Bonar Menninger
Author of Mortal Error: The Shot That Killed JFK
About the Author
Works by Bonar Menninger
Tagged
Common Knowledge
- Canonical name
- Menninger, Bonar
- Gender
- male
- Nationality
- USA
- Associated Place (for map)
- USA
Members
Reviews
This is a non-fiction account of the EF5 tornado which struck Topeka, Kansas in June of 1966. It begins with author's notes (1) to explain source material and how he used it and (2) to warn readers that those who survived the tornado by huddling under bridges were very, very lucky -- that it is NOT recommended. That said, he gets to the story, and what a story it is.
He follows the experiences of a great number of people who were in the tornado. The accounts are more or less divided up into show more different areas that the tornado hit as it entered and moved through the city. Each section has a map, and at the beginning there is a larger map to place the area maps into the larger context. I found these maps extremely helpful in following what happened, as the area maps are marked with the locations of different people that we are reading about.
There is a chapter involving Toledo history and a legend which people associate with the tornado. There is also a chapter about the formation of tornadoes, this tornado in particular, and the history of tornado forecasting. I found this fascinating; people less interested in weather might differ on that opinion. We also read of the aftermath of the storm, and how it furthered the progress of tornado safety.
But it was the accounts of the people in the storm that I found absolutely riveting. I've read a lot of weather-related books, and a number of them on tornadoes, but I've never gotten such a clear sense of what it's like to experience a major tornado. The stories were spellbinding, and some of the details were absolutely incredible.
I could hardly put this book down. I read until 2 a.m. the night I started it, and the next day (my day off) I did very little but read, except for those tasks I absolutely had to accomplish (medical appointment, cooking meals, etc.) I thought this was a fabulous book, and I've given it 5 stars. show less
He follows the experiences of a great number of people who were in the tornado. The accounts are more or less divided up into show more different areas that the tornado hit as it entered and moved through the city. Each section has a map, and at the beginning there is a larger map to place the area maps into the larger context. I found these maps extremely helpful in following what happened, as the area maps are marked with the locations of different people that we are reading about.
There is a chapter involving Toledo history and a legend which people associate with the tornado. There is also a chapter about the formation of tornadoes, this tornado in particular, and the history of tornado forecasting. I found this fascinating; people less interested in weather might differ on that opinion. We also read of the aftermath of the storm, and how it furthered the progress of tornado safety.
But it was the accounts of the people in the storm that I found absolutely riveting. I've read a lot of weather-related books, and a number of them on tornadoes, but I've never gotten such a clear sense of what it's like to experience a major tornado. The stories were spellbinding, and some of the details were absolutely incredible.
I could hardly put this book down. I read until 2 a.m. the night I started it, and the next day (my day off) I did very little but read, except for those tasks I absolutely had to accomplish (medical appointment, cooking meals, etc.) I thought this was a fabulous book, and I've given it 5 stars. show less
The Answer to 'Who Killed JFK' is Finally Figured Out. I've been a JFK assassination buff for decades. I cannot tell you how many books, movies, and articles I've read on the subject. To date, the best and most logical, was by Gerald Posner entitled "Case Closed." But after reading Mortal Error, that is no longer the case. All books dealing with the assassination concentrate on the conspiracy theories? None of these books ever deal with the science, the ballistics, of the murder. This book show more does just that. You cannot argue with the science and the facts of what are the characteristics of bullets, angles and the after-effects of bullets hitting bones, muscle, etc. This book takes a very, very deep dive into just those areas - areas that the Warren Commission and every other book never even bothered to delve into. Lee Harvey Oswald definitely shot AT JFK, but he didn't KILL JFK. JFK was killed by an accidentally fired bullet from the AK-47 of Secret Service agent George Hickey from the follow-up car behind JFK's limousine. I implore every American who cares about justice, the truth and their government to read this book. show less
This is the story of the June, 1966 tornado that ripped through Topeka, Kansas, from one end of town to the other (it was on the ground for 22 miles for 40 minutes). The tornado obliterated Washburn University. Though the Fujita scale hadn't been invented yet, it would later be called an F5 tornado.
Thanks to strong tornado preparedness and newscasters who got the word out, among other factors, only 16 lives were lost.
Initially, I was a bit put off by the author's use of a neighborhood by show more neighborhood approach to telling the story of this tornado as there seemed to be quite a bit of repeated information, but I quickly got used to it. The author excelled at mentioning something interesting about each person and his or her experiences during the tornado.
For instance, he talks about children and their families where the kids were about to start a music recital when the tornado hit. The group relocated to the basement but the piano in the southwest corner of the basement was out of tune so they relocated to another area of the basement (very fortunately, I might add). He wrote so vividly about the victims that, even though I met them only briefly, I really started to care about them and was glad that he followed up.
Many lessons were learned from this tornado, including the fact that the southwest corner of the basement is NOT the safest place to be.
If you like to read about disasters, this is the book for you. Excellent!! show less
Thanks to strong tornado preparedness and newscasters who got the word out, among other factors, only 16 lives were lost.
Initially, I was a bit put off by the author's use of a neighborhood by show more neighborhood approach to telling the story of this tornado as there seemed to be quite a bit of repeated information, but I quickly got used to it. The author excelled at mentioning something interesting about each person and his or her experiences during the tornado.
For instance, he talks about children and their families where the kids were about to start a music recital when the tornado hit. The group relocated to the basement but the piano in the southwest corner of the basement was out of tune so they relocated to another area of the basement (very fortunately, I might add). He wrote so vividly about the victims that, even though I met them only briefly, I really started to care about them and was glad that he followed up.
Many lessons were learned from this tornado, including the fact that the southwest corner of the basement is NOT the safest place to be.
If you like to read about disasters, this is the book for you. Excellent!! show less
A very well thought out and researched theory from a totally different perspective. Makes a lot of sense and is probably true. The writing is a bit dense and the author adds things that detour from the overall narrative.
It's a shame that this will never be fully resolved and if indeed this is the actual way it happened, the government is equally guilty of killing JFK as Oswald is for causing the events which led to his unfortunate death.
It's a shame that this will never be fully resolved and if indeed this is the actual way it happened, the government is equally guilty of killing JFK as Oswald is for causing the events which led to his unfortunate death.
Lists
Awards
You May Also Like
Statistics
- Works
- 2
- Members
- 250
- Popularity
- #91,400
- Rating
- 3.6
- Reviews
- 8
- ISBNs
- 8













