The Republic of Love

I think I must have overlooked this at the time because it was the novel Shields wrote immediately before her two big international successes, The Stone diaries and Larry's Party. A shame, but anyway, better late than never - it seems to have aged very well. It's a clever, ironic look at the way rational and irrational thinking get mixed up with each other in our lives, and the compromises and suspensions of disbelief that we have to make to get them to work together. (Or, to put it another way, a thinly-disguised romantic comedy!) Enjoyable as an entertainment, and probably full of little in-jokes for anyone who knows Winnipeg, but also occasionally quite thought-provoking.
Something that only really struck me when I'd finished the show more book was how cleverly Shields manages to tell us the key story about the older characters - her own contemporaries - whilst making us think that it's all about the young(ish) central characters. show less

One is the loneliest number. And boy does it take a long time to get to two. This was the first Shields book I was exasperated by. Chapter after chapter filled with the quotidian minutiae of both Tom and Fay. It’s no secret they will get together, but it does seem to take forever. And considering their close orbits and near misses, it’s a bit of a wonder that it does. Their connection is reasonably direct, but it still takes a bit of chance to get it going.

I did like how Shields made Fay a bit unconventional. She made decisions that I didn’t predict given my prejudice regarding ‘love stories’ and their storytelling crutches. I should have known better with this writer, but there you go.

There are the usual moments of beautiful show more prose and a terrific sense of the absurd. The mere idea of a folklore center is wonderful as is Fay’s job as an Associate Folklorist. Delicious - “She is a woman plagued with information, burdened with it, and always checking an impulse to pass it on to others. Is Peter Knightly, her lover of a thousand wasted days, aware that in certain Slavic villages young men on Good Friday fashion squirt guns from reeds and spray each other with water, and that this, of course, has strong sexual implications?” p 22

And Tom’s job, though more tangible, is just as odd and romantic - he’s a nighttime DJ who hosts an eclectic and popular show of his own device. He loves a good routine and condemns himself for his three failed marriages. Luckily he’s not self-pitying.

Here are some more of Shield's gems -

“But he {Tom} has no children, no relatives, no property, none of the blown aftermath other people attach to their arrangements.” p 241

“He set an eave of muffin afloat in his coffee…” p 78

“What Fay uncovers are mostly fragments, blurred visions, partial accounts, and even these tentative offerings are underpinned by the suggestion of hard drink, and the deceptive algebra of the imagination trying to make a story out of the absence of linearity.” p 195

“Tom puts this question to himself, finding it more speculative and interesting than the issue of hypochondria, a shameful condition boiled out of ego and abetted by loneliness.” p 391

“Was she shriveling up inside her jangling singleness?” p 283 show less

Spoiler-free summary:
Fay McLeod, a folklorist studying mermaids, wakes up one morning to quite simply realize that she does not love her partner of three years. Tom Avery, a late-night radio host who was raised by 27 mothers, has been married and divorced three times. Both, despite their infinite connections to the city, are alone, drifting through the familiar streets of Winnipeg, surrounded by a complex web of acquaintances and memories. Carol Shields' The Republic of Love chronicles their tumultuous paths toward love and happiness, which may or may not go hand in hand.

.....

I am so surprised (and somewhat ashamed) that I had not heard of Carol Shields or The Republic of Love before receiving this ARC from Open Road Media. Apparently a show more movie was made based on the book and Shields won the 1995 Pulitzer Prize for her novel The Stone Diaries. After beginning the novel, it really did not come as a shock to learn that Shields was such a revered writer. This book definitely stands out from other books I've reviewed. It is polished, amazing, beautiful, astounding - I could go on and on. I loved this book.

This novel, I've decided, is what I will hand out when and if people ask me, "What is love?" Love is a wordless, messy, nonsensical thing that, somehow, Carol Shields has been able to describe in a beautiful, witty novel. How? I keep asking myself, "how?" I want to pass this novel out to my friends, my family, my ex-boyfriends, everyone, with the hope that they will understand me better when they're finished.

