Mark Dowie

Not at all an unbiased reporting but interesting anyway, as a lens into one perspective.

Haida Gwaii is such an easy case (geographically isolated, no overlapping land claims, strategically minor) compared to the rest of BC and yet is still so complex. Zero ink given to the possibility that parallel government structures will fatally weaken the province / Canada. I know the book predates Trump's rhetoric but this should always be a consideration when adjusting power structures.

Random thoughts show more while reading
* "better than killing them" defense of slavery (slave descendents segregated to this day!) is pretty ballsy
* don't the love the "some people say" dabbling in smallpox conspiracy
* seems inconsistent to rail against the legitimacy of religous proclamations while depending on later crown proclamations as legal evidence - the latter follows largely from the former if you aren't going with "might makes right'
* it was fine for tribes to fight each other to establish territory but suddenly those borders are frozen in time
* repeated references to the Haida being "undefeated" as relevant... like, we could revisit that in pretty short order but I feel like that is not the desired outcome?
* the support here for hereditary wealth seems at odds with general left wing thinking
* I do like the environmental outcome of this treaty but that's a pretty big hammer for that purpose (and ultimately futile if it significantly weakens the power/unity of the province) show less

OK. This is, granted not a book that is going to appeal to everyone. While it is not something that often shows up on the blog I have long had a passion for anthropological issues and Native American history so this book certainly piqued my interest. It’s been a bit since I sat in my college classes (ah-hem) and I am no scholar but that does not mean a title can’t be accessible to some schlub sitting in a yurt in Montana.

If you have the slightest interest in Native sovereignty or Native show more issues do not be afraid that this book will be written like a textbook. It is not. Mr. Dowie presents the material in a remarkably down to earth manner. I actually found myself turning the pages as if I were reading a fiction book anxious to reach the ending. He breaks down complicated issues into eminently readable chapters about how the Haida Gwaii started, thrived, were decimated by smallpox, recovered and then one day were told they were citizens of Canada whether they liked it or not.

There are chapters at the front of the book and at the end of the book that deal solely with the history of the Haida Gwaii peoples and then how they fought for their sovereignty. In the middle of those chapters is a primer on the European conquest of well, the world and how they treated the Native populations they encountered. I was particularly fond (not) of the tale of the Spanish landing in what is now South America, loudly proclaiming their intentions to those they met and then killing them for not immediately answering back in a language they neither understood nor spoke.

Greed is good?

The book certainly makes you want to go back and revisit what you learned in high school because if you are like me you will come out after reading this book feeling a little bit disgusted with well, let’s just call it Manifest Destiny. None of this can effectively be righted but we can at the least read our history with a little more honesty.

OK – off of the soapbox and back to the book. It certainly left me with feelings of hope for other First Peoples. The Haida Gwaii are willing share their efforts to achieve what some of them never really thought they had lost in the first place. But when a nation tells you that your land is now under its dominion and you must now do things a certain way, issues are going to arise. The people who worked tirelessly for years to allow for a level of sovereignty, if not independence do not want acclaim, in fact they didn’t want personal notoriety, only to be part of a whole nation – sovereign.

It’s a very interesting book. I read it over the course of three evenings. It has given me a lot to think about. It’s well footnoted, lots of appendices and there are several other books I’ll be looking to acquire for later reading. show less

Looks very interesting, but I am currently too disheartened by the crimes of my culture against others to finish reading it. Not a"West bad, natives good" position, but just discouraged by how badly our culture is screwing up.

An analysis of the formation of American environmentalism and historical imperatives. Discusses the inspirations of Thoreau, Muir, Marshal and Carson and the social antagonisms created in response that climaxed with the election of Ronald Reagan.