Murder on Astor Place

by Victoria Thompson

Gaslight Mysteries (1)

On This Page

Description

After a routine delivery, midwife Sarah Brandt visits her patient in a rooming house and discovers that another boarder, a young girl, has been killed. At the request of Sergeant Frank Malloy, she searches the girl's room, and discovers that the victim is from one of the most prominent families in New York and the sister of an old friend. The powerful family, fearful of scandal, refuses to permit an investigation. But with Malloy's help, Sarah begins a dangerous quest to bring the killer to show more justice before death claims another victim. show less

Tags

Recommendations

Member Recommendations

cbl_tn Historical mysteries that team a society woman with a policeman who doesn't want her involved in the investigation yet needs the insight she can provide into her circle of friends and acquaintances.

Member Reviews

64 reviews
I enjoyed this historical mystery that brings to light class distinctions, the control of husbands and fathers over their wives and daughters, police corruption, and societal judgments of unconventional roles and choices in the Victorian era in New York.

There are many mysteries featuring an amateur sleuth and a detective but this mystery totally captured my attention when Sergeant Frank Malloy is told by his superiors to stop investigating a murder and he encourages midwife Sarah Brandt to continue investigating. As Frank has promised to check in with Sarah every few days to see if she's learned anything Sarah's courage is bolstered and she admirably takes on the challenge.

With each step of the investigation, readers also learn more show more about the past histories of Frank Malloy and Sarah Brandt and essentially what motivates their actions going forward. They complement each other well and as a series opener it is heartwarming for the reader to anticipate their growth individually and together as the series continues.

I also found Sarah's nosy neighbor, Mrs. Elsworth and her superstition for every occasion to be an amusing addition to the storyline. Mrs. Elsworth made me wonder if she was the originator of many of the phrases designated as "Old Wives' Tales."
show less
Of course, I never follow the correct order for books in a series. This is the premiere book of the Gaslight series set in New York City in the 1890's. I have already read two later books and enjoyed the series so much, that I have purchased all the earlier books. The characters are introduced from Sarah Brandt to Frank Mallory to Teddy Roosevelt. Thompson does a wonderful job showing the huge gap between the rich and the poor in their lodgings, character, rules, and clothing. I like Sarah who like a curious mouse can go anywhere in the city and fit-in. In this episode a daughter of one the wealthy families is murdered, but the family seems content to allow the murder to fade away rather than invite scandal. An interesting adventure show more into New York history. show less
I saw an ad for Victoria Thompson in the back of one of the recent Christie novels I read, so when I was at the bookstore, I picked up her first one. I wasn't disappointed.

Her use of the turn-of-the-century New York City made me smile first off. It was such an interesting time period (and I have a fondness for Teddy Roosevelt, I won't lie) and I've lived in NY my whole life. So to read about my "backyard", so to speak, was nice.

Characters first: We have Sarah Brandt, a midwife with a past that is very easily figured out, so I doubt it was meant to be mysterious. A once-well-off woman who decided to follow her heart rather than her parents rules, she is considered to be somewhat lower classed now. It's fascinating to see just how show more differently she's treated, and the shock that everyone gives her when they learn her maiden name.

She's feisty, to say the least, and a bit headstrong. I do like that in my female characters, so I didn't mind. Sometimes she may have been a bit too much (such as visiting the VanDamms all the time, even if it was necessary), but she got her job done.

The other main character is Detective Sergeant Frank Malloy, your Irish New York Cop. (Sidenote: All the Irish names in the police force made me smile). He's brutish, hot-headed, and only wants to do things that help himself. But as the book progresses, a bit of his softer side (and his past) comes out and it makes a reader appreciate him a bit more.

One thing that did annoy me: the constant reminder in the beginning that they found each other annoying. It felt almost to the point of telling the reader, "Hey! If you couldn't figure this out for yourself, I'll tell you again. She annoys him. He annoys her. Got it? I can say it once more..."

As for the plot, I'll say what I can with little spoilers: the sister an old friend of Sarah Brandt turns up dead. Afraid that the corrupt police won't solve anything on their own, she sticks her nose in. Chaos and plot twists ensue.

