A Song for Arbonne

by Guy Gavriel Kay

On This Page

Description

Here, the lands of Arbonne and Gorhaut are on the verge of an all-consuming conflict. When a devious high priest of Gorhaut seizes the opportunity to wage a holy war against residents of Arbonne, an epic clash between the two cultures ensues.

Tags

Recommendations

Member Recommendations

Member Reviews

59 reviews
Fabulous epic fantasy. Thematically interesting, with a multitude of engaging, deeply-imagined characters who grow and change and find their destinies in an intricately-woven, extremely satisfying plot.

I was also struck by how many of the Internet-dispersed "rules" for writing genre fiction that Kay breaks with impunity and panache. Don't have too many viewpoint characters; don't change viewpoints in the same scene; avoid adverbs when tagging dialogue ("She said" is always better than "She said gravely." -- No it isn't!). Most remarkable is how almost every scene is embellished with endless flashback and character-illuminating backstory. There is doubtless a reason these "rules" are prescribed to novice writers, but in the hands of a show more master like Kay, breaking them results in a novel of grand scope, riveting detail, and heart-breaking depth.

The book is not totally flawless. The fight scenes are sometimes unconvincing, and the author manages a few times to remove actors from the scene with "precise blows to the head" that render them conveniently unconscious until the plot is ready for them again. Also, while most of the book is in standard past tense, some areas are unaccountably switched to present-tense. This particular rule-breaking was an annoyance, at least for me.

As in other of Kay's fantasy's I've read, there is almost no magic. What there is here is at least well-explained and vivid, albeit it plays an extremely minor part in the story. So if well-imagined magic and wonder are what you crave in fantasy, you might want to look elsewhere.

My edition of the book has a quote from Charles de Lint calling this "the ideal novel." While I do not totally agree, I'd say it is pretty darn close.
show less
The troubadours' war, the heart's true north.

I came to A Song for Arbonne after reading The Lions of Al-Rassan and Tigana, expecting more of the same: a slow, beautiful, heartbreaking meditation on love and loss set against a meticulously recreated historical backdrop. I got that. But I also got something I did not expect: a novel about the difference between courtly love and real love, between the songs men sing and the lives they actually live. And the ending, the moment when a man finally understands what he has lost- broke me in a way Kay had not broken me before.

What it is:

A world shaped like Provence in the 12th century. The land of Arbonne is a place of troubadours, courts of love, high-windowed towers, and a goddess worshipped show more openly. It is wealthy, cultured, and in the eyes of its northern neighbor, the warrior kingdom of Gorhaut- decadent and sinful. Gorhaut worships a stern sun-god named Corannos. Its ruler, King Ademar, is a cold, ambitious man who longs to conquer Arbonne and eradicate its "corrupt" worship of the female divine. But the catalyst for war is not religion alone. It is a woman. A woman who has died before the story begins.

The novel follows multiple threads: Blaise, a Gorhautian mercenary who has fled his homeland and now serves the Count of Arbonne; Bertran de Talair, the charismatic, pleasure‑loving troubadour who is Arbonne's finest warrior in secret; his sister, the fierce and intelligent Countess Aelis; and the high cleric Galbert of Gorhaut, who preaches holy war while hiding his own dark secrets. The plot moves from Provençal courts to mountain passes, from jousts to sieges, from love poems written in secret to a final, terrible battle where songs and swords meet.

Why it works (and why it stays with me):

1. The deconstruction of courtly love. Kay spends the novel showing you the ideal- troubadours singing of ladies on pedestals, of love that is pure, unattainable, and ennobling. And then he shows you the reality. Bertran de Talair is a genius with the lute and a brave commander, but he is also a man who has used women, neglected his son, and mistaken obsession for love. His arc, the slow, painful realization that he has wasted years chasing a ghost while real love stood beside him is one of the most devastating things Kay has ever written.

