David Robertson (1)

This is the best answer to Dawkins' "God Delusion" that I have read - certainly better than McGrath. It originated a series of open letters posted on the internet (and soon linked from Dawkins' own webpages) where Church of Scotland minister David Robertson responded chapter by chapter to Dawkins' book. He is polite, engages in the debate, agrees with much of what Dawkins' says about the evils done in the name of Religion, but does not let him get away with the sloppy and poorly researched show more and unbalanced argument which features in the book. Whether you take Dawkins' side or not, this is a good book to read to see what Christians REALLY believe rather than the caricature Strawman that Dawkins often sets up, only to demolish a few paragraphs later. Robertson presents good arguments to show and that there are intellectually rigorous responses to the objections Dawkins raises. show less

A very helpful response to Dawkins' "God Delusion", robustly but politely taking him to task on his poor research and for the false picture of God, Christianity and the Bible that he paints. Definitely recommended for anyone who wishes to dig deeper than the polemics.

(I'm docking half a star because it could have done with a better edit to remove some of his parenthetical asides and a few of his exclamation points.)

Replaced by a New Revised edition 9781845505974