This topic is currently marked as "dormant"—the last message is more than 90 days old. You can revive it by posting a reply.
1MrsKroeger
My personal favorite leader is Firestar.I miss Bluestar and it was sad when she had drowned.
Here r the leaders:
Leopardstar
Firestar
Blackstar
Onestar
I think Onestar is a good cat but I didn't really think he deserved to be leader.Leopardstar is nice becuz she is the only female leader and it shows that the female cats can also be a powerful bunch. :)
Here r the leaders:
Leopardstar
Firestar
Blackstar
Onestar
I think Onestar is a good cat but I didn't really think he deserved to be leader.Leopardstar is nice becuz she is the only female leader and it shows that the female cats can also be a powerful bunch. :)
2nymith
In terms of most capable leader, I think Firestar is the best.
Onestar is a good cat but he doesn't seem to be leader material, and he was so ready and willing to forsake his long friendship with Firestar.
I hope Crowfeather will become leader someday, but that will probably never happen because of his love for Leafpool. Then again, Graystripe became deputy after Silverstream, so maybe he will become leader. I hope so! He was very brave on the journey, and when the clans were traveling, and Deadfoot believed he would make a fine leader of Windclan someday, so I hope he does.
I also like Leopardstar because she is the only female leader. I wish another would turn up. Not Russetfur though.
And I like Blackstar, even if he did start off evil. I think he regretted it afterwards, and took Firestar's advice to learn from the mistakes he and his predecessors made. But that is just my opinion.
So I like them all except Onestar. I guess Firestar is my favorite too.
Onestar is a good cat but he doesn't seem to be leader material, and he was so ready and willing to forsake his long friendship with Firestar.
I hope Crowfeather will become leader someday, but that will probably never happen because of his love for Leafpool. Then again, Graystripe became deputy after Silverstream, so maybe he will become leader. I hope so! He was very brave on the journey, and when the clans were traveling, and Deadfoot believed he would make a fine leader of Windclan someday, so I hope he does.
I also like Leopardstar because she is the only female leader. I wish another would turn up. Not Russetfur though.
And I like Blackstar, even if he did start off evil. I think he regretted it afterwards, and took Firestar's advice to learn from the mistakes he and his predecessors made. But that is just my opinion.
So I like them all except Onestar. I guess Firestar is my favorite too.
3pika_panda
Leopardstar, Firestar, and i'll always like Bluestar.
4dakpoppy123
yeh bluestars cool firestars ok but he just seems to good he always does the right thing where as others do wrong things but i like therm better firestar is too perfect
leapordstar is cool, blackstars quite good but i prefered tallstar to onestar
leapordstar is cool, blackstars quite good but i prefered tallstar to onestar
5TheReadCat
Firestar is unequivocally the best leader. Leopardstar is a weak leader, and she showed us that she was a "lemming" when she allowed Tigerstar to take over her clan. I liked Tallstar a lot as well. Don't trust Blackstar for a second.
6Lillytail
Blackstar. Firestar's a mary sue now, Leopardstar is just unagreeable, Onestar got into a snit and lost his lovable nature...Blackstar, he's just, exalted.
7mjrcatgirl
I think it would be cool if Mistyfoot would become leader of RiverClan. My favorite is Firestar (you can't not remotely like Firestar) and I really liked Bluestar as well. I don't really trust Shadowclan...I mean I guess they should be given a chance...but I don't know Blackstar just always seems aloof, I don't know enough about him to be sure. I also liked Tallstar a lot. :)
8Aquali96
I have this negative view of leopardstar and there's loads more leaders:
blackstar
brokenstar
tallstar
onestar
firestar
bluestar etc...
i like bluestar
tallstar was leader a longtime
i hate blackstar!!!!
blackstar
brokenstar
tallstar
onestar
firestar
bluestar etc...
i like bluestar
tallstar was leader a longtime
i hate blackstar!!!!
9mjrcatgirl
bluestar kind of went crazy in the end...but she was a great leader
i admired tallstar he was just kind of always there.
firestar's obviously a favorite it's amazing to think he used to be rusty the kittypet
i admired tallstar he was just kind of always there.
firestar's obviously a favorite it's amazing to think he used to be rusty the kittypet
10Aquali96
yea I kw she was just pissin me off so i was kinna happy she died but just the words she said, made me regret i wanted her to die.
I just read wen Tallstar died, I feels wierd now..
But there's seem something wrong with Leopardstar, and I miss Crookedstar.
I allways thought Onewhisker was an elder, and he became leader i was like oh...right he was young
he just has and elder name!
I just read wen Tallstar died, I feels wierd now..
But there's seem something wrong with Leopardstar, and I miss Crookedstar.
I allways thought Onewhisker was an elder, and he became leader i was like oh...right he was young
he just has and elder name!
11mjrcatgirl
yeah...his name did sound like an elder name. crookedstar was runner-up for the story contest thingy that erin hunter's publisher did...whatever clan leader won got a special story written about them. firestsar won, of course,...which kind of sucks b/c he already has firestar's quest written about him.
13mjrcatgirl
it's kind of silly b/c firestar already has story and we know all about him. it would be so interesting for crookedstar!
15mjrcatgirl
yeah. they just don't understand how interesting stories about other cats from other clans would be.
16firehart12
I like blackstar
17firestar00
I like firestar, bluestar, tallstar, and leperdstar
20feathercat1
I like Firestar because he is so confident of himself and can make good choices. I also like Bluestar and Leopardstar. Leopardstar has made some bad choices, but she is always doing what is right for her clan. I liked Onestar, but when he became leader he gave up his and Firestar's friendship. I understand that he wanted to prove that Windclan was independent and strong, but Thunderclan is still a good allie.

