William M. Kelso

A popular account of how the archaeological work of the last generation has given us a new understanding of the English colony at Jamestown, Virginia. I'm not as impressed as some people but Kelso does tell the story of his work on the site with great verve.

From 2007 publishing date on verso t.p., this looks like an early effort; in fact, this was the author's first novel. The author has given us a workmanlike story but style is that of a beginner but with flashes of talent. I'd like to read a later effort to compare author's growth. I call this a "what-if" novel; the author has given us a scenario setting out what might have happened if the Romans had won the Battle of Teutoberg Forest.

A young man, Gaius, joins the staff of Governor Varus, show more who rules Germania Magna. He is tasked with bringing back the rebel guerrilla Arminius. He does meet Arminius but is unsuccessful in bringing back the Eagle of the 18th. Gaius also hopes to reunite with his long-lost brother, Marcus. There is much treachery involving a civilian merchant and a rogue centurion as well as Arminius. There is a climactic battle with Arminius' forces, in which the Romans are aided by another German tribe. Much later the author has produced a novel with the same title; this is a completely different novel. Not having read any subsequent novels yet I wondered if the Marcus in the later novels will be Gaius' nephew and if you could call this novel a sort-of prequel.

Proofing was poor; love interest was earnest but awkward. Some incidents seemed far-fetched and characters were all either completely good or dripping with evil. Varus was just feckless. I'm glad the author avoided the dominus/domine problem by the use of the word Sir. I appreciate the author's efforts; he certainly gave us a readable and riveting story. show less

Dr. Kelso has done dug up the real Jamestown! Here is his report in a highly readable book with tons of photos from the dig. This book should be at the top of the list for anyone interested in reading about Jamestown.

Dr. Kelso has done dug up the real Jamestown! Here is his report in a highly readable book with tons of photos from the dig. This book should be at the top of the list for anyone interested in reading about Jamestown.