Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World

Summary
An astonishing work of cultural criticism, this book is widely recognized as a brilliant and devastating challenge to conventional views of literature, anthropology, religion, and psychoanalysis. In its scope and itnerest it can be compared with Freud’s Totem and Taboo, the subtext Girard refutes with polemic daring, vast erudition, and a persuasiveness that leaves the reader compelled to respond, one way or another. This is the single fullest summation of Girard’s ideas to date, the book by which they will stand or fall. In a dialogue with two psychiatrists (Jean-Michel Oughourlian and Guy Lefort), Girard probes an encyclopedic array of topics, ranging across the entire spectrum of anthropology, psychoanalysis, and cultural show more production. Girard’s point o departure is what he calles “mimesis,” the conflict that arises when human rivals compete to differentiate themselves from each other, yet succeed only in becoming more and more alike. At certain points in the life of a society, according to Girard, this mimetic conflict erupts into a crisis in which all difference dissolves in indiscriminate violence. In primitive societies, such crises were resolved by the “scapegoating mechanism,” in which the community, en masse, turned on an unpremeditated victim. The repression of this collective murder and its repetition in ritual sacrifice then formed the foundations of both religion and the restored social order. How does Christianity, at once the most “sacrificial” of religions and a faith with a non-violent ideology, fit into this scheme? Girard grants Freud’s point, in Totem and Taboo, that Christianity is similar to primitive religion, but only to refute Freud--if Christ is sacrificed, Girard argues, it is not becuase God willed it, but becaus ehuman beings wanted it. The book is not merely, or perhaps not mainly, biblical exegesis, for within its scope fall some of the most vexing problems of social history--the paradox that violance has social efficacy, the function of the scapegoat, the mechanism of anti-semitism. show less

En este ensayo, Girard reflexiona sobre el papel de la violencia y la imitación en la cultura, abordando la revelación cristiana como un punto de inflexión en la comprensión del sacrificio. La obra prolonga las tesis de La violencia y lo sagrado, ofreciendo una lectura teológica y antropológica del mensaje evangélico.

Girard's basic thesis is well known; Human culture arose out of the resolution of mimetic desire. By nature we desire what is desired by others, this leads to conflict and ultimately murder. Institutions and rituals arise out of this act. Girard sees the Gospel texts of the New Testament as a revolutionary exposing of this basic mechanism. However, the church has continued to offer a sacrificial reading of the Gospel which undermines its revelatory potential.
This book is an excellent and accessible overview of his thought. What I found interesting was his conclusion. At the end of the book Girard suggests we suffer most basically from a lack of meaning. I find this to be a bit dissonant from much of his work. Perhaps he is was still too show more heavily influenced by the existential angst that seemed to exist in the middle of the twentieth century but I expected him to move in a much more 'material' direction in his conclusion. Here are some of his parting lines,
"What is important above all is to realize that there are no recipes; there is no pharmakon anymore, not even a Marxist or a psychoanalytic one. Recipes are not what we need, nor do we need to be reassured - our need is to escape from meaninglessness.
. . .
I hold that truth is not an empty word, or a mere 'effect' as people say nowadays. I hold that everything capable of diverting us from madness and death, from now on, is inextricably linked with this truth. But I do not know how to speak about these matters. I can only approach texts and institutions, and relating them to one another seems to me to throw light in every direction.
. . .
Present-day thought is leading us in the direction of the valley of death, and it is cataloguing the bones one by one. All of us are in this valley but it is up to us to resuscitate meaning by relating all the [Judeo-Christian] texts to one another without exception, rather than stopping at just a few of them. All the issues of 'psychological health' seem to me to take second place to a much greater issue - that of meaning which is being lost or threatened on all sides but simply awaits the breath of the Spirit to be reborn."

At which point Girard concludes by quoting Ezekiel 37's vision of the valley of dry bones. show less

100 GIR

Un eccesso di parole per una tesi interessante ma che si basa su fondamenta molto labili, l'autore esplora campi diversi, facendo una cernita molto stretta di singoli esempi che possano sostenere la sua idea, omettendo di aprlare di qualsiasi controesempio che possa mettere in dubbio la tesi. La costruzione del libro si basa su un dialogo a tre voci, ma non c'è contradditorio ne occasione di spunti, è un concerto di tre voci che convergono in una. Anche il ragionamento è molto piatto, alla fine si basa su un empirismo parziale e specialista, privo di profondità universale, per dimostrare una tesi che invece è ontologica, lo trovo un modo fallace di argomentare.
Sulla scrittura (e la relativa traduzione) nulla da dire, sono entrambe show more fatte bene.
Per quello che di interessante c'è da dire bastavano cinquanta pagine, il resto è ridondante e non significativo. show less

Difficile à lire - compliqué - mais la pensée de Girard est intéressante