Stormy's Hat: Just Right for a Railroad Man

by Eric A. Kimmel

On This Page

Description

As Stormy, a railroad engineer, searches for the perfect hat--one that will not blow off, get too hot, or shade his eyes too much--his wife, Ida, becomes increasingly annoyed that he will not let her help. Includes a historical note about the real Stormy and Ida Kromer.

Tags

Recommendations

Member Recommendations

kthomp25 Story of the creation of the cowboy Stetson hat

Member Reviews

8 reviews
Prolific picture-book author Eric A. Kimmel teams up with illustrator Andrea U'Ren to tell the story of the Stormy Kromer cap, a type of hat invented in 1903 by Ida Kromer, the wife of train engineer George "Stormy" Kromer. As Stormy tries out one type of headwear after the other - a derby, a cowboy hat, a pressman's hat, a fireman's hat - he finds that every one has some drawback, and simply doesn't work for him, in his job setting. His wife Ida, who has been trying to get him to listen to her ideas, finally loses her temper, and in the discussion afterward, they come up with the perfect idea, based on Stormy's needs: a modified baseball cap that would stay on his head, not occlude his vision, and resist fire. The hat was so effective show more that soon other trainmen were asking Stormy if Ida could make them similar hats...

Although many of Kimmel's books are retellings of various folk and fairy-tales, Stormy's Hat: Just Right for a Railroad Man is an exception, presenting a fictionalized version of a true story. The Stormy Kromer cap is still used by many railroad workers today, and has also become a part of the traditional clothing worn in some regions of the United States. The version with flaps is very popular in the American Midwest, particularly in Michigan. I enjoyed the story here, which highlights both the way in which necessity is the mother of invention, and the importance of listening to the ideas of those around us. Stormy's continual dismissal of Ida's attempts to help demonstrate that when we fail to do the latter, we could be losing out on potential solutions to our problems. The accompanying artwork from U'Ren is expressive, and really captures both Stormy's distress and Ida's growing impatience. Recommended to all young train lovers, and to anyone looking for children's stories about invention, clothing (specifically, headwear), and the importance of communication.
show less
It's Kimmel, but it's not a folktale. It's got 'railroad' in its title, but there's not a whole lot about trains. What it mostly is, is an interesting episode in history, and a nod to a woman's ability to cleverly problem-solve.

If Temple Grandin had known this story, she may well have included it in [b:Calling All Minds: How to Think and Create Like an Inventor|36717955|Calling All Minds How to Think and Create Like an Inventor|Temple Grandin|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1517984414l/36717955._SX50_.jpg|58513783]. Grandin sews and could make the railroad man's hat... and one of the other suggestions to Stormy was a pressman's hat, which is folded paper, which any of us can make.

The interior show more illustrations are, imo, much more appealing than the cover. I would never have picked this off the shelf, but since it's by Kimmel, I requested it, and I am very glad that I did. show less
As Stormy, a railroad engineer, searches for the perfect hat--one that will not blow off, get too hot, or shade his eyes too much--his wife, Ida, becomes increasingly annoyed that he will not let her help. Includes a historical note about the real Stormy and Ida Kromer.
½
Stormy loves trains and loves everything about them but he hates that he can;t find the perfect hat. So he goes to see all his friends who work for different occupations. Either their hat gives him a head ache, catches on fire, or blows away. He goes home to visit his wife who tries to give his advice and finally Stormy listen. She gets Stormy to close his eyes and describe the hat. His wife makes the perfect hat and years later the hat still lives on.
This book tells of Stormy's diffcult task at finding a hat to wear to his engineering job and how the railmans blue cap came into existence. Wether your students are into trains and things of that nature this would be a good book to share because it give insight on a little bit of history .
This is a true story about George Kromer who worked on a train that and had issues with keeping a hat on while he was working. He tried different ones, but none worked. They were too big, heavy, or not durable enough. His wife has an idea to make him the perfect hat. Her idea is successful and ahe being selling them to all the other train conductors. Her hats are still worn today by train conductors.
Stormy was a real rail road man... tells about his real life at the end of the book. He can't find a hat for his rail road job so he try different ones. In the end his wife makes one for him and that becomes the 'railroad hat' of today. Set in older setting.

Members

Recently Added By

Published Reviews

ThingScore 100
CCBC (Cooperative Children's Book Center Choices 2009)
Railroad engineer Stormy Kromer drives the Red Stack line from St. Paul to Chicago. He loves his work, but he doesn’t love his hat. In fact, he doesn’t love any of them. His derby hat blows off in the wind when the train goes into a tunnel. The paper pressman’s hat he tries bursts into flame from a rogue cinder. Every night he comes show more home and complains, and every night his wife, Ida, tries to help, but Stormy always interrupts: “Aw, don’t you worry your pretty little head . . . I’ll figure out something.” The night Stormy comes home with a pounding headache from the heavy fireman’s hat he’s borrowed, Ida has had enough. “My head isn’t little. It’s as big as yours. Either listen to what I have to say, or stop complaining.” And what Ida, who turns out to be a seamstress, has to say is that she can make him the perfect hat—she just needs him to describe what it should look like. Eric A. Kimmel’s droll picture book tells the (mostly) true story of how the traditional railroad workers’ hat came to be. Andrea U’ren’s terrific illustrations perfectly complement the humor while making it clear all along that Ida may be able to give Stormy exactly what he’s looking for. CCBC Category: Picture Books for School-Age Children. 2008, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 32 pages, $16.95. Ages 5-8. show less
Cooperative Children's Book Center Choices
added by kthomp25

Author Information

Picture of author.
142+ Works 16,866 Members
Eric Kimmel was born in Brooklyn, NY in 1946. He received a bachelor's degree in English Literature from Lafayette College. He also has a Ph.D. in Education from the University of Illinois. He was an elementary school teacher and college professor before becoming a full-time writer. He has published over fifty titles, many of which have won state show more and national awards. His titles "Hershel and the Hanukkah Goblins" won the Caldecott Honor Medal, "The Chanukkah Guest" and "Gershon's Monster" won the Sydney Taylor Picture Book Award and "Anansi and the Talking Melon" won the Utah Children's Choice Award. Kimmel travels nationally and internationally visiting schools and talking about his books and telling stories. (Bowker Author Biography) show less

Some Editions

U'Ren, Andrea (Illustrator)

Awards and Honors

Common Knowledge

Classifications

Genre
Children's Books
LCC
PZ7 .K5648 .SLanguage and LiteratureFiction and juvenile belles lettresFiction and juvenile belles lettresJuvenile belles lettres
BISAC

Statistics

Members
37
Popularity
778,581
Reviews
8
Rating
½ (3.67)
Languages
English, French
Media
Paper
ISBNs
3