5F

Did you ever suspect Justin of being the letter writer?

No. I didn't think it was him because I thought he wouldn't have known about Nelson and Ruth. Never surmised that Cathbad had told him.

No. Like Eadie, I didn't consider Cathbad would have told Justin about Nelson. I have to say, I was very disappointed in Cathbad for betraying a confidence in that way: I didn't think he was the type.

I thought Justin was the killer not the letter writer. Shame on Cathbad! That was a major betrayal of Harry's trust.

I thought Justin was the murderer and Robin more likely the letter writer. Apparently Cathbad is a gossip, which doesn't fit with our favorite character. Maybe he thought it was safe since Justin didn't know Ruth or Harry.

Never expected him to be the writer. Very out of character for Cathbad to tell on Ruth and Nelson.

Sometimes, I think these authors don't know their characters as well as we readers do...!

>7 Sergeirocks: Or they are just trying to shake us up:)

They just use them to do what they need them to do even if it's out of character.

>7 Sergeirocks: Lol! Isn't that the truth!

I never even considered Justin as the letter writer.