1Andrew-theQM
When Ruth woke up a big Black Dog was in front of her and Michelle. Did this help in your thinking of what was going on?
3Sergeirocks
If it was the dog, it had to be Paul.
4Olivermagnus
I agree. If the dog was there, so was Paul.
6ColinMichaelFelix
Simply no. I always thought Paul was acquainted with the dog as well as Chloe. But I kept waiting for David to show up as a bad guy.
7threadnsong
I thought it added to the mystery of the Black Shuck and trying to use the dog to terrorize the two women. As far as who did it, I was not sure whether it was Chloe or Paul.

