6I

Did McCaleb do the right thing in shooting Crimmins? What did you think this meant for Graciela and Raymond?

I couldn’t see any different ending between McCaleb and Crimmins/Noone. Crimmins wouldn’t be taken alive, and McCaleb wouldn’t let him simply walk away.
I didn’t think it was wise, however, to kill Crimmins before finding out where Graciela and Raymond were.
Having said that, I thought McCaleb would be able to find them, dead or alive.

Yes I believe Crimmins should have been shot by McCaleb. I think McCaleb will be able to still find Gracelia and Raymond,

Too bad he couldn't have shot him sooner.

He was never going to give McCaleb their location. Shoot him fast and then try to deduce where they are located

I wasn’t surprised he killed him, but surely not until Graciela and Raymond were safe, this seemed totally stupid!