2. Blaise is a classic Kay protagonist: the outsider trying to find his way home. He is a Gorhautian who fights for Arbonne, haunted by his father's disgrace and his own exile. His romance with a woman who is not what she seems is tender and complicated. But the heart of his story is not romance; it is the question of where home truly lies. Is it the land of your birth, even if that land is ruled by a monster? Or is it the place where you choose to stand, even if you have no blood claim?

3. The women are not pedestal ornaments. Arbonne is a land where women inherit, rule, and command armies. Countess Aelis is a brilliant tactician. The troubadour Beatritz, long dead, haunts the novel as both muse and warning: a woman who used her beauty and wit as weapons, and who paid a price. And the young woman who becomes Blaise's lover (I will not name her, to avoid spoilers) has more agency than she initially reveals. Kay writes women who are not waiting to be rescued. They are waiting for the men to catch up.

4. The theology is nuanced. Gorhaut's god is not evil; its clerics are. The novel takes seriously the idea that faith can be corrupted by power, that holy war is almost always a mask for greed and ambition. But it also shows you the cost: ordinary people on both sides who die for beliefs they barely understand. There is a scene where a Gorhautian soldier, dying, asks for a priest of his own faith, and an Arbonnese woman brings him one. It is a small moment. It is also everything.

5. The final battle is not the ending you expect. Kay has written magnificent battle sequences before (The Lions of Al-Rassan comes to mind). Here, the battle is shorter, more brutal, and followed by a long, quiet aftermath. The real climax is not the clash of armies. It is the scene in a castle courtyard where a man finally says the words he should have said years ago; and the woman he says them to has already stopped listening. I will not spoil it. But I will say that I closed the book and sat in silence for a long time.

Where it might lose some readers (honest, even as a fan):

1. The pacing is slow in the first half. Kay spends considerable time establishing the culture of Arbonne: the troubadour competitions, the courtly rituals, the politics of love. If you are impatient for action, you may find yourself wanting to skip ahead. Do not. The slow burn makes the fire at the end fiercer.

2. The cast is large, and some characters feel underdrawn. The Gorhautian court, in particular, has several villains who are more functional than fascinating. Galbert is a compelling antagonist, a true believer who has twisted his faith into a weapon but his subordinates blur together.

3. The fantasy elements are almost invisible. There are two moons. There is a goddess whose presence is felt more than seen. There is a moment of possible supernatural intervention. But if you come from Sanderson or Rothfuss expecting magic systems, you will be disappointed. The magic here is the poetry.

Who should read this:

Lovers of historical fiction who enjoy a quarter‑turn to the fantastic.
Anyone who has ever wondered what happens after the troubadour puts down his lute.
Readers who believe that love songs are beautiful, but the truth behind them is more beautiful still.
Fans of The Lions of Al-Rassan and A Song for Arbonne is often mentioned in the same breath for good reason.

Who might skip it:

If you need fast-paced action and clear good‑vs‑evil binaries.
If you find courtly love rituals tedious.
If you prefer your fantasy heavy on magic and light on political intrigue.

Final verdict:

A Song for Arbonne is not Kay's most famous book. Tigana has the name recognition. The Lions of Al-Rassan has the critical acclaim. But this novel might be his most human. It is about the gap between the songs we sing and the lives we lead, between the love we imagine and the love we actually have. It is about a man who spent years writing poems to a dead woman, only to discover that the woman who loved him was alive, and waiting, and he had been too blind to see her.

I finished this book and immediately wanted to read it again. Not for the plot. I already knew what happened. But for the prose, the atmosphere, the quiet devastation of Kay's final chapters. He writes like a troubadour who has learned that the truest songs are not about perfect love. They are about love that is flawed, delayed, imperfect; and still, somehow, worth everything.

Five stars. For Bertran's lute. For Blaise's exile. For the road from Gorhaut to Arbonne, which is paved with lies and lit by a few stubborn truths.
show less
I am in awe. This might be the best book I've read this year. It might be one of the best books I've ever read.

If you like epics, this is for you. Romance, intrigue, artistic expression, mystery, combat scenes, sex, violence, passion, compassion, bitter revenge, redemption. It's all here.

