder and was feeling quite pleased with myself until the real murder was revealed! Again details of law were involved but not as obscure as in previous entries in this series.
Hare's lawyer detective and his young wife return to stay in a farmhouse on the edge of Exmoor where he had stayed as a boy. While out riding a pony, he sees what appears to be a corpse; his pony bolts, when he returns the corpse is gone --but he recalls having seen a body in the same place many years before. Meanwhile other mysterious events are happening --a man is paying a late night visit to the daughter of the couple who run the farm. Note this story is dedicated to Michael Gilbert, another skilled writer of British legal mysteries I like.
Francis Pettigrew finds a dead body on the moor while he and his wife are on holiday at Exmoor. However, the body is gone by the time he gets back with help. Another dead body is discovered on the moor two days later, but this person had died just that morning.
The mystery of just exactly when did the deceased die is linked to a inheritance of a nearby estate.
The mystery of just exactly when did the deceased die is linked to a inheritance of a nearby estate.
I am sure that I have read this before (say 25-30 years ago) but I had no inkling of a memory during this reread. I was glad to see Inspector Mallett, now retired, in this final book.
Members
- Recently Added By
Lists
Anthony Boucher's Best Crime Fiction of the Year
115 works; 5 members
Author Information
Some Editions
Awards and Honors
Distinctions
Series
Belongs to Publisher Series
Perennial Library (P514)
Work Relationships
Common Knowledge
- Canonical title*
- Er hätte später sterben sollen
- Original title
- He Should Have Died Hereafter
- Alternate titles
- Untimely Death
- Original publication date
- 1957
- People/Characters
- Francis Pettigrew; Eleanor Pettigrew; Mr. Joliffe; Edna Joliffe Gorman; Hester Greenway; Mr. Olding (show all 12); Tom Gorman; Percy Percy; Inspector Mallett; Dick Gorman; Mr. Manktelow; Justice Pomeroy
- Important places
- Exmoor, Somerset / Devon, England
- Dedication
- To Michael Gilbert
- First words
- The holiday had been Eleanor's idea in the first place.
- Last words
- (Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)The ghosts were gone from Bolter's Tussock.
- Original language
- English
- Disambiguation notice
- originally published in the UK as 'He Should Have Died Hereafter'
*Some information comes from Common Knowledge in other languages. Click "Edit" for more information.
Classifications
Statistics
- Members
- 232
- Popularity
- 140,717
- Reviews
- 8
- Rating
- (3.75)
- Languages
- English, German, Japanese, Russian
- Media
- Paper, Audiobook, Ebook
- ISBNs
- 14
- ASINs
- 11































































