A Lion Among Men

by Gregory Maguire

The Wicked Years (3)

On This Page

Description

Return to a darker Oz with Gregory Maguire. In A Lion Among Men, the third volume in Maguire's acclaimed, New York Times bestselling series The Wicked Years, a fuller, more complex Cowardly Lion is brought to life and gets to tell his remarkable tale. It is a story of oppression and fear in a world gone mad with war fever—of Munchkins, Wizards, and Wicked Witches—and especially of a gentle soul and determined survivor who is truly A Lion Among Men.


.

Tags

Recommendations

Member Reviews

87 reviews
I'll say this upfront: I think Gregory Maguire is a genius. I get completely carried away when I read his re-take on classic fairy tales.

A Lion Among Men is his third look at Oz (following Wicked, and Son of a Witch). This story looks at the life of Brrr, the cowardly lion and draws a deep and rich profile of this Animal who struggles to make his way in life.

The story involves Brrr, now working for the Emerald City "police", trying to find information about the location of the grimmerie, Elphaba's book of magic. Like the previous two books, Oz is on the cusp of war, with the Munchkins having separated, and disagreements on who should rule both Munchinkinland and Loyal Oz. Against this political back drop, we listen as Brrr speaks with show more the oracle Yackle and learn of their lives.

While Wicked became a musical, this book would be more suited as a stage play. It's less about action and more introspective.

I loved it....bring me another one, soon.

(p.s. For those who like this kind of book, my favourite of Mr. Maguire's books is Mirror, Mirror, based on Snow White.)
show less
Brr, the Cowardly Lion, finds himself trading stories and reminiscences with an old maunt who may hold the key to the Thropp family's destiny.

This is, in many ways, a story about stories; a story about memory and its impact on the present; a story about the connections between people and the need to view each person as an individual, above all else. Brrr, like Elphaba before him, is more than his public persona. Maguire takes us inside his story and lets us see what really went down.

It's beautifully done. My favourite thing about all Maguire's books is the way he takes these flat, stock characters and situations and gives them substance. Brrr isn't perfect. He is rather a coward. But Maguire takes us inside his cowardice and shows us show more what makes him tick. We come to see that it's not a clear-cut case; Brr is a person, (er, Lion), with the same complex motivations and fears that drive us all. He's a product of his past: his forcible removal from his mother, his awkward socialization, his life under the Wizard's anti-Animal regime. Maguire does a brilliant job of showing us why Brrr is the way he is. Like Elphaba and Liir, he's not an entirely likeable character; he messes up, often with disastrous results. But at the end of the day, it's hard not to feel for him.

Oz itself continues to expand beneath Maguire's pen. (Or keyboard, as the case may be). Brrr finally gives us a first-hand look at what Animals go through. We see how they integrate - or fail to integrate - into society, how they were pushed out, what options were open to them in the wake of the Wizard's departure. It's fascinating stuff.

And we get some answers, at long last! Maguire excels at finding and illuminating the connections between his characters, their situations, and the state of the nation, and he uses these connections to drive the story forward. He shows us everything we might need to know and lets us piece it all together for ourselves. The answers found here are more in the line of confirmations, really; many readers will already have guessed portions of the outcome, but it can be nice to hear someone actually come out and say what you already know. And like all the best confirmations, these ones raise a whole host of new questions.

I highly recommend this to anyone who enjoyed the first two books. I wish I'd bought it instead of borrowing it from the library. I realized, midway through, that I've never purchased a new copy of any of Maguire's books. He's given me so many hours of reading enjoyment over the past five years that he most definitely deserves some of my royalties. You can bet I'll be buying the next book, which can't come out quickly enough.

(Rating reduced from 4.5 stars to 3 after my second reading, twelve years later. Early 2021 Me didn’t respond to the same things as Late 2008 Me.)
show less
This is the third book in the "Wicked Years" series from Gregory Maguire. I'm still trying to figure out what I really think about this book and why. As with the previous books, this novel gives us an alternate look at the world of Oz that many of us only know from The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (most likely the Judy Garland movie, but also perhaps the book). I, for one, keep intending to go and read the many Oz books written by L. F. Baum, but sadly I've never done so.

That said, I'm fairly certain that (apart from the high level similarities such as local, character types, etc) Maguire's envisioning of Oz is quite different from Baum's. And that's not necessarily a bad thing…it's just different.

I enjoyed Wicked (book 1), although I show more preferred the hit Broadway play based on the novel. I liked Son of a Witch as a continuation of the story from book 1. It presented an intriguing follow-up to the intrigue and difficulties that were unraveling at the end of the first book.

