Flames Across the Border: 1813-1814

When I was in middle school, we studied the War of 1812, and the course seemed to last longer than the actual war. So you'd think I would be somewhat familiar with the events in this book, which covers the second half of the conflict. Either I repressed the memories or our class really only stopped after Queenston Heights, because I learned so much by reading this, and enjoyed it to boot. A lot of the battles Berton covers here were really only just names to me -- Lundy's Lane, Crysler's Farm, the Battle of the Thames, the Battle of Stoney Creek -- but with his present-tense, front-and-centre view of the action, the conflicts come to life. He relies on primary sources for the vast majority of his dialogue, which adds an even more show more authentic flavour. Leaders on all sides receive credit or blame where such is due; on the whole I would say it is a balanced portrayal.

I wouldn't have expected this going in, but my favourite part was the Battle of Lake Erie and the other naval campaigns. The maps provided for these parts of the book were extremely helpful and Berton's accounts were especially fascinating. I attribute it to having picked up C.S. Forester earlier this year.

The afterword and the very end of the last chapter were very poignant, talking about the utter waste that a great deal of the war was. Thousands died horrifically, but to read the treaty is to see that a lot of the major issues for which they were actually fighting don't even get a look-in. Impressment, the big issue for the Americans, was quietly dropped from the treaty negotiations (it had ceased to be an issue once the British defeated Napoleon at Waterloo), and of course the First Nations and Native Americans were utterly betrayed. The contrast between the bloody battles and diplomatic dithering is striking.

This is a big book but the pages almost turn themselves once you get into the groove. Recommended for history buffs, particularly those who like naval battles (à la C.S. Forester). And if you live in southwestern Ontario or along the Great Lakes, this is a thrilling look at the history in your backyard. show less

This picks up where "The Invasion of Canada" ended, at the beginning of 1813. The American forces continue to suffer a string of defeats or hollow victories until the battle at Fort Stephenson, the first significant British blunder. William Henry Harrison, the future president, proved himself the most capable of America's military leaders in this era, but otherwise the United States continued to suffer bad leadership. The leaders of Canada's successful defence went similarly sour whenever they crossed the border.

Reading about battle after battle could have been exhausting, but Berton always finds the telling detail or human interest angle that makes every story unique and engaging, and he uses adequate foreshadowing to tie every event show more to the bigger picture. The peace negotiations were just as interesting to read about. Initially the British demanded a buffer state for the native American population. They knuckled under pretty fast on that point, but just imagine if it had happened?

Battles cover a wider range of locations including York (Toronto), the Niagara peninsula (including Lundy's Lane), Ohio, Quebec, Washington and ending with Plattsburgh (some events are not covered in detail, e.g. Baltimore, New Orleans.) There's a couple of navy battles full of honour and blood. Maps in these books have been very helpful and plentiful, placing the locations in their historical context and clearly indicating the troop movements and points of conflict. It was an awkward tale to tell, "bloody and senseless", but Pierre Berton has done it ample justice. show less

Not a professional treatise on the war, but a good read with some elements of social history. The later 1812 war without the mythological figures of Tecumseh and Brock, but still, part of the library of those who wish to know Canada.

This was the first book I ever purchased on the War of 1812. I had difficulty with Berton's narrative style at first, which is in the present tense. Nevertheless, Berton's account of the most important battles in Canada--Chippewa, Lundy's Lane, the burning of York are all quite good, and are accompanied by helful maps.

Berton also draws in actions outside the Canadian to contribute to the context they occurred in, and emphasizing their relative importance.

Good descriptions and details.

this was better than the first book. but wouldn't recommend it. it's so long.

Excellent read!!