The mystery wasn't hard to figure out, especially near the end. The subject matter is a touchy one, but I'm sure something you've heard before (even if you didn't want to). While not the best mystery I've read, certainly one that will keep me reading the Gaslight series.
show less
Murder on Astor Place
4 Stars

As a midwife, Sarah Brandt is no stranger to the struggles of life and death. However, after attending a routine birth at a boarding house, Sarah is shocked to learn not only that one of the other guests has been murdered, but that the young woman is someone she knows. When the girl’s prominent family refuses to permit an investigation and the police appear to be just as disinclined, Sarah takes it upon herself to discover the truth.

A good mystery, but it is the dynamic between Sarah Brandt and Frank Malloy that truly make this book shine.

Sarah is a strong willed and independent heroine, and it is impossible not to admire her courage for turning her back on the capricious and prejudiced social strictures of show more her upbringing. It is more difficult to appreciate Detective Frank Malloy character as his moral compass appears to have gone awry. However, as the circumstances of his life are slowly revealed, it becomes clear that there is more to him than meets the eye and that underneath his gruff facade and bullying manner lies a decent man trying to survive in a harsh world.

The murder investigation is compelling as the victim evokes a strong sense of empathy and sympathy, which makes it all the easier to identify with Sarah's need to get justice for her. There are a variety of suspects and motives, but it is possible to figure it all out by following the clues.

All in all, a well-written mystery with a strong sense of setting and engaging characters. Looking forward to continuing with the series.
show less
Sarah Brandt is a young, widowed midwife in turn of the century New York. While delivering a baby in a nearby rooming house Sarah sees a young pregnant woman who is the image of an old friend from her youth. The young girl is later found murdered in the same rooming house. Investigating the murder is Detective Frank Malloy. At this point in time Teddy Roosevelt is the NY Police Commissioner trying to clean up the corruption that is prevalent in the organization. Frank is used to the system of graft and is skeptical that Roosevelt will be successful. He expects the only way he will solve this mystery is if he uses bribes. The victim comes from a wealthy, powerful family who doesn't want the case investigated, fearing they will be show more embarrassed in society once the murder facts are public. Sarah pushes Frank to continue his investigation despite being removed from the case and together they team up to discover the truth.

The historical detail in this book is very good. The inclusion of facts about the time and place made it very absorbing. Frank and Sarah were highly engaging, the secondary characters were nicely developed and the plot was quite detailed. I thought it might be a poor imitation of the Pitt mysteries but it was a perfect book to relax with. This style of mystery is traditionally more predictable than others so readers may or may not be surprised by the conclusion.

If you are a fan of the Thomas and Charlotte Pitt mysteries by Anne Perry, you will probably like the Gaslight Mystery series by Victoria Thompson. I love period mysteries so I found this very enjoyable. Usually mysteries of the genre are set in Britain so it was nice to see one set in America. I will definitely continue with this series.
show less
Sarah Brandt is a midwife in New York City in the late 19th century. During a routine middle of the night delivery in the squalor of a tenement rooming house, Sarah discovers that one of the tenets is a girl she recognizes, the youngest daughter of a very wealthy family. When it is discovered that the girl was murdered in the wee hours before dawn, Sarah feels compelled to find out who did it and why this girl was living in such squalid circumstances. Because Sarah herself is the estranged daughter of a wealthy man on Astor Place, she uses her societal connections, weak though they are after all these years, to help her gain entrance to houses she hasn't visited in years. Police Sergeant Frank Malloy is not very comfortable working with show more an upstart female with a mind of her own, but he has to admit, he can't solve this on his own.

This was a very well written book and I enjoyed it quite a bit, even though I figured out what was going on about halfway through the book. I'll read more in this series.
show less
Set firmly in New York City 1895, this mystery tells the story of the murder of a young socialite who has run away from home. Sarah Brandt, a socialite herself who left her family after her husband's death, is working as a midwife. While attending to the routine birth of a boarding house owner's sixth child, she sees a young woman who reminds her of one of her childhood acquaintances. When she visits the mother and baby the next day, she learns that the young girl was murdered. And she meets Police Detective Frank Malloy who is investigating the crime.

Malloy is a typical cop of the time period. He's saving money so that he can pay the bribe needed to make Captain. That means he focuses more on crimes when someone is willing to pay him show more something extra to solve it. Off hand it doesn't look like the death of a pregnant runaway is going to add to his bribe fund.