With book 3, we catch up with the story a few years after book 2 and so in some ways it is a continuation of the saga. However, this book is largely an introspective presented to us by the Cowardly Lion and set alongside a bit of thoughtful backstory from Yackle as well as the slow moving action of the Time Dragon.

As for an overall storyline with rising and falling action, this story strays from the normal mode. The meta story involves a war being waged across the land and presents us with the Lion (Brrrr) interviewing Yackle on a site which will soon be right in the middle of an ensuing battle. The approaching armies add some urgency to the timeliness of their discussion but the war and the battle exist on the periphery so it's difficult to fully gage any rising or falling action or suspense based on the war in Oz.

Instead, we spend most of the time learning the backstory of the Cowardly Lion, beginning from his life in Oz around the same time Elphaba was making her mark and then following his actions up until the present day. Part of the narrative seems to be his search for family or at least for his own "origin story" to try and figure out where he came from and who he was.

The idea of identity figures strongly in the book. Over the years, Brrr has done what he can to stay comfortable and safe but often at the expense of any real definitive action on his part. He constantly finds himself in the middle of predicaments and sometimes he even feels strongly one way or another, but he quite often takes the path of least resistance attempting to avoid confrontation and commitment. His inaction (or sometimes, poorly planned/executed actions) lead to him being constantly slandered and associated with the bad forces around the land. He finds himself accused both of being an ally to Elphaba and and ally to the Wizard in her destruction. Similar paradoxical attributions happen throughout his life.

Brrr introspectively considers what it is that really matters in his life. He contemplates the repercussions of his actions (and inactions) and generally feels like he's let himself down, although he never seemed to have a clear set of expectations for himself.

His mission to interview Yackle is a sort of last-ditch effort to make something of himself…though at the same time, the main motivating factor for endeavoring on the mission is actually one of self-preservation so once again he is very much compelled into action rather than freely and consciously choosing to undertake this action.

By the end of the book, Brrr has a better sense of himself. He's still a bit confused. He's still not fully sure of where he fits in. But at least he's made up his mind to actually DO something….he's thought through some of the consequences of his potential action and decided that whatever the cost, he must do what he believes. And that's key…he finally has a cause he believes in, even if it's just a glimmer of belief.

Often I found the narrative to be an ambling mis-mash of ideas and stories. I kept trying to fit in some sort of larger meta-story or gather a better overall sense of how things were going in the larger world of Oz. But then I realized/decided that this book was more about individuals…personalities….Character….of taking control of our life by deciding WHAT we each want to do and WHY we want to do it…and then having the integrity to DO and LIVE the life we believe in.

So in the end, I felt like this story was more an exploration of the psychology of the individual than about some larger than life war in a fantasy land. That's not the sort of book I was expecting, but it was still an interesting read. I understand there's a 4th book being written in the same world and I'm interested to see where it goes. Maguire's stories (even those with a more "natural" progression/plot) seem intent on exploring human (or Lion) nature. I think if I approach his books with that in mind rather than expecting an adventure story, I'll have a better time. As it was, I didn't hate the book, I just found it more "work" than "entertainment" to read. If you've read it, I'd be interested to hear your thoughts.
show less
He hadn't yet had enough experience with humans to know that the thing they hold dearest to their hearts, the last thing they relinquish when all else is fading, is the consoling belief in the inferiority of others.

Ah...the poor Cowardly Lion (AKA Brrr). He never really had a chance: snatched from his parents as a tiny cub (as seen in Wicked, then thrust back into the forest by well-intentioned Shiz University students too young to really fend for himself. But what happened between then and the arrival of Dorothy? And (ignoring Mr. Baum's sequels) what happened to him after Dorothy's departure? Most of this third novel concerns his story and that of old Yackle, a creation of Mr. Maguire, who keeps showing up in this series, framed show more within their conversation after Brrr is sent (by whom????) to find Yackle and investigate what she knows about Elphaba and her son, Liir.