This book was what makes fantasy great. It is what makes historical fiction great. A perfect blend of the two, with very human elements there to give life to the characters. The reader is constantly on the edge of his/her seat, and the payoff is in spades.

I loved Tigana, my first experience with Kay, when I read it last year. This tops it.

I don't know what else to say without spoiling anything. I will say there was only one thing I didn't like about show more this book: that the experience had to end....... show less
Guy Gavriel Kay has the kind of prose that makes me want to bury myself and cry because I'll never be able to write like him. A Song for Arbonne has everything: romance, troubadours, intrigue, war, passion, revenge. It's an epic story.

Guy Gavriel Kay writes something I wouldn't call fantasy but more alternative history. He takes a place (here it's the lovely Provence) then does his research and sets a story in an alternative version of it. Beautiful plot, great characters and a lot of heartbreak.

There were a few things I liked less about this book. The antagonists seem to be evil, just to be evil and I couldn't really find a motive. I find a villain who is a villain just so there's a villain a bit unsatisfying. And I wasn't happy with show more the resolution at the end, but maybe that was just me.

Definitely a must read for all GGK fans. If you haven't read any of his work yet, I suggest you start with The Lions of Al-Rassan. It made me sob into my pillow.
show less
What a fantastic book. So beautifully written as are all GGK books, definitely recommend the audio books as Euan Morton sings the troubadours songs which makes the storytelling even richer.

As always with this author it is a book to be savored like a fine wine, even better with wine!

I loved the plotting and courtly intrigue, lush characters and world building. I can honestly say that I am amazed that he fits it all into one book.. but he manages it to perfection.

I have to say that the ending broke my heart a little but it was still magnificent.

If you like historical, low fantasy then you will really enjoy this book.
I need to write this review quickly, because the more I think about A Song for Arbonne, the less I like it. I enjoyed reading it – though less than any of my other Guy Gavriel Kay experiences – and it deserves a positive spin, however belatedly. Arbonne is an interesting world, even if some of it didn't sit well with me. Kay's lyrical prose is something I enjoy, and there is a thick, layered passion to everything he writes that sweeps you along in the moment. The key phrase there is 'in the moment'. Because though Kay is capable of crafting jewels (see Tigana), A Song for Arbonne finishes as just a piece of costume jewellery.

At first, I thought the problems would be overcome; that the extremely slow start to the book (about half its show more length) was necessary world-building and characterisation for an eventual payoff. But, aside from a brief 100-page span towards the middle/end, the book does not reward perseverance. The world-building fails when it truly matters (i.e., to help make plot pivots believable) and the characterisation became increasingly deformed. The writing, though lyrical, is often melodramatic in pushing the narrative forward, and the plot is so full of holes that the book could almost be seen as a whited sepulchre. I want to mention some of these holes in the paragraph below; consider this a spoiler warning, and those who wish to avoid them should consider merely the length of the paragraph:

[spoilers] I hope, by the end of this 600+ page novel, you remember who the people were in the prologue. Because, at the end, it matters. Or, at least, it does to the characters. Because the readers will have forgotten them, and its over-egged influence on the ending is really stupid. Kay would have us believe that the Miraval/Talair rivalry is incredibly tragic and important, but the big revelation is… that Aelis died naturally in childbirth and the child also died naturally. Oh. But wait! In the finest soap opera tradition, there was a second child, who is… some random side character. And Aelis made Ariane swear an oath not to tell Bertran – the father, whom she supposedly loved – of the existence of this second, living child, for no reason I can see other than to inject some tension into the plot. This is made even more stupid when the Countess of Arbonne, Signe, intervenes to hug her long-lost grand-daughter: she wasn't told either. I guess Beatritz was irrelevant too. If it's hard to remember who's who, and who they're related to, I've not even come to Gorhaut, the invading country. I still don't know what Blaise's claim to the throne was, and his switch from exiled mercenary to noble king-apparent is abrupt, to say the least. I'm confused by the terms of the nonsensical Treaty of Iersen Bridge, and the two main antagonists, Ademar and Galbert, are cartoon villains. I've not even come to the bare-arsed cheek of the deus ex machina arrow in the final battle, or how lamely unnecessary (and dangerous, in the heat of battle) the battle plan between Urté and the Countess was. A third plot arc, concerning Lisseut the troubadour, goes literally nowhere. An overwhelming number of other small things leap out at me the more I think about the book. [end spoilers]

