Matthew Bunson

If you ever host a Sherlock Holmes trivia night, be sure to bring this book along.

This is a thoroughly useful reference to the Holmes canon. For instance, every Conan Doyle story is included here, with a setting and a list of major characters -- but without telling the solution to the case; you'll rarely have to worry about spoilers. All those major characters also have their own entries, as do places involved in the tale. In addition to that, there is a lot of information about peripheral show more material. So you'll find information about pastiches and parodies, as well as movie tie-ins (so, e.g., there is information not only about The Hound of the Baskervilles, the novel, but about related movies, and about actors such as William Gillette, the original stage Holmes, and of course Basil Rathbone, among many others). There is also a chronology, though this strikes me as too dependent on William S. Baring-Gould, with too little discussion of alternatives.

The one thing the book doesn't cover very well is all the sources that Conan Doyle used. The example that struck me was Birdy Edwards and the Scowrers of The Valley of Fear. The Scowrers are based on a real group, the Molly Maguires (though the Scowrers are worse and have far fewer excuses than the Mollies), and Edwards is an avatar of the man who broke up the Mollies, James McParlan(d) (though here again, Conan Doyle distorts things, making Edwards a very good man, whereas McParland proved to be a less-than-wonderful character in real life). But author Bunson never so much as mentions either the Mollies or McParland.

And some of Bunson's citations are a little off. For example, in his entry on "Shakespeare," he accuses Holmes of mis-quoting the line from "Twelfth Night" -- cited by Holmes as "Journeys end in lovers' meetings." Bunson is right that the final word should probably be "meeting," not "meetings," but he makes much too much of the orthography -- we use apostrophes and standardized spellings, but such things were much more fluid in Shakespeare's time.

These are nitpicks, or, rather, they are differences in emphasis. I would have preferred a slightly different book. But if you accept its scope, this is a very solid, and often amusing, book. show less

This is a perfect book for fans of the new tv series Sherlock starring Benedict Cumberbatch. Or for those who before never ever really cared about Sherlock Holmes, or *gasp* never even heard about him.

It's a fun book to read, a quick read, but for people that know quite a lot about Sherlock Holmes, that have for instance read some or all the books, seen the movies with Basil Rathbone or the excellent tv-series with Jeremy Brett (R.I.P my one and only true Sherlock) then this book will not show more really satisfy you.

But as an introduction to future Sherlockians, then this is perfect!

Thank you Netgalley for providing me with a free copy for an honest review!
show less

Accessible, informative, and rooted in journalistic rigor and an intimate understanding of the Church, Leo XIV: Portrait of the First American Pope is essential reading for anyone seeking to understand the man inside the white cassock—and the moment in which he will reign.

An informative & interesting look at a man I hadn’t know existed before becoming Leo XIV. The author does a good job introducing him to the world & giving us some insight into his thinking.