It's sweet and romantic, but it is also devastating and disturbing. Shields does not sugar coat things that we are accustomed to being sugary sweet. People do things in this novel that make no sense and they hurt one another and it's fabulous because it's true. Shields spends just as much time describing the dark underbelly of love as she does describing the beauty and happiness of it. I liked that. A lot.

I loved the language - the novel is written in beautiful, rhythmic prose. Moments of complete incomprehension and unhappiness are described with succinct grace. Tom and Fay both had their own clearly defined voice, which I appreciated.

Please, read this novel.


www.bookpuke.com show less

Another airport book purchase (can't stand the thought of a long flight without a book to read). Picked it up from the 'Canadian fiction' section in the bookshop at Toronto Pearson International. It was a perfect choice: kept me absorbed while waiting for the plane, while flying and while waiting for the next flight. It's a fairly straightforward love story, with interesting asides about mermaids thrown in. Both the lead characters struck me as a bit drippy (sorry) and in need of a good shake at times and I wasn't completely convinced by the storyline involving the elderly parents of the female protagonist. But those are minor gripes - it was a good read and painted a realistic picture of Winnipeg through the changing seasons.

The Republic of Love is the story of two people: Tom and Fay. Tom is forty years old and thrice divorced. Every week he attends meetings for the newly single, although he is no longer fresh out of a relationship. His life is filled primarily by these meetings, a few awkward dates and his career as a night-time disc jockey. Fay has never married, although she has come close a couple of times; She has, however, been in a number of years-long relationships. For some reason, neither Tom nor Fay seems able to make their romantic relationships stick.

I own several of Carol Shields' novels, but this is the first one I have gotten around to reading. Incidentally, Carol Shields is an alumna of my alma mater, Hanover College. Pretty much our only show more famous one (unless you count good ol' Woody Harrelson, who may or may not have actually graduated - I think he got an honorary degree subsequently).

The writing is quite highbrow, full of five dollar words and complicated sentences. This does make a rather nice change from all of the teen fiction I have been reading. For the most part, I really loved her writing style. Every so often, a particular sentence would strike me as a bit over the top, as though big words had been used solely for the sake of using big words.

The narrative of the story moves along at a good pace, especially through the first half of the book. The format of the story, which follows the two main characters in alternating chapters, propels the reader forward, curious to discover how and when they will actually meet. I really loved the thought-provoking ideas about love, serendipity, marriage and being single that are woven throughout this novel. The theme of the interconnectedness of people's lives and the degrees of separation was particularly fascinating. It reminded me a lot of a slightly darker and more literary version of When Harry Met Sally, only not the plot with Billy Crystal and Meg Ryan. It called to mind the little insert stories about how people met.

I highly recommend this to literary fiction fans. For those who like easy reads, not so much. This is an excellent novel (thank goodness, since I do own several more by Shields!). show less

Tom Avery, a forty-year old thrice-married late night DJ in Winnipeg and Fay McCloud, a thirty-five year old academic specializing in the mythology of mermaids who has had serial relationships but never married, fall in love.

It’s complicated. The age, the marriage history, the academic world, the opinions and advice of family and friends all contribute to the complications. And then Fay’s father, in a seemingly perfect marriage for 40 years decides to leave his wife.

It is a well told story and one of the interesting devices Shields uses is to employ dialogue in a narrative fashion. An event happens and then we hear from a flock of Tom or Fay’s friends and families. It’s not back and forth dialogue – it’s more like show more listening to someone’s voicemail messages or overhearing someone talk on the phone. You only get half the conversation, but it’s is still clear what’s being said.

Engaging story.
show less

Whilst I've enjoyed all of the Carol Shields books I've read, I think The Republic of Love' is the one I've most related to. The story, and intimate detail, of a couple coming together and the influences of their families, friends, colleagues and general environment is just so real. The story's beauty is it's detail, a small aside , a pause, transformating awareness that takes place in the blink of an eye.