Agnes of God: A Drama

by John Pielmeier (Playwright)

On This Page

Description

In this contemporary murder mystery set within the confines of a convent, Agnes is a devout, innocent young nun accused of infanticide. As a psychiatrist (herself a lapsed Catholic) and the Mother Superior struggle over Agnes’ fate, the play plunges into the mystery of faith and the consequence of truth.

.

Tags

Recommendations

Member Reviews

5 reviews
Solid drama that takes a 'murder mystery' involving a newborn and its conception through all the expected and not so expected paces you'd assume of a convent setting. It didn't quite sell the miraculous turn for me, or rather the desperately held denial of the nun, but the human tragedy was extremely well told and acted. The inclusion of hypnotism says a lot about when the play was authored, and it's very dated in the views on psychology - so you have to take it for what seemed plausible in the 70s.
An audio production of the play. When a baby is found strangled with its own umbilical cord in the room of Agnes a young nun at a local convent, a psychiatrist who is also a lapsed Catholic, is called in to determine whether Agnes is criminally responsible. As the psychiatrist interviews both the Mother Superior and Agnes repeatedly to get to the bottom of what happened that night she will be forced to grapple with issues of faith and the possibility of miracles.

All three actresses in this production are powerhouses and make all of the emotions palpable to the listener. Compelling not only as a mystery but as a character study.
This is a very powerful play about the clash between fact and faith.

Dr. Martha Livingstone is a court appointed psychiatrist sent to discover what happend when an infant born to a young nun is found strangled. Her examination of Sister Agnes and conversations with Mother Miriam spark a debate on miracles and the art of what is possible with faith.
The fascinating confrontation between unbroken faith and atheism; a battle of beliefs which will leave you wanting more.
½
It considers, or pretends to consider, some of the most basic questions of human morality and treats them on the simple, lightweight and foreseable level of Eleanor H Porter's Pollyana. Agnes of God offers little besides its jury-rigged suspense. Despite all the anguished huffing and puffing, there isn't a single authentic moment in it, and all you're left with in the end is the fading memory of two overscaled characters.
½
Jan 15, 2026English (UK)

Members

Recently Added By

Lists

AP Lit
363 works; 6 members
Next Plays / 2025
352 works; 1 member

Author Information

Playwright
20+ Works 707 Members

Awards and Honors

Work Relationships

Common Knowledge

Canonical title
Agnes of God: A Drama
Original publication date
1982
People/Characters
Agnes; Mother Miriam; Dr. Livingstone
Related movies
Agnes of God (1985 | IMDb)
Epigraph
...why do you worry? What good would it do you if I told you she is indeed a saint? I cannot make saints, nor can the Pope. We can only recognize saints when the plainest evidence shows them to be saintly. If you think her a ... (show all)saint, she is a saint to you. What more do you ask? That is what we call the reality of the soul; you are foolish to demand the agreement of the world as welll...But it is the miracles that concern me. What you say takes no account of the miracles. Oh, miracles! They happen everywhere. They are conditional...Miracles are things that people cannot explain...Miracles depend much on time, and place, and what we know and do not know...Life is too great a miracle for us to make so much fuss about petty little reversals of what we pompously assume to be the natural order...Who is she? That is what you must discover...and you must find your answer in psychological trugh, not in objective truth...And while you are searching, get on with your own life and accept the possibility that it may be purchased at the price of hers and that this may be God's plan for you and her. -- Robertson Davies, Fifth Business
Dedication
To the Lady
First words
I remember when I was a child I went to see Garbo's Camille, oh, at least five or six times.
Last words
(Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)Wouldn't it?

Classifications

Genre
Fiction and Literature
DDC/MDS
812.54Literature & rhetoricAmerican literature in EnglishAmerican drama in English20th Century1945-1999
LCC
PS3566 .I3815 .A7Language and LiteratureAmerican literatureAmerican literatureIndividual authors1961-
BISAC

Statistics

Members
218
Popularity
149,161
Reviews
5
Rating
½ (3.72)
Languages
English
Media
Paper, Audiobook, Ebook
ISBNs
7
UPCs
1
ASINs
8