Intertwined Lives: Margaret Mead, Ruth Benedict, and Their Circle

by Lois W. Banner

On This Page

Description

This book is a revealing biography of two eminent twentieth century American women. Close friends for much of their lives, Ruth Benedict and Margaret Mead met at Barnard College in 1922, when Mead was a student, Benedict a teacher. They became sexual partners (though both married), and pioneered in the then male-dominated discipline of anthropology. They championed racial and sexual equality and cultural relativity despite the generally racist, xenophobic, and homophobic tenor of their era. show more Mead's best-selling Coming of Age in Samoa (1928) and Sex and Temperament in Three Primitive Societies (1935), and Benedict's Patterns of Culture (1934), Race (1940), and The Chrysanthemum and the Sword (1946), were landmark studies that ensured the lasting prominence and influence of their authors in the field of anthropology and beyond. With unprecedented access to the complete archives of the two women--including hundreds of letters opened to scholars in 2001--Lois Banner examines the impact of their difficult childhoods and the relationship between them in the context of their circle of family, friends, husbands, lovers, and colleagues, as well as the calamitous events of their time. She shows how Benedict inadvertently exposed Mead to charges of professional incompetence, discloses the serious errors New Zealand anthropologist Derek Freeman made in his famed attack on Mead's research on Samoa, and reveals what happened in New Guinea when Mead and colleagues engaged in a ritual aimed at overturning all gender and sexual boundaries. show less

Tags

Recommendations

Member Reviews

4 reviews
I wanted to like this book. And I did learn biographical information about Margaret Mead and Ruth Benedict, and a great deal of historical information about America in the early twentieth century, particularly between the world wars. Unfortunately, the sexual relationship between the two alluded to on the cover is not well supported in the text - the primary supporting source is a poem, Banner's interpretation of which left me scratching my head. Mead and Benedict's other romantic entanglements, however, are more clearly presented - both queer and straight.

It is also a slow read, quite dense with detail. During the month I was actively reading it, I sometimes refered to it as The Book That's Trying to Kill Me, because its endurance was show more clearly greater than my own. Honestly, I probably would have liked it more had I not been woefully misled by cover copy. show less
I enjoyed this book very much. I really didn’t know much about Margaret Mead and Ruth Benedict, and hadn’t a clue that they were lovers, so that was a revelation. They are both amazing women and I really appreciated the chance to get to know them better.

The book follows Mead and Benedict from birth, covers their relationship with each other and their relationships with others, lingers on their work, and continues until Benedict’s death. One of the book’s flaws is that it then ends, leaving me to wish for another chapter, a picture of Mead’s remaining years.

This book is not gossipy or sensational in the slightest. If anything, it sometimes sinks under the weight of its scholarship. It spends a great deal of time on the show more intellectual atmosphere around them, and their participation in that. The writer is very painstaking in her analysis of social attitudes towards lesbians. She traces Benedict’s and Mead’s philosophical paths in a variety of areas: sexual freedom, gender roles, progressive political beliefs, race, anthropological approaches. She shows how Mead and Benedict influenced each other and how they differed, as well as how they were influenced by the other people around them.

So much theory can sometimes make things a little dry, and these women were anything but dry. However, it’s not just a biography of Margaret Mead and Ruth Benedict, but also a description of the times in which they lived - how they were shaped by it, and how they shaped it. It’s definitely worth reading.
show less
I enjoyed this book very much. I really didn’t know much about Margaret Mead and Ruth Benedict, and hadn’t a clue that they were lovers, so that was a revelation. They are both amazing women and I really appreciated the chance to get to know them better.

The book follows Mead and Benedict from birth, covers their relationship with each other and their relationships with others, lingers on their work, and continues until Benedict’s death. One of the book’s flaws is that it then ends, leaving me to wish for another chapter, a picture of Mead’s remaining years.

This book is not gossipy or sensational in the slightest. If anything, it sometimes sinks under the weight of its scholarship. It spends a great deal of time on the show more intellectual atmosphere around them, and their participation in that. The writer is very painstaking in her analysis of social attitudes towards lesbians. She traces Benedict’s and Mead’s philosophical paths in a variety of areas: sexual freedom, gender roles, progressive political beliefs, race, anthropological approaches. She shows how Mead and Benedict influenced each other and how they differed, as well as how they were influenced by the other people around them.

So much theory can sometimes make things a little dry, and these women were anything but dry. However, it’s not just a biography of Margaret Mead and Ruth Benedict, but also a description of the times in which they lived - how they were shaped by it, and how they shaped it. It’s definitely worth reading.
show less
Best yet bio of two great Anthropologists, Clues into Creativity and Genius

Members

Recently Added By

Lists

Author Information

Picture of author.
11+ Works 676 Members
Lois Banner is Professor of History and Gender Studies at the University of Southern California.

Awards and Honors

Common Knowledge

Original publication date
2003

Classifications

Genres
Anthropology, Nonfiction, Biography & Memoir, General Nonfiction, Sexuality and Gender Studies, LGBTQ+, History
DDC/MDS
306.092Society, government, & cultureSocial sciences, sociology & anthropologySocial Behavior - Dating, Marriage, DivorceSocial historyBiography
LCC
GN20 .B36Geography, Anthropology and RecreationAnthropologyAnthropology
BISAC

Statistics

Members
113
Popularity
288,437
Reviews
4
Rating
½ (3.71)
Languages
English
Media
Paper, Ebook
ISBNs
3
ASINs
1