The History Thieves

by Ian Cobain

On This Page

Description

A revelatory book exposing the culture of concealment at the heart of the British government, from the award-winning author of Cruel Britannia.

Tags

Recommendations

Member Reviews

2 reviews
In 1889, the first Official Secrets Act was passed and created offences of 'disclosure of information' and 'breach of official trust'. It limited and monitored what the public could, and should, be told. Since then, Britain's governments and civil service have been engaged in the greatest identity fraud of all time - the dishonest and manufactured creation of our understanding of the British nation, our history and our culture.
Many people are probably familiar with the phrase Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it, but what happens when you aren't allowed to know the facts of the present, let alone those of the past. How can you ever learn anything when everything is a secret?
The History Thieves is a show more fascinating book that looks at a culture of secrecy grew into Official Secrets Acts and laws that made everything official a secret. And all this in a country that prides itself on being open, honest, and honourable. Of course, those countries that have experienced British rule may have a different view of the country. As this book makes very clear.
It is in many ways a disturbing book to read. Not only because of the horrific things that the British State did, rape, torture, murder etc., but also because when these facts come to life and are publicised nobody seems to care. Cobain recounts cases from Kenya, Northern Ireland, and elsewhere that clearly indicate that the British state was directly involved with terrible crimes and yet no reaction, no outrage, apart from the people directly involved. It was all for the good of the country, seems to be some sort of mantra used in its defence, but I'm not one who believes in the ends justifying the means. Jack Bauer is not a hero to emulate!
I would recommend that everyone read this book. It'll open your eyes to the horrors that are not so far away from you as you may think.
It also made me think of that Star Trek episode, was it Voyager, or TNG? where the crew encounter a planet that eradicated part of its population and then covered that fact up ((I googled. The answer is Star Trek : Voyager ad the episode is Remember )). If no one is around to remember a crime did the crime take place? In case you're wondering I'd argue, hell yes, the crime took place, and part of the crime is that no one acknowledges it.
You cannot be forgiven or something when you don't try to make amends, if you don't recognise what you did as wrong, if you pretend you never did it, then you aren't really sorry. You're just ashamed, as well you should be.
The British government has a lot to be ashamed for. But I'd guess that every government has its own history it would rather not reveal. The terrible thing is that we, those who elect them, don't really seem to care either.
show less
First, I'm sorry I've not been reviewing well recently, my mind's not been up to scratch.

but this book is really fascinating

I'd never heard of the civil war in Oman and the UK's key role in it before, it was astounding to read about.

Overally very readable, mostly new stuff (at least to me, I've never seen most of this stuff talked about) that gives a very good introduction to why the British state is inherently evil

Members

Recently Added By

Published Reviews

ThingScore 75
Britain’s retreat from empire is remembered in a popular iconography that contains only a little violence. [...] This book supplies a more troubling image: as the sun sets on the greatest empire the world has ever seen, long columns of smoke fill the tropical skies. In a thousand bonfires, Britain is burning the historical evidence.
Ian Jack, The Guardian
Oct 6, 2016
added by Nevov

Lists

Review 1
30 works; 1 member

Author Information

Picture of author.
3 Works 192 Members

Some Editions

Dazeley, Peter (Photographer)
Mogford, Dan (Cover designer)

Awards and Honors

Common Knowledge

Canonical title
The History Thieves
Original publication date
2016-09-01

Classifications

Genres
Politics and Government, Nonfiction, History, General Nonfiction
DDC/MDS
323.44Society, government, & culturePolitical scienceCivil Rights & Liberties/ Human RightsThe state and the individualLiberty
LCC
JN329 .S4 .C63Political SciencePolitical institutions and public administration (Europe)Political institutions and public administration (Europe)Great Britain
BISAC

Statistics

Members
94
Popularity
342,408
Reviews
2
Rating
½ (4.67)
Languages
English
Media
Paper, Ebook
ISBNs
3
ASINs
1