All told, Kay has enough craftsman's skill to lull me into a sweet sleep for the course of his novel, but after finishing it, its errors become cruelly exposed. Kay's books are all of the same character, more or less, and there are some that reward the stamina they require. A Song for Arbonne, unfortunately, does not, and should be low on the list of titles for readers wanting to see if Kay's schtick is to their tastes. He usually is to mine, but here there were too many screws shaken loose after it had moved.
show less
Oh, my, how I needed this book. I’ve been so eager for an awesome fantasy read, but nothing’s held my attention in quite a while. Guy Gavriel Kay has always been one of my favorite authors. I adored his Lions of Al-Rassan - in fact, it’s my favorite book of all time. So I’m not sure why it took me so long to finally get around to reading A Song for Arbonne, but I’m so thrilled I finally did.

This book was everything I was hoping for - and more! The lyrical language, the immersive world-building, the three-dimensional characters I both loved, and loved to hate. Kay is a master of the craft, and his rich, immersive storytelling is such a pleasure to read.

The story deals with some pretty heavy themes: love, loss, cultural show more differences used as justification for war, misuse of religious power, the treatment of women as lower-class citizens and sex objects, loyalty and treason. Yet in the hands of a master storyteller, these are handled beautifully. None of these issues are glossed over, disregarded, or included for shock value or just to titillate the reader.

Blaise De Garsenc was one of my favorite characters (along with Bertran), and his character growth was fascinating to read. I adored Signe, Beatritz, Ariane, Lisseut, and Rosala as well. The way Kay weaves the full fabric of human emotion into his characters is enviable!

I’m recommending this book to every fantasy reader I know!
show less

Members

Recently Added By

Published Reviews

Guy Gavriel Kay n'est pas un auteur de fantasy comme les autres, Depuis la déjà fort remarquée Tapisserie de Fionavar, qui liait aux thèmes classiques de la High Fantasy une interprétation très personnelle du fameux triangle amoureux Arthur / Lancelot / Guenièvre, il s'est signalé par une tendance croissante à substituer aux poncifs du genre des préoccupations d'ordre historique, show more politique ou stratégique. Certes, la thématique du pouvoir joue toujours un rôle assez considérable dans les romans d'heroic fantasy, comme dans toute la littérature inspirée de l'héroïsme romantique du XIXème siècle. Mais ce romantisme, chez Guy Gavriel Kay, se teinte à la fois d'un intérêt pour l'Histoire et d'un cynisme résolument contemporains, post-modernes. Ainsi, d'un roman à l'autre, son oeuvre semble s'orienter vers une forme nouvelle d'heroic fantasy qui, tout en respectant la structure, les conventions littéraires et même l'ambiance générale du genre, se débarrasse peu à peu de sa naïveté foncière, de sa croyance en l'homme ou de son obsession pour la spiritualité. Une progression tout à fait intéressante dans un genre parfois quelque peu bégayant, où les auteurs se contentent (trop ?) souvent d'appliquer des schémas préconçus — tels que ceux conseillés par David Eddings dans son Codex de Riva. A ce titre, la Chanson d'Arbonne constitue certainement le roman le plus représentatif de Guy Gavriel Kay, puisque c'est là, après la Tapisserie de Fionavar et Tigane, que la transition est la plus manifeste. show less
Nathalie LABROUSSE, noosfere
Feb 15, 2001
added by Ariane65

