I Am the Dog I Am the Cat

The text is neither a dialogue nor a narrative, but a choppy list. I've enjoyed other poetry by Hall, but not this one so much. The pictures seem straightforward to me, too, nothing special. Also, please, if you're expecting a delivery, restrain your dog before the carrier trips and gets hurt. Two stars means 'it was ok' and that's how much I appreciated this book.

Fun Dog and Cat altercations - wish they had gone deeper...

Humorous book with beautiful illustrations. Common characteristics of both animals compared and make you laugh as you recognize them in your own pet!

I didn't really like this book. The illustrations were lame, and there seemed to be no meat to the story. Basically the dog and the cat traded turns bantering back and forth about what made them a cat or what made them a dog. Some of the dialogue was amusing but mostly it was just generic banter. I wouldn't recommend this book. In fact, if this book were purchased for a child, I would be willing to bet that the book would end up destroyed because nobody would care about its existence.

this book is a fun children's book, that both dog and cat lovers can enjoy. The book describes the different routines that the dog and cat have. It has great illustration that show off both animals personalities.

This is a story narrative of the events of an average day of both a cat and a dog. It is told by both of the animals together from their perspectives. The dog described how loyal he is and how he protects the home and sleeps at night. The cat described how she stays up all night searching for mice, and watches all the birds during the day when she isn't napping. They were in competition about their roles in the household, and who does more and is more important.

rating: 3.6 stars

media: watercolor on handmade paper