Isaac Asimov's Inferno

While I found Caliban decent, this is where the story gets even better: the mystery and the writing in general seem to have been kicked up a notch for the second volume of the trilogy. Alvar Kresh isn't a particularly complex lead character, but he's as effective likeable a protagonist as his dramatic opposite, Elijah Baley, was. Just as Baley went up against a world with robots, Kresh must discover a world without one, and the result is an excellent exploration of the universe of Asimov's robots that uses the Three Laws (and the New Laws) quite well. Oh, and R. Donald is just the coolest.

Inferno is the second Asimov universe book written by Roger MacBride Allen. Much like Asimov's Robots and Empire and Caliban, its what I will call an "issue book". In Robots and Empire the issue at hand was that having a long life results in risk adversity and therefore the stagnation of society as a whole. In Caliban the issue was the over protection of humans by robots, and the ultimately corrupting nature of living in a society built on slavery (even of machines), as well as stagnation caused by the risk adversity of the robots themselves. In this second Allen book, the issue is the exploitation of the "new law" robots who ultimately become the new slaves in return for a chance at freedom later. This exploitation is a criminal show more offence, so of course they end up with a society in which pretty much everyone has dirty hands of some form.

Overall this was a good read, and probably a better book than Inferno. I certainly found it easier to read and more enjoyable. I read the majority of the book on a single set of flights between the US and Australia because it was such a good read.

Its interesting that the Amazon reviews for this book are mostly negative, and I can see the point they're trying to make. There are certainly opportunities for Prospero's psychology and the overall political situation created by the massive disruption of the society to be explored more. Additionally, the murder mystery is resolved very rapidly at the end of the book after crawling progress during the majority of the book. Then again, that's just like Caves of Steel and Naked Sun, which both are resolved rapidly at the end of the book and gloss over issues which aren't core to the story. I guess you can chose to tell a story many different ways, and just because Allen didn't chose to tell it the way that the Amazon reviewers thought he should doesn't make his choice incorrect.

http://www.stillhq.com/book/Roger_MacBride_Allen/Inferno.html show less

How disappointing. After reading Isaac Asimov's Caliban, I was clearly expecting a better novel than this. Although some important events happen in this novel, I was bored to tears throughout most of it.

In a Universe protected by the Three Laws of Robotics, humans are safe. The Second Law states, a robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law. When a key politician is murdered, suspicion falls on Caliban... the only robot without guilt or conscience, with no need to obey or to respect humanity... a robot without the Three Laws. But the stakes go deeper than one man's life. Caliban...

See Caliban.

In Inferno komt het voortbestaan van dit nieuwe type robot opnieuw zwaar onder druk te staan als de ruimterwereld in hevige beroering wordt gebracht door de afschuwelijke moord op de weinig geliefde gouverneur.
De twee hoofdverdachten zijn de superrobots Caliban en Prospero die, dat weet iedereen, eerder een poging deden het slachtoffer te chanteren. Ze bedoelden het echter goed. Beiden veronderstelden de triomf van een nieuwe samenleving te zullen meemaken, maar dat vooruitzicht lijkt opeens onhaalbaar veraf als foute ideologen hun stem laten horen.
Er ontstaat gewelddadig tumult en de verantwoordelijke politiefunctionaris Alvar Kresh krijgt opdracht de zaak met uiterste voorzichtigheid te behandelen. Ondanks zijn inspanning worden de show more complicaties hoe langer hoe groter, tot aan de frappante ontknoping toe. show less