When Heaven Fell

I picked up this book as part of an independent reading assignment for a children's literature assignment on multiculturalism. I loved it so much I wanted to share it here.

A full disclaimer... in my previous life, I was a Vietnamese linguist in the US Army. Because of that, I fell in love with all things Vietnamese culture, a big reason I chose this novel. The messages of this book are both eye-opening and beautiful, and it truly shows the differences and assumptions that are often made about different cultures.

It is set in relatively contemporary times in Vietnam. Binh is 9 years old and has spent her entire life in her village, never even seeing her own country. She lives with her parents, her brother, and her grandmother in a tiny show more one-room home nestled next to the river. Her days are spent by the highway, selling fruit and soda to passersby. Although school is free in communist Vietnam, the uniforms and books are not and her family cannot afford to send her to school. A little cost comparison... school costs approximately 600,000 dong in southern Vietnam, which today is equivalent to about $28.

Ba Ngoai, Binh's grandmother, finds out that her long-lost daughter Thao is coming to visit her. Ba Ngoai has not seen her daughter since she gave her away after the end of the war when the Communist regime threatened the lives of Vietnamese children of American mixed blood. Thao's father was an American soldier, her life at risk. Binh's family sees all Americans as rich and assume that Thao will bring them gifts, gifts that will bring them a life of ease, maybe even a move to the States. Instead, Thao comes with little, seemingly meaningless gifts. The entire book is a journey for Binh to understand that there are gifts and beauty to be found in her own country, in her own life. Thao learns about the value of things that she takes for granted, how much those very things mean to the family left behind. There is so much to learn about diversity and culture and values in this book and it is simply beautiful. There is a quote from a story within the book told by a Buddhist monk that I love. The story was about a rich man looking for his runaway cows. No one had seen them and after he left, the Buddha told his followers that the mand was burdened by his cows and that they were the lucky ones, having no cows to worry about.

Please think about your cows. Some cows may be possessions Others may be ideas you cling to. Think of releasing your cows.

My Recommendation: Although a middle grade book, it is a beautiful story that I highly recommend! show less

There's a sad sweetness about Binh and her family's hopes that her Ameriasian aunt visiting from America will be as rich and generous and beautiful as they imagine. You can feel the embarassing regret as the cultural divide widens between Di Thao and the family. Binh finds a way to make everything all right.

Written for younger readers, this book gives an insight into the Vietnam War from the perspective of a struggling Vietnamese family. Binh, the main protagonist, discovers that she has an aunt who was sent to America as a five year old during Operation Babylift and now she is coming back to her birth mother in Vietnam. It looks at how Thao found it difficult to fit into American society as a child and now finds Vietnam and its culture alien to her. However, one thing I didn't like about this story was the emphasis on material wealth that permeated throughout and the distinction between the haves and have nots.

When Heaven Fell is set in Vietnam. It's about a 9 year old girl who is too poor to go to school, and so she sells fruit to help her family. Her grandmother tells her that she has an aunt that is coming to visit from America. When the aunt gets to Vietnam the young girl gets very confused because their lives are very different.

I really liked this book, children can learn a lot by reading it. I would recommend this book to grades 3 and up.

When 9 year old Binh finds out that her grandmother had a child with an American soldier during the Vietnam War and that she is coming to visit the family, she is very excited. The whole family goes to great lengths to welcome her and all of them hope that the American will be able to help them because they are poor. This is a sweet story about families and different cultures and how they react with one another. While her aunt is not rich and doesn't at first understand how difficult life is for her Vietnamese family, she eventually realizes that she can make a difference in their lives especially for Binh.

A great story of Vietnam in present day. A long lost Aunt returns who was adopted out to America in Operation Baby Lift. Life for half Vietamese children was hard after the war. Vietamese family has high expectations of their foreign aunt.