Lists

Best Fantasy Novels
821 works; 361 members
Favourite High Fantasy Books
113 works; 23 members
Books That Made Me Cry
199 works; 105 members
The Best of Canadian Literature
235 works; 32 members
Nineties
43 works; 10 members
Top Five Books of 2021
604 works; 181 members
1990s
309 works; 17 members
Speculative Fiction to Read
706 works; 32 members
Books Read in 2023
5,547 works; 145 members
Books Read in 2021
5,361 works; 114 members
Best Audiobooks
240 works; 114 members
Books That Made Us Cry
278 works; 145 members
Book Worlds We'd Like To Visit
322 works; 158 members
Canadian Jurist-Novelists
204 works; 1 member
Survey of Fantasy Classics
111 works; 23 members

Talk Discussions

Past Discussions

Author Information

Picture of author.
34+ Works 38,704 Members
Guy Gavriel Kay was born on November 7, 1954 in Weyburn, Saskatchewan, Canada. He became interested in fantasy fiction while working as an assistant to Christopher Tolkien. He assisted him with the editing of J. R. R. Tolkien's The Silmarillion. After receiving a law degree from the University of Toronto, he became principal writer and associate show more producer for the CBC radio series, The Scales of Justice. He also wrote several episodes when the series moved to television. He has written social and political commentary for several publications including the National Post, The Globe and Mail, and The Guardian. His first fantasy novels were The Summer Tree, The Wandering Fire, and The Darkest Road, which make up the Fionavar Tapestry Trilogy. His other works include A Song for Arbonne, The Lions of Al-Rassan, Beyond This Dark House, The Last Light of the Sun, and Under Heaven. He has received numerous awards including and the Aurora Award for Tigana and The Wandering Fire, the 2008 World Fantasy Award for Best Novel for Ysabel, and the International Goliardos Award for his work in the fantasy field. (Bowker Author Biography) show less

Some Editions

Howe, John (Cover artist)
Jermann, David (Cover artist)
Kraft, Kinuko Y. (Cover artist)
Odom,Mel (Cover artist)

Awards and Honors

Series

Belongs to Publisher Series

Work Relationships

Common Knowledge

Canonical title
A Song for Arbonne
Original title
A Song for Arbonne
Alternate titles*
Een lied voor Arbonne
Original publication date
1992-08
People/Characters
Blaise de Garsenc; Bertran de Talair; Ariane de Carenzu; Signe de Barbentain; Rudel Correze; Lisseut de Vezét (show all 11); Urté de Miraval; Aelis de Miraval; Galbert de Garsenc; Ademar, King of Gorhaut; Ranald de Garsenc
Important places
Arbonne; Gorhaut
Dedication
This book is dedicated with love, to the memory of my father, Dr. Samuel K. Kay, whose skill and compassion as a surgeon were enhanced all his life by a love for language and literature - a love he conveyed to his sons, among... (show all) so many other gifts.
First words
On a morning in the springtime of the year, when the snows of the mountains were melting and the rivers swift in their running, Aelis de Miraval watched her husband ride out at dawn to hunt in the forest west of their castle,... (show all) and shortly after that she took horse herself, travelling north and east along the shores of the lake towards the begetting of her son.
Last words
(Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)And so Luth lifted is voice without shame, feeling a deep richness, a glory in the night, as he galloped his horse down the winding, empty road to the south, past farm and castle, village and field and forest, under the risen moons and the stars above Arbonne.
Blurbers
de Lint, Charles
Original language
English
*Some information comes from Common Knowledge in other languages. Click "Edit" for more information.

Classifications

Genres
Fantasy, Fiction and Literature, General Fiction, Historical Fiction
DDC/MDS
813.54Literature & rhetoricAmerican literature in EnglishAmerican fiction in English1900-19991945-1999
LCC
PR9199.3 .K39 .S6Language and LiteratureEnglishEnglish LiteratureEnglish literature: Provincial, local, etc.
BISAC

Statistics

Members
2,931
Popularity
6,087
Reviews
58
Rating
(4.10)
Languages
8 — Czech, Dutch, English, French, German, Greek, Polish, Croatian
Media
Paper, Audiobook, Ebook
ISBNs
40
ASINs
14