Things get even more muddled when Sarah visits the young girl's family to find that they are more concerned about possible scandal than they are in solving the murder of the girl. Sarah investigates among society where she has an in and shares her findings with Malloy who tries to discourage her interest. When Malloy is warned off the investigation by his superiors, Sarah still continues to try to unravel the case.

I will admit that I had a pretty good idea who the father of the baby was pretty early on but the author still managed to surprise me along the way. I liked the budding relationship between Sarah and Malloy. I'm glad there are more books in this series to read.
show less

Members

Recently Added By

Lists

Gaslamp Mysteries
78 works; 4 members
Books Read in 2025
4,091 works; 97 members

Author Information

Picture of author.
54+ Works 10,809 Members

Series

Work Relationships

Common Knowledge

Canonical title
Murder on Astor Place
Original publication date
1999-05-01
People/Characters
Sarah Brandt (née Decker, Tom's widow, midwife); Frank Malloy (Francis Xavier, Detective Sergeant, New York City police, Kathleen's widower); Alfred (the VanDamms' butler at their Manhattan mansion); Mrs. William Blackhouse Astor, Jr. (THE Mrs. Astor, matriarch of the family (THE Mrs. Astor, matriarch of the family); Maggie Decker (Sarah's late older sister); Elizabeth Decker (Felix's wife, Sarah and Maggie's mother) (show all 21); Ham Fisher (Hamilton, one of Mrs. Higgins' boarders); Mary Grace Higgins (10 years old, the Higgins' oldest); Mrs. Higgins (boarding house owner, Sarah's patient); Mrs. Hightower (the VanDamms' housekeeper at their Mamoraneck mansion); Lizzie (Alicia VanDamm's lady's maid for two years, now a chambermaid at the Mamoraneck mansion); Cornelius Van Damm (millionaire, one of the New York Knickerbocker familes); Alice Smith (young girl boarding with the Higgins); Dolly Yardley (Will's wife, Sarah Brandt's patient); Edith Rose Yardley (Will & Dolly's new baby); Officer Murphy (the beat cop where Sarah lives); Chief Conlin (New York City Police); Desk Sergeant O'Shaughnessy (New York City Police); Officer O'Brien (New York City Police); Harry Kelly (New York City Police detective); Bill Broghan (New York City Police detective)
Important places
New York, New York, USA; Mrs. Higgins' boarding house, Astor Place, New York, New York, USA; the VanDamm mansion, Marble Row, New York, New York, USA (the block of 5th Ave. between 57th & 58th Sreets); Sarah Brandt's house, Bank Street, Greenwich Village, New York, New York, USA; Police Headquarters, Mulberry Street, New York, New York, USA; Greentree, the VanDamms' country mansion, at Mamoraneck, New York, USA (show all 13); Mamoraneck, New York, USA (village); Slippery Joey's pawnshop, Catherine Street, the Bowery, New York, New York, USA; the Deckers' Italiante brownstone town house on 57th Street, New York, New York, USA; the plush offices of Mattingly and Springer law firm, New York, New York, USA; The Brass Lantern, the Bowery, New York, New York, USA (a flophouse); the Malloy 2nd floor flat, the 17th Ward, New York, New York, USA; Emma Petrovka's house, Gramercy Park, New York, New York, USA
Dedication
To my agent Nancy Yost, who never stopped believing and who always makes me laugh, even when the news is bad. And to my dear husband Jim, who eased the load so I'd have the time and energy to write this.
First words
At first Sarah thought the tinkling of the bell was part of her dream.
Last words
(Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)Feeling the odd mingling of satisfaction in a job well done and regret that the job was over and her mundane life beginning again, Sarah made her way back into the life of the city.
Blurbers
Coulter, Catherine; Churchill, Jill

Classifications

Genres
Fiction and Literature, Mystery, Historical Fiction
DDC/MDS
813.54Literature & rhetoricAmerican literature in EnglishAmerican fiction in English1900-19991945-1999
LCC
PS3570 .H64395 .M87Language and LiteratureAmerican literatureAmerican literatureIndividual authors1961-
BISAC

Statistics

Members
1,146
Popularity
21,954
Reviews
57
Rating
½ (3.71)
Languages
English, German
Media
Paper, Audiobook, Ebook
ISBNs
10
ASINs
8