Nothing really happens until the last 50 pages or so. It's all character development, but fails to make me actually care about the characters. Some ends are tied up (or at least reintroduced), but none of it felt satisfying. I'm hoping that something actually happens in the final book.
show less
While I enjoyed this book more than Son of a Witch, it still cannot quite compare with Wicked itself. Still, we always wondered why the Lion was cowardly, and Maguire provides his past in flashbacks and memories that reveal a cowardice both physical and, more importantly, spiritual. The action is as remarkable and unpredictable as ever, and I was pleased that my favorite characters, the maunts such as Sister Apothecaire, the dwarf and especially Yackle, were given juicy parts. I would certainly recommend this book, and look forward to Out of Oz.
“The time came for her to die, and she would not die; so perhaps she might waste away, they thought, and she did waste, but not away…”—A Lion Among Men”

Some stories tell of great adventures with heroes that sweep in and save the damsel in distress. Some stories tell of frightening mysteries that keep you guessing until the very end. And some stories tell of great romances that transcend time and space. “A Lion Among Men” by Gregory Maguire is none of these.

Instead, “A Lion Among Men” is essentially the memoirs of Brrr the Cowardly Lion. Dispatched by the Emerald City, he is set a task: to find the Grimmerie, the famed source of Elphaba’s powers, which was last seen in her possession. This assignment soon leads him to show more a crazy old woman who’s dubbed herself Yackle. It’s said that she had once been an Oracle and that she also may have had a connection at one time to Elphaba. But what Brr does find when he finally tracks Yackle down is not some high and mighty Oracle, but an old, decrepit, blind, cranky rotting corpse of a woman. Even though Yackle is barely clinging to life like bad Saran-Wrap, she just can’t seem to die. In fact, she’s been trying to walk through death’s door for over a year, but to no avail. Finally locating her, Brr becomes one step closer to completing his assignment for the Emerald City.

That said, I have now just summed up more or less the entire plot of this “A Lion Among Men,” which as you can see only took 132 words, 9 lines and one paragraph. The other three hundred and eight pages of the book, less one paragraph, were unfortunately about as exciting as what the quote above described. The book would just not die, even though it was way past its time. So maybe it would waste away leaving behind a good story. Ultimately, it did waste away, just not into a good story.

The rest of “A Lion Among Men”, a supposed accounting of the Cowardly Lion’s life, consisted of Brrr (not the most creative of names and Maguire doesn’t even give a great explanation for it) wandering through the woods trying to find Yackle, or some goal along those lines. Now for anyone who has ever read a book that was comprised of the main characters walking endlessly through the woods, you know it can be a potential disaster, or even worse, an exercise in extreme boredom. Well, “A Lion Among Men” was no different than every other novel that has crashed and burned at the roots of the boredom tree. A tree that the characters, I wish, had tripped over, for it would have been more exciting than what was going on in the plot line. (Note to authors: characters walking through the woods for the entirety of the story is fictional suicide. So spare all your devoted readers and think of something with a pulse!)

Aside from the wandering-in-the-woods syndrome “A Lion Among Men” seems to suffer from, it’s also plagued with a myriad of other issues. What little plot line there is in the novel is entwined with a sickening amount of flourish, producing garish prose that says nothing at all. Any part of the story that could be deciphered was often buried in painful dialogue that accomplished absolutely nothing and was incomprehensible to those of us who live in the real world and not Munchkinland.

“A Lion Among Men” can’t even claim to have the same vulgar and appalling nature that ran rampant through Maguire’s other two books in the series, “Wicked” and “Son of a Witch.” It was immensely disappointing that the novel didn’t even have these less than kosher aspects to possibly enliven it. At least the inclusion of these adult qualities may have provided a reprieve to a storyline that ended up being less exciting than even watching paint dry.

Last word:
“A Lion Among Men” is reputed to be the story of Brrr the Cowardly Lion’s life. So based on the novel then, Brr must have lived an incredibly mind-numbing and dull life. By the time I finished trudging my way through this snooze-fest, I could not find any redeeming qualities to the novel. If only I could get those hours of my life back…
show less
The final book of Gregory Maguire's trilogy loses none of the magic and bite of Wicked and flows more easily than Son of a Witch, perhaps because it doesn't get lost in the dungeons of Emerald City as that one did. Maguire's prose is itself often magical. We see starry nights as amazing as Van Gogh's, hear music from oak string trees, and see characters morfing as in an Anime film or even a cartoon. The amazing assortment of characters continue: dwarfs, Munchkins, Animals, animals, winged women, but, with no Elphaba, no green ones.

The satires on society and politics continue, and, to them, is added religion. He makes an interesting--and clever case for the impossibility of their being music in heaven, centered on the fact that music is show more time-based and heaven is not. (If I understood him, or rather the character who said it, correctly.)

There is one brilliantly erotic scene between Animals of different species. The paragraphs on food are mouthwatering, although one can hardly reproduce the meals this side of Oz.

