Heraclitus: The Cosmic Fragments
by Heraclitus
On This Page
Description
This work provides a text and an extended study of those fragments of Heraclitus' philosophical utterances whose subject is the world as a whole rather than man and his part in it. Professor Kirk discusses fully the fragments which he finds genuine and treats in passing others that were generally accepted as genuine but here considered paraphrased or spurious. In securing his text, Professor Kirk has taken into account all the ancient testimonies, and in his critical work he attached show more particular importance to the context in which each fragment is set. To each he gives a selective apparatus, a literal translation and and an extended commentary in which problems of textual and philosophical criticism are discussed. Ancient accounts of Heraclitus were inadequate and misleading, and as Kirk wrote, understanding was often hindered by excessive dogmatism and a selective use of the fragments. Professor Kirk's method is critical and objective, and his 1954 work marks a significant advance in the study of Presocratic thought. show lessTags
Recommendations
Member Reviews
I am not really a fit person to leave a review of this book, except to say that I think it is of primary interest to the reader of Greek. It takes a very close look at issues of translation and provenance. The fragmentary natures of Heraclitus' surviving writings requires such an approach, but for those of us who do not have the time or the knowledge to participate in rich, textual/linguistic analysis, this is somewhat wasted. I read it because it is said that Heraclitus inspired Jonathan Bowden. Someone like me is better off with a much shorter work - the Penguin Classics Early Greek Philosophy is probably better. With that said, I am saddened at the thought that there can be very few people left in British universities who understand show more or care about books like this. Soon there will be even fewer. When the link breaks between us and our classical past, the chain of European identify is broken too. So a valuable book, I am sure, but less so to a casual reader such as myself. Perhaps I will learn ancient Greek! show less
Didn’t understand it. Will read again later!
Members
- Recently Added By
Lists
The Luca Guadagnino Universe
62 works; 1 member
Author Information
Classifications
Statistics
- Members
- 48
- Popularity
- 624,082
- Reviews
- 2
- Rating
- (3.67)
- Languages
- English, Greek
- Media
- Paper
- ISBNs
- 3
- ASINs
- 1

























































