This is a mystery set in two timelines. In the past, Louise is attending Highfield Manor, an exclusive boarding school in Dublin. She is a daughter of a working class family and immediately an outsider, until she meets Shauna, who takes her under her wing. But Lou's time there is full of tragedy as there is a murder that goes unsolved.

Thirty years later, Shauna's brother, a lawyer, is suing Highfield Manor over the events of the past, and needs Lou to testify. Lou has spent all those years trying to forget and move on, but has been forced to relive the past.

This was a really good thriller. I really liked the audio narration. Although the narrator was Irish the accent was still very understandable. Thank you Macmillan audio for giving me an advanced review copy of this audiobook in exchange for an honest review. ( )

This story weaves back and forth between two timelines about a privileged girls school and the secrets that went on there, notably sexual assault and the grooming that is perpetrated before such assault can take place. Louise Manson is a teenager from a working class family headed by a single mother who receives a scholarship to attend Highfield Manor, Dublin’s exclusive private school. She does not fit in with the rich girls that attend. As she navigates her way through trying to blend in by she meets another young girl, Shauna who she feels an instant attraction to. They become good friends and are both athletes that are singled out by the head swim coach. They both enjoy his attention as it makes them feel special, that is until Lou is unnerved by some of the touching and other inappropriate behaviors by the coach. She tells Shauna of this and Shauna doesn't agree, she is willing to go along with such behaviors as it's 'just the way coach is'. The whole thing culminates at the schools swimming pool and Lou is accused of murder. Years later there is another abuse case that has come up and Shauna's brother, a lawyer wants Lou to testify in this trial and speak of her experiences from the past because it has taken place at the same school, Highfield Manor. This is the last thing she wants to do but agrees so she might finally move forward from the guilt and pain she carries from the past. This was a really interesting and captivating novel. It has a lot of secrets that don't come to light until the very end. Well written with a powerful message for readers. Highly recommended. 4.5 stars.

Many thank to Net Galley and Macmillan Audio for the opportunity to listen/read an audio version of this novel. ( )

Have you been searching for a gripping and thought-provoking read? Look no further than "When We Were Silent" by Fiana Phillips. Despite my initial doubts about a heavy topic, I was thoroughly captivated by India Mullen's exceptional narration. Her voice is truly remarkable, and it drew me in from the start. In fact, she has now become my favorite audiobook narrator.

The novel takes place in Dublin and tells the stories of several girls who attend the prestigious Highfield Manor School. The two main characters, Shauna and Louisa (Lou), will leave you heartbroken by the traumas they have endured in their young lives. Fast forward thirty years, and Lou faces a life-changing decision that will have profound consequences for herself and her daughter. Does she have the courage to confront Highfield Manor and its current and past teachers?

Phillips' book is a potent and emotionally charged narrative, bravely tackling the challenging themes of exploitation and retribution. These are issues that often go unspoken, but this novel shines a piercing light on them. It is a must-read for those seeking a story that will leave a lasting impression. I cannot stress its importance enough. Give it a chance, and you will be moved. ( )