Falling Off the Face of the Earth

by J.F. Smith

On This Page

Tags

Recommendations

Member Recommendations

Member Reviews

6 reviews
I struggled a lot with this one, mainly because I didn’t want to be the Miss Ego to JF Smith’s Gusteau, but– you know.

I’m a huge plot fan. Huge.

I’m forever in search of a Plot featuring Well-Rounded LGBT Characters, Multidimensional & With A Purpose In Life (all capitalized because this is my quest, my Holy Grail) (spoiler alert: still searching). I also prefer to read adult characters rather than teens or YA, because I love to embark in impossible tasks.

When James from New York came along, I was all yay! An outta the closet MC, adult to boot and carrying a tragic secret all the way to his hometown? Bring it. The prologue promised me so many things. So many. And yet.

[Keep reading @ Bookshelves&Teacups]
I really enjoyed this small town romance; James is a New York City big shot name in the Advertisement industry, with a good looking boyfriend who has to remain in the closet. Actually the boyfriend is more small-town boy than James who is actually from the South; he would like to come out, he would love for James to be the one helping him facing the public opinion, but James is all for the imagine, and not at all supporting; worst, James doesn’t understand his boyfriend is hurting, not until the day he finds him dead for an barbituric overdose. James’s world crashes down and he can only think to go back home, to his mother’s welcoming embrace. But the limited mentality of the small town he left so many years ago is still there, show more and worse than worst, his high school nemesis, Brick, is now his mother’s second hand in the business she owns.

Brick is really changed from when he was a teenager, but James doesn’t trust him at the beginning. And while he is hurt from his mistakes, he hasn’t probably learned from them since James starts another relationship with a closed man, who, on the contrary of his previous boyfriend, is not at all ready to come out from the closet.

While James is grieving, he has not crossed the chance to have again a love life; from day one, James is ready to check out the market for a possible partner, but of course he always picks the wrong option. James will also have issues with the small town attitude, very few examples are good, like his mother and the friends he will make anew.

I found the romance well developed, and in a way surprising, even if I was expecting the evolution; what I was not expecting was the sidetracking the author had for James, he didn’t take the straight road (no pun intended) to happiness. And what I didn’t expect was the tragic ending for one of the supporting characters, from my point of view, if the author wanted to revisit this couple, having that character out of the picture is a tremendous loss, but maybe James had to grew somehow, since, as proved, not even the death of his boyfriend was a shock enough to make him.

http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0054LX3C2/?tag=elimyrevandra-20
show less
4-4.5 stars. Seriously awesome book that I felt I was getting for a steal at $.99 cents! Loved the character, the emotions, the family and friendship interactions...can't gush about it enough. I would of loved some 'on-page' smexxin, but that's just my pervy self. *grins*

Definitely adding this author to my 'auto-buy' list.
4.5 stars.

So good! Lots of room to flesh the characters out and allow them to grow organically. Beautiful ending.

Not crazy about the brief enraging moment of fatphobia which is why this isn't five stars. (Example in my update comment and in the way the description of Brick seemed to change from "thick, slight beer belly" to "naturally muscular" with no mention of the belly as the MCs reached the sexy part of their relationship).

Overall, it was just a fantastic story.
4.5 stars.

So good! Lots of room to flesh the characters out and allow them to grow organically. Beautiful ending.

Not crazy about the brief enraging moment of fatphobia which is why this isn't five stars. (Example in my update comment and in the way the description of Brick seemed to change from "thick, slight beer belly" to "naturally muscular" with no mention of the belly as the MCs reached the sexy part of their relationship).

Overall, it was just a fantastic story.
While this book could do with some severe editing, it's still a decent read for a $.99 buy.

Members

Recently Added By

Author Information

5 Works 281 Members

Classifications

Genres
LGBTQ+, Fiction and Literature, Romance

Statistics

Members
74
Popularity
427,005
Reviews
6
Rating
½ (3.42)
Media
Ebook
ASINs
1