Simon Bucher-Jones
Author of The Taking of Planet 5
About the Author
Image credit: me
Works by Simon Bucher-Jones
Associated Works
Sherlock Holmes and the Occult Detectives vol. 4 (The Great Detective Universe) (2022) — Author — 3 copies
Occult Detective Magazine #9 — Contributor — 3 copies
Tagged
Common Knowledge
- Birthdate
- 1964-09-06
- Gender
- male
- Nationality
- UK
Members
Reviews
Lists
You May Also Like
Associated Authors
Statistics
- Works
- 11
- Also by
- 11
- Members
- 452
- Popularity
- #54,272
- Rating
- 3.5
- Reviews
- 8
- ISBNs
- 11
Simon Bucher-Jones has produced a really good Black Archive on this story, considering mainly the horror tropes. It’s quite long but has only four chapters.
The first and longest chapter, “Why Are Hands So Significant?”, looks at the history of the hand in art from the stone age onwards, and at the precedents for detached hands in horror films, looking at the obvious Addams Family, The Beast with Five Fingers and Carry On Screaming, but also a 1963 B-Movie called The Crawling Hand which features a detached body part from a spaceship explosion.
The second chapter, “‘Eldrad Must Live’: Three Types of Fear in The Hand of Fear“, points out that the hand itself doesn’t strangle anyone and isn’t bloodied; so why is it scary? Or even, is it scary? Bucher-Jones diverts via the Flixborough disaster to considering the story’s plot structure and how the narrative beats function. He’s not completely certain that it all works, but I’m more confident that it does.
The third chapter, “The Thing from the Aeons: Fossil Horror and The Shadow Out of Time“, looks at how ancient figures coming back to life are treated in Doctor Who, linking Eldrad with Omega, Davros and Rassilon.
The fourth chapter, “Gender (and Other) Issues in The Hand of Fear“, briefly considers a) the fact that Judith Parrish’s female Eldrad is much better than Stephen Thorne’s male version; b) how the Hand could have landed relatively undamaged; c) the morality of the Doctor’s disposal of Eldrad; and d) the perfection of the final scene with Sarah’s departure.
An appendix, “Kastria and the Kastrians”, considers the difficulties of locating Kastria and of the Kastrians’ biology.
It’s a rare case among the Black Archives where I think I like the story more than the writer does, but in any case he does a good job.… (more)