Lulu and the Cat in the Bag

I bought the Lulu books as soon as they came out, several years ago. Hilary McKay, diversity that's not focused on said diversity, and animals - what's not to love? I never actually got around to reading them, since they are almost always checked out or I'm recommending someone to check them out so I was pleased when two were nominated for Cybils and I could justify taking them home.

In the second Lulu story, Lulu and the Dog from the Sea, Lulu and her family (including her cousin Mellie and her old dog Sam) are going to the beach for a week! Everyone in the family has a different plan; Lulu's dad is going to train to run a marathon, her mom is going to read, Mellie is going to make a perfect kite, and Lulu quickly decides, as soon as show more they arrive, that she's going to make friends with the mysterious stray dog that's hanging around the cottage. Although things don't go exactly as planned, everyone gets what they want, more or less, and Lulu is delighted to add another pet to her collection at home.

In Lulu's third story, her Nan is watching Mellie and Lulu while their parents are gone for a week. Nan doesn't like animals at all and definitely thinks Lulu has too many! When Lulu finds a stray cat, Nan is absolutely horrified; but this isn't just any cat, it turns out to be a cat that's perfect for a gardener, just like Gran.

These stories are utterly delightful. There's a slight air of unreality about them - Lulu is just a little too perfectly behaved, but that's part of the appeal. It's refreshing to read a story about a little girl who isn't having dramatic break-ups with her friends, conflicts with her teachers, or arguments with her siblings on every other page. These are exactly what they appear to be - sweet, funny stories about a little girl who loves animals. Dog from the sea is a little more cliched I felt, with the stray dog, Lassie-type theme, but it's still sweet. Cat in the bag was hilarious - I laughed all through Charlie's deadpan delivery of his antics and Nan was a perfectly peppery character.

Priscilla Lamont's illustrations are perfectly suited for a beginning chapter book. Simple black and white sketches, they bring out the characters and events in the book with small motifs and a few half-page spreads.

Verdict: If you don't already have Lulu in your library, go out and add her! Hilary McKay's writing is sweet and strong with enough animals and humor to keep kids reading and a well-written story that parents will enjoy helping struggling readers or even reading aloud to younger listeners. Lulu belongs in every library; highly recommended.

Dog from the sea
ISBN: 9780807548202

Cat in the bag
ISBN: 9780807548042

Published 2013 by Albert Whitman; Borrowed from the library show less

Thoroughly enjoyable - the story of a girl who keeps quite a menagerie, rather to the disapproval of her strict but loving Nan. Lulu's cousin is staying with her, and they find a cat dumped on their doorstep in a bag. The cat is marmalade coloured and huge and Lulu can't possibly turn it away...

Likeable characters, a nicely told story (if a tad predictable at the end) with some low-key humour here and there. Ideal for a read-aloud for children of around four or five and upwards, or as an early chapter book for fluent readers who want something a little more challenging.

Definitely recommended.

Longer review here: https://suesbookreviews.blogspot.com/2022/08/lulu-and-cat-in-bag-by-hilary-mckay...

Lulu the animal lover is back in Book 3 of this appealing series. Lulu's parents are out of town, and Nan is on duty. She does not like cats. That's a problem, because Lulu does -- and has just found a new stray she'd like to adopt! Along with her cousin and best friend, can Lulu keep Nan away from the new pet while, at the same time, trying to convince her to be more amenable to pets? Charming -- even better than Book Two! (42)

Lulu first appeared in Lulu and the Duck in the Park to glowing reviews. She’s still glowing. She and her best friend. Mellie, are left in the care of Grandma. Lulu loves animals but Grandma doesn’t. When a big old orange cat decides that it loves living in Lulu’s bedroom, and starts leaving flowers around the house, Grandma slowly comes around, and when it is time for Grandma to go home, she invited Marigold and her two new kittens to come live with here. If you’re looking for engaging characters for very young chapter book readers, consider Lulu. She’s a lot of fun. Priscilla Lamont’s illustrations add to the fun.

When a mysterious bag is left on Lulu's doorstep, the last thing her grandmother expects to be in it is a cat--a huge, neon orange cat. But Lulu knows this cat doesn't mean any harm and in fact it needs a lovely new home.

Cute and simple first chapter book. Lula is quite the animal lover and her Grandmother is certainly not. An abandoned cat left on their doorstep changes this dynamic.