K. M. Kostyal

This book is much more than a look at a key battle during the civil war. This book, targeted to grades 3-6, provides a wonderfully robust overview of what the civil war was about, and what fanned the flames of the battles that tore the new country apart.

Of the 48 total pages, only a handful are focused on the key battle at Fredericksburg. The book points out that there were numerous skirmishes, run-ins and battles at and near the strategically placed town in northern Virginia, which is only show more 50 miles from the capital cities of both the North (D.C.) and South (Richmond).

The book is enhanced by many full color photos of a myriad of reenactments...soldiers in battle, as well as civilians in different situations. But the real win of the book is the incorporation of text pulled from letters and memoirs from those that were there.

Taken from the writings of one John Washington, a slave who fled to the safety of Union soldiers during the battle, we learn first-hand what it was like: "...in an instant all Was Wild confusion as a calvaryman dashed into the Dining Room and said 'the yankees is in Falmouth..." Author Kostyal chose to reprint Washington's writings with no editing which gives the reading a very real vibe.

A white woman who fled from Frereicksburg as the battle was starting wrote, "I am afraid of the lawless Yankee Soldiers but that is nothing to my fear of the negroes if they should rise against us."

The quotes add a vivid realism to this rather simple book, and combined with the photos fulfill a very "National Geographic" look at history.

Kostyal writes about slavery and writes about it's role in dividing the country. She also writes on the battle itself which the South won by killing 13,000 Union soldiers.

I highly recommend this book. show less

This book offers a fresh perspective on the American Revolution through reenacted photographs from the Colonial Williamsburg Foundation. e photographs provide insight about people le out of history books: the farmers, the blacksmiths, the women, and enslaved people.

What may have once been intriguing and breathtaking photographs are in many cases blended into one amorphous montage that is cumbersome to look at and aesthetically unappealing. Information supplied within the book is cursory and provides little satisfaction or knowledge. As a result, the book fails to fill the role of either a coffee table article of interest or a material for individual scholarly reading. This is unfortunate because one senses that the photos would have been strong on show more their own if left untouched. The book feels like a heavily edited "Xtreme" TV segment, complete with rapid scene transitions, rocky handheld camera work, quick changes of focus, gravelly narration, and drum and bass soundtrack. Fail. show less

This book not only clearly and concisely describes the events of the Civil War as they affected Fredricksburg, Virginia, crucially located halfway between Washington D.C. and Richmond, it also adds good visuals. Photographs were taken of reenacters, and while they look somewhat posed, they make the people seem less different than old, faded and blurry photographs do. There are also a few excerpts of letters or memoirs of people on either side of the war -- even two from a slave who ran away show more and met the Union Army as they approached Fredricksburg. show less