1Q

What is your initial provisional rating? Why?

3 stars. It would have been higher if less graphic in descriptions of the bodies.

I'm starting at 3. I'm definitely okay with going higher if the plot continues to be this interesting.

I'll start at 3.25 but I know it will probably go higher next time around.

I'll start with 3. It will probably go higher as we get more into the story.

Think I will start with 3.5 because has certainly hooked me into the character and storyline.

Starting at 3.25 -- would have been 3.5 except for that weirdness in Chapter 11.

I'm starting at 3.5 stars. A very strong start (notwithstanding chapter 11)

I'm going to be conservative with a 3 to start.

I'll start with 3.5 as well. I have no issue with weird stuff like chapter 11 as long as it ties in properly in the end.