5C

When Ruth woke up a big Black Dog was in front of her and Michelle. Did this help in your thinking of what was going on?

I know who the dog was and that Paul had the dog guard Ruth and Michelle.

If it was the dog, it had to be Paul.

I agree. If the dog was there, so was Paul.

Same with me. It had to be Paul.

Simply no. I always thought Paul was acquainted with the dog as well as Chloe. But I kept waiting for David to show up as a bad guy.

I thought it added to the mystery of the Black Shuck and trying to use the dog to terrorize the two women. As far as who did it, I was not sure whether it was Chloe or Paul.