Heartbreaker: A Novel

I liked this. It was quirky, but quirky in the good way that knocks you out of your usual ruts of signs, signifiers, and shortcuts to emotion to get at some good truths. And despite its odd premise, including an anachronistic cult complete with strange customs and ritualistic nicknames, the book gets less and less odd as it goes along, and resolves in a real and satisfying fashion. Because it's about basic stuff, really—love, deceit, loneliness, family, and a missing mother. And very much about innocence, helped along by the quirky but reasonable narrative setup: the first chapter from the POV of a tough-but-innocent 15-year-old girl, the second from a sweetly dispassionate-but-loyal old dog, and the third from a show more not-quite-tough-enough-but-wise 19-year-old young man. But hey, enough with the hyphens—it's good, odd, and sweet, and that's plenty. show less

Heartbreaker by Claudia Dey is a highly recommended, quirky, unique character driven novel that is part dystopian, part alternate reality.

The territory is an isolated cult/settlement that was founded in the north decades ago. In the territory is it 1985, including the music, TV shows, listening to Walkmans, album covers, shoulder pads, track suits, and more. The narrative is told in three parts from the point-of-view of three different characters: the girl, the dog, and the boy.

The girl is fifteen-year-old Pony Darlene Fontaine. Pony is our first introduction to the territory and the one who begins the story of her mother, Billie Jean Fontaine, who has taken the truck and left her family. Billie Jean arrived in the territory seventeen show more years earlier, married The Heavy, Pony's father, and tried to fit in with the townspeople who never totally accepted her. Now the town is helping to search for her, but never beyond their own borders. Pony is an excellent character who is examining her circumstances, her mother's life, and has a plan. She is also the one who introduces us to a sinister way the territory makes money.

The dog is the Fontaines' and brings a unique perspective and keen observations to the story about Billie Jean, the community, and all the characters, while furthering the narrative thread. The boy, named Supernatural, adds additional information and completes the story, allowing a complete picture to emerge.

Telling the story only through the first person perspective of these three characters and what they know is utterly extraordinary. I was uncertain about Heartbreaker for almost half the novel and then the story began to emerge and take shape. It increasingly became a compelling, fascinating look at a community, setting aside their isolation and the peculiar features of the cult, through the eyes of three very different, unique characters.

The ending was the clincher and increased my assessment of the whole novel. I also keep thinking about the novel based on the ending and want to re-read it someday to catch information and clues I might have missed.

Disclosure: My review copy was courtesy of Penguin Random House Group.
http://www.shetreadssoftly.com/2018/08/heartbreaker.html show less

It has an interesting storytelling style (cadence, wording) & uses three consecutive narrators -- Pony Darlene (Billie Jean's teen daughter), the dog (Billie Jean's dog; probably the most reliable narrator), & Supernatural (a teen boy in the town) -- to relate the slowly revealed tale of Billie Jean (Pony's mother), who walks out one night into the cold weather & disappears. I have no real idea of the category of this book other than to say it is an offbeat, cult-ish book stuck in 1985. Maybe semi-dystopian...? At heart, it's a family saga, albeit an odd one in a strange setting. Comparisons to M. Night Shyamalan seem apt. Worthwhile

I completely agree with the reviews that say this reading experience is similar to that of being stuck in conversation with the egomaniacal person at a party who just never stops talking.

I appreciate Random House and Goodreads giving me the opportunity to read and review this book. I wanted to like this book so badly. The premise sounded incredible, and right up my alley. Unfortunately, the reality is that this book bombed for me. It was dry, slow, and boring. Reading it felt like a chore and was very tedious. I had such high hopes, but it just could not hold my interest.

A quirky novel