Ada Buisson (1839–1866)

Christmas Ghost Stories: Classic Victorian Tales for Cold Winter Nights
Rating: 4.5 / 5

This is an exceptionally well-curated and well-framed collection. I enjoyed it far more than I expected, and I read it quickly—one of those books where the momentum sneaks up on you.

Wells’s introduction does real work, not just scene-setting. It clearly explains why Christmas became a season for ghost stories: long nights, enforced domestic closeness, cold, ritual, memory, and the tension between show more comfort and unease. That framing carries through the whole book. Each story is preceded by its own introduction, and those are just as valuable—brief but intelligent discussions of the author, the historical moment, and what kind of horror you’re about to encounter.

What I appreciated most is the range Wells highlights without flattening it. There’s domestic horror, where the threat is inside the home and the family structure itself. There’s horror of the unseen, horror of the half-seen, and horror that relies on implication rather than spectacle. There’s even room for a lighter, almost comic piece—something to relieve the pressure so the evening doesn’t become relentlessly grim. That balance feels very true to how these stories were originally told and consumed.

The standout for me was The Nurse’s Story, which remains one of the most chilling Christmas ghost stories ever written, precisely because the person in danger is a lonely child rather than a reckless adult. The collection as a whole reinforces how often Victorian ghost stories are about neglect, moral coldness, and quiet failures of care, rather than monsters.

The only story that did not work for me was The Brown Hand. The problem isn’t the premise—it’s the ending. After setting up a haunting rooted in colonial exploitation and bodily violation, the resolution feels evasive. The ghost is effectively tricked, which undermines the story’s own moral argument. Instead of reckoning, the narrative opts for reassurance, and that sits badly alongside the book’s broader themes about consequence and responsibility.

That single misfire aside, this is an excellent anthology. Wells respects the reader, trusts the material, and gives just enough context to deepen the experience without explaining the fear away. It’s thoughtful, unsettling, and very satisfying to read in winter, when darkness comes early and the house feels a little too quiet.

Highly recommended for readers who like their ghost stories intelligent, historically grounded, and morally sharp. show less

Eight excellent Victorian ghost stories are presented as prime examples of ghost stories told on Christmas Eve. As the title suggests this is a book focused on the tradition of telling Ghost stories on Christmas Eve and the selection of stories is excellent. The authors included is a who’s who of genre and includes Elizabeth Gaskell, Ada Buisson, Charlotte Riddell, Ameila Edwards, M. R. James, E. F. Benson, Arthur Conan Doyle and Jerome K. Jerome.

Each story is preceded by an introductory show more section that I insisted on reading only after reading the story. These story specific commentaries are useful discussions on the nature of the story concerned and support the editor’s intention of presenting the stories in a sequence that revealed the differing natures of ghost stories.

The overall introduction to the volume talks about the tradition of telling ghost stories on Christmas Eve. The final conclusion is a good summary of the evolution of such tales and how both the tellers and listeners participating in the practice were affected by the stories. The final story by Jerome K. Jerome is a humorous look at the behaviours of the people involved in one such story telling session and is well worth the read.

I recommend this selection as a good collection of ghost stories and suggest reading the stories in the sequence presented. This was an enjoyable read. show less

I was expecting something old-fashioned, and that’s exactly what it delivers, in a good way. Back in Victorian times, it was a tradition to read aloud and share ghost stories at Christmas, and this collection captures that spirit perfectly.

These eight stories are quiet and atmospheric, relying more on mood than on shock. The stories alone would have made for a good book, but what truly elevates it are the foreword, introductions, and illustrations.

I enjoyed the foreword and the show more introductions as much as, if not more than, the stories themselves. Without them, I feel the book would not have had the same impact and would not be as enjoyable.

They provide background information before each tale, helping to place the author and the stories within their historical context and making the reading experience more meaningful.

The illustrations are black-and-white sketches that add to the atmosphere and help draw the reader into the world of each story. They feel like part of the stories, not just something extra.

I feel a hard copy of this book would be a treasure to own or to give as a gift, something you’d want to keep on your shelf and return to year after year, perhaps even starting a new family tradition of reading one of the stories outloud at Christmas.

I believe a hard copy of this book would be a treasure to own or to give as a gift — something you’d want to keep on your shelf and return to year after year, perhaps even starting a new family tradition of reading one of the stories each Christmas. show less

This thoughtfully put together anthology of Christmas-related ghost stories was thoroughly enjoyable. All the stories are public-domain and can be read individually and cost-free, however, the background information provided for each story and their authors make this a very worthwhile read.