Forewarning: Based on the cover, it's easy to mistake this book for a graphic novel, but it's not; it's a novel with some illustrations. There is a lot of discussion of comic books and graphic novels in the text, though, so comic book fans may still enjoy the book.

I like the premise of Project Superhero, and its combination format of diary, interview letters, and illustrations is interesting. The yearlong Superhero Slam project assigned to Jessie and her classmates in the book is a great idea and would make for an interesting school year; I'd like to see more classes doing such long-term, interdisciplinary projects that really challenge the kids to think and research and debate. Unfortunately, Project Superhero reads too much like the actual notes of a research project and not enough like a compelling story.

Since the main character is 13, I'm not sure if Project Superhero will wind up classified as a middle grade or a young adult book. Either way, I don't think its intended audience will find it to be a very exciting read. For the middle grade level, Project Superhero doesn't have enough action--most of the text is Jessie's musings, thoughts, and interviews, which may inspire some "What makes a hero?" musings of their own in readers, but doesn't hold a young reader's attention very well or make them wonder what will happen on the next page. For the YA level, Project Superhero doesn't have enough character development--the only real character is Jessie; two friends and a sister are in the book, but barely. There are some friendship frustrations and changing relationship dynamics involved with the two friends, but the friends and day-to-day events are so briefly mentioned that it's easy for readers to figure out what's going on but hard for them to become invested enough to care.

The topic is intriguing, though, and Project Superhero's biggest asset is the real letters from true-life heroes. For kids interested in superheroes or who want to be heroes in their own ways, Project Superhero is still a good read.

Note: I received a digital galley of this book through NetGalley. ( )

This story attracted me because instead of being about a boy, it is about a girl. Normally when I see a title like this I automatically assume superhero - boys however once I read the synopsis I was hooked. And the school project she undertook was awesome. There is a lot of positive in this book for both girls and women in general. ( )