I Don't Want to Talk About It: Overcoming the Secret Legacy of Male Depression

Most men are depressed. Many of them don't even know it. Sexism and the Patrix are part of the problem. Talk about stuff! Tell your stories! Don't keep it in. Don't hide emotion.

Way back in July or something I listened to the audio edition of “I Don’t Want to Talk About It: The Hidden Legacy of Male Depression" - a book by psychotherapist Terrence Real, recommended to my by my friends Jorge and Dave.

He asserts, as I’ve long believed, that a majority of men in the US have depression. But unlike the overt depression we hear about that goes with suicide attempts and the like, Real proposes that most men have what he calls covert depression - a condition of which they’re not even aware, yet which can often manifest in addictive show more behavior and a general dissatisfaction with life/self.

Lately I’ve been thinking about myself, and the people around me, and have realized that addictive behavior is rampant in our culture. Almost anything can be used addictively - whether it be alcohol, TV, Facebook, athletics, or even spirituality and love. I list these examples because they’re forms of addiction which I’ve personally experienced or witnessed.

I was super into the book, and all the case studies. But I forgot to tell other people about because the book just peters out. The premise is bulletproof, but Real focuses more on the academic side of things that the DIY/handbook aspect of things - so I didn’t actually find the piece that helpful for identifying next steps for myself or those I support.

It got me asking the question again - why are most US americans [the community with which I’m most familiar] depressed and addicted? It brought me back to my sustainable living class with John Gerber at UMass Amherest. Gerber proposed that we’re more interconnected than we are separate. In other words, we can’t be healthy if our community or planet isn’t healthy. It’s a theme echoed by Charles Eisenstein.

I’d say that I’ve experienced this to be my truth as well. I do my best to take care of myself, but if I’m ever truly going to be healthy, the world’s going to need to be healthy as well. Maybe this is why Real didn’t address the bigger picture - it’s pretty daunting.

I have identified one leverage point for these issues: our culture prefers externally-derived self-esteem to internally-generated self-esteem. Until people make this personal shift, we’re going to keep being addicted - filling that hole with things that can’t fit. show less

I read this book because I loved [b:Us: Getting Past You and Me to Build a More Loving Relationship|58502657|Us Getting Past You and Me to Build a More Loving Relationship (Goop Press)|Terrence Real|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1636979112l/58502657._SY75_.jpg|91881634] so much.

[b:I Don't Want to Talk About It: Overcoming the Secret Legacy of Male Depression|236765|I Don't Want to Talk About It Overcoming the Secret Legacy of Male Depression|Terrence Real|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1424410383l/236765._SY75_.jpg|229325] was published in 1997, and Real's take on male depression seemed cutting edge then, and, at least from my experience, is still not widely show more accepted.

Real says there are two types of depression. Overt depression which includes Major and Minor Depression, the traditional definitions of depression. This manifests as loss of sleep, loss of appetite, eating too much, loss of interest in things and so on and so forth. The second for of depression is Covert Depression. This is where men (I assume can apply to women) are depressed but are using coping mechanism to keep it at bay. This normally includes some type of addiction, drugs, alcohol, sex, or any other form of addiction, and men, generally externalizes this depression in aggressive behavior towards other. (Women would normally internalize this depression)

Though this book is not engaging as [b:Us: Getting Past You and Me to Build a More Loving Relationship|58502657|Us Getting Past You and Me to Build a More Loving Relationship (Goop Press)|Terrence Real|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1636979112l/58502657._SY75_.jpg|91881634], I found it to be really helpful in analyzing your past and connecting it to your current actions. How you have to move from Covert to Overt depression before you can heal.

This is the type of therapy I thought I was going to receive when I started going. show less

I found the author to be insightful and helpful. I related to some of the childhood experiences. Reading this made me remember some of the pain in my past. I recommend this book freely to anyone interested in improving their relationships and demeanor.

Very impactful read, especially for female therapists. Demonstrates effectively socialization that can sometimes be hard to catch in male clients.

I can't recommend this book highly enough. It's filled with insight and soul.
I was both educated and moved to tears. It helped me understand my own struggles with depression as well as those of my father.

Got this book to understand better the lives of screwed up males *ahem* but found it very interesting to read about the psychology of this guy. Wounds, duality, hidden depression, etc. Interesting.

Got this book to understand better the lives of screwed up males *ahem* but found it very interesting to read about the psychology of this guy. Wounds, duality, hidden depression, etc. Interesting.