It's strange that I loved these books as, even as a child, I never read fairy tales, or the Oz books. I did read reality based kids' series like The Bobbsey Twins, Heidi, and all of Louisa May Alcott. I also read all the adult novels in my parents' library since I was blessedly unattended most of the time.

The only book I did read that treated animals as people was a curiosity in my parents' library called, Lightfoot the Leaping Goat, which, along with Heidi and the Alcott books, I read and reread at least fifty times each. I can't explain that aberration. Nor can I explain the aberration of The Wicked Years. I don't like fantasy. Nor do I like science fiction. Do you ever wonder why you like the books you do? It's not only their artistic worth, although Maguire's prose is very fine, very vivid, wickedly satiric, but never with a bludgeon.
show less

Members

Recently Added By

Lists

Animals in the Title
498 works; 11 members
Books Read in 2016
4,666 works; 199 members
Books Read in 2008
336 works; 8 members
All Things Oz
32 works; 2 members
Books Read in 2019
4,052 works; 108 members

Author Information

Picture of author.
67+ Works 80,621 Members
Gregory Maguire was born June 9, 1954 in Albany, New York. He received a B.A. from the State University of New York at Albany and a Ph.D. in English and American literature from Tufts University. He is a founder and co-director of Children's Literature New England, Incorporated, a non-profit educational charity established in 1987. He writes for show more both adults and children. His first book, The Lighting Time, was published in 1978. His adult works include Wicked, Confessions of and Ugly Stepsister, Lost, Mirror Mirror, Son of a Witch, and A Lion Among Men. The Broadway play Wicked is based on his book of the same title. His children's books include the picture book Crabby Cratchitt, the novel The Good Liar, and the Hamlet Chronicles series. (Bowker Author Biography) show less

Some Editions

McDonough, John (Narrator)
Smith, Douglas (Illustrator)

Awards and Honors

Series

Work Relationships

Common Knowledge

Canonical title
A Lion Among Men
Original title
A Lion Among Men
Original publication date
2008-10-14
People/Characters
Cantle Osqa'ami; Mother Yackle; Madame Morrible; Elphaba Thropp; Liir Thropp; Mr. Boss (show all 25); Nor Tigelaar; Grimalkin the Cat; Jemmsy; Brrr; Tenniken; Cubbins; Queen Ursaless; Traum; Muhlama H'aekeem; Chief Uyodor H'aekeem; Dorothy Gale; Nick Chopper; Wizard of Oz; Mister Mikko; Professor Lenx; Melena Thropp; Nessarose Thropp; Cattery Spunge; Fiyero Tigelaar
Important places
Oz; Shiz, Gillikin Country; Emerald City; Munchkinland
Epigraph
The moment one definitely commits oneself, then Providence moves as well. All sorts of things occur to help one that would never otherwise have occurred. A stream of events issues from the decision, raising in one's favor all... (show all) manner of unforeseen accidents, meetings, and material assistance that no one could have dreamed would come their way. Whatever you can do or dream you can do, begin it. Boldness has genius, power and magic in it. Begin it now.
- Goethe, by attribution
A statement about luck is a statement about the mind, not about the world. . . . We find what seems to have been the lucky break or the big mistake, and so we thank our lucky stars that we took the road less traveled or curse... (show all) the fates that sent that little wavelet that flipped us on our backs. With hindsight, we seem to see that everything preceding the pivotal point was leading up to it, tending toward it, and that everything following it grew from it.
To any observer outside the lucky one himself, however, luck is simply chance. Chance is neutral.
- Eric Kraft, "I Consider My Luck,"
from Brothers and Beasts:
An Anthology of Men on Fairy Tales
Dedication
For Maurice Sendak
King of all wild things
First words
The time came for her to die, and she would not die, so perhaps she might waste away, they thought, and she did waste, but not away; and the time came for her to receive final absolution, so they set candles upon her clavicle... (show all), but this she would not allow.
Last words
(Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)But the clouds suggested this only to themselves, while he kept his head down, bent to his task.

Classifications

Genres
Fiction and Literature, General Fiction, Fantasy
DDC/MDS
813.54Literature & rhetoricAmerican literature in EnglishAmerican fiction in English1900-19991945-1999
LCC
PS3563 .A3535 .L56Language and LiteratureAmerican literatureAmerican literatureIndividual authors1961-
BISAC

Statistics

Members
5,045
Popularity
2,774
Reviews
83
Rating
½ (3.33)
Languages
English, Portuguese, Spanish
Media
Paper, Audiobook, Ebook
ISBNs
29
ASINs
16