300 years ago Brumfitt Kings moved to a small island on the border of Maine and Nova Scotia, somewhere in the nowhere land between the US and Canada. It starts as a seasonal job, then he remains behind while everyone gets back and then he decides to stay forever. He starts to write a diary and to paint - the diary will provide the stories for his descendants, the paintings will be "discovered" by the art world and make the current generation comfortably well-off. And it seems like the ocean and Brumfitt had made a deal - because the family can always catch the biggest and best lobsters. But they pay a price - a son is always lost in the water - one way or another.

By the time we meet his descendants, they are the biggest lobstermen on the small Loosewood Island. Woody, the patriarch is still a lobsterman at heart, despite the painting allowing him other choices and his oldest daughter, Cordelia, is as interested in it as he is.

The novel moves between the diary of Brumfitt, descriptions of his paintings (from Cordelia), the back story of the current generation and the now and here of the life on the island - where lobstermen from the neighboring islands and the mainland are trying the steal the catch of the island's families and drugs are finally hitting the peaceful community. Well, relatively peaceful.

Each of those stories have its own heartbreak and beauty. Not everything is beautiful and there is no character who is completely innocent or good - this is real life after all, not one's idealized version of it. There is romance and death, there is beauty and there are a lot of descriptions about the lobster trade and how the lobster fishing works. And then there is that war with the neighbors - fueled both by drugs and by the desire for more lobsters.

The novel is inspired by King Lear but it is neither a retelling, nor it is based on it. The patriarch of the family and the three daughters are all there but it does not follow the trajectory of the Bard's tragedy - in a way it is the opposite of it. Woody Kings' way is not to split evenly - instead he gives each daughter what she needs - a house for one, a job for another, a job for a partner when needed. He still dies but without the regrets and bitterness (and even if the daughters are not always best friends, the acrimony and hate of the play are just not there). If one pays attention, they may notice the rest of Lear's cast - they are there, under names similar enough to recognize. And if one expects this to be a Lear retelling, it won't work for them. If I had not read King Lear a few days earlier, I probably would have missed at least half of the nods to it. And that would have been ok.

I liked this novel a lot more than I expected to. The fact that it was not a retelling of the play actually worked for it better than I expected - it allowed the author to allow his characters to get out of the evil/good roles and be just people. It is a novel of a place and a occupation - the people in it were almost unimportant. It did not really matter that there were no real positive characters (even the narrator Cordelia managed to do things that could have landed her in jail...) or that we never hear all the backstories. They fit the story of the island, a story told in the old pictures, in the memories and in the main story. And there is even a hint of magic out there -- how much one wants to believe in it is up to them.

I am not sure if the novel will work for most people - it is definitely not perfect but it is the kind of imperfect that made it work for me. And this positive end that tied all kinds of lose threads without a happy end just added to the weirdness to the novel. In a good way. ( )

I really liked this book. It tells the story of a lobster fishing family, their sibling and parental relationships, and even has a little touch of the mystical. Well written, a strong female main character, good dialog.....an enjoyable read. ( )

To be fair - I did not finish this book. Stopped less than half. A REAL BUMMER. WAY TOO DEPRESSING!

Very well written however - just not for me. ( )

I seem to have an affinity for stories situated in the Maritime provinces, even though I have only ever been to PEI. Something about the simple yet often dangerous way of life and the remoteness from many modern conveniences makes for engrossing stories and fantastic characters.

The setting for this novel is more recent than most I have read, and yet the way of life still retains many aspects that are centuries old. I felt that the characters were well developed and the family relationships rang true. I didn't love the last little bit where things got very intense, but I still loved this novel! ( )

A book that promises much and fails to deliver. The depiction of the lobster fishing I enjoyed, discovering a world far from where I live, the prairies. The romance was tepid to hackneyed, and the references to King Lear while interesting, inevitably, this novel pales by comparison. ( )