5P

What was your final rating for the book? Why?

I'm ending at 3.75. I might have gone to 4 if not for Nonna and Gray's father...and that disappearing library...but those things left me dissatisfied with the ending.

I'm giving it a 5 as I loved the story and Rollins' writing was excellent.

I'm giving it a 4. It was better reading it with a group. The first time I read it I only gave it a 3.

Only 4, because I found some parts quite predictable.

I ended with a 4. I enjoyed it but will have forgotten it by the time we get to the next one.

I will end up with a 4.5 rating, like Carol this is higher for the Group Read - when I read it previously I gave it 4 Stars.