4H

Should Hilary have told the police about the new letter or be arranging to meet the letter writer on her own?

Close on being a TSTL moment. She should have taken the letter straight to Nelson so that the police could catch the perpetrator.
I don't think she's in danger, per se, because I don't think the letter writer is the killer, but the letters need to stop, and the only way for that to happen is for the police to catch that person and bring charges.

I agree another TSTL moment. I think Father Hennessey is the letter writer. Hilary should have told the police and should not go to the meeting. At least the police will be watching.

Our TSTL moment has arrived!! What is wrong with these people's heads? A murderer is on the loose and possibly sending me letters so I'm going to go meet him at O'dark thirty??? Really?????

I can't add anything more than you all. Definitely a TSTL moment.

Either TSTL or an attempt at manipulating Ruth for some obscure reason I can't figure out.

Definitely a TSTL moment.