This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.
  • LibraryThing
  • Book discussions
  • Your LibraryThing
  • Join to start using.

Chaim Potok--American Author Challenge January 2019

75 Books Challenge for 2019

Join LibraryThing to post.

Edited: Jan 11, 8:34am Top

Herman Harold Potok was born in 1929 to Polish parents with ties to Hasidic traditions, and was raised in an Orthodox Jewish home. He was given the Hebrew name Chaim, and received an Orthodox education. As a teenager, he read Brideshead Revisited, and was transported to another world, one inhabited by upper-class British Catholics. He began writing fiction himself, optimistically submitting a story to The Atlantic Monthly at the age of 17. He received a B.A. in English literature from Yeshiva University, where he was first published in its literary journal. Following graduation, he went on to the Jewish Theological Seminary of America, from which he was ordained as a Conservative rabbi. He did graduate studies in English, Philosophy and Theology at various times in his life. In 1955 he enlisted in the US Army, serving as a chaplain in South Korea for 2 years, again becoming fascinated with another religion, as well as with another world—one in which there were no Jews, and no trace of anti-Semitism. He served on the faculty of several Jewish universities, edited two Jewish publications, and worked with young people in Conservative summer camps and youth organizations. For 7 years he and his family lived in Israel.

Potok’s first novel, The Chosen, is also probably his best known work. It was published in 1967 to much critical and popular acclaim. It is the story of two boys, one from the Hasidic community and one from a slightly more worldly Conservative Jewish family. Their friendship developed despite the challenges brought about by the differences in their life-styles, and Potok used this device brilliantly to explore those differences for a wider, non-Jewish audience. It was the first book dealing with Orthodox Judaism in this way to be published in the United States. Most of Potok’s subsequent fiction is also concerned with the conflict between religious and secular interests.

In addition to his novels, Potok wrote plays, stories for children, scholarly articles and two non-fiction works Wanderings: Chaim Potok’s History of the Jews and Old Men at Midnight. He also painted in a style reminiscent of Chagall, and created a real-life version of the fictional Brooklyn Crucifixion painting described in his novel, My Name is Asher Lev.

Chaim Potok died in 2002 of brain cancer. His correspondence, lectures, sermons and other papers are in the collection of the University of Pennsylvania, where he taught graduate seminars for several years before his death.

The General Discussion Thread for the 2019 AAC is here.

Dec 26, 2018, 5:47pm Top

I have read at least 3, possibly more, titles by Potok. I should probably reread them, though, because I read them eons ago and have little recollection apart from the knowledge that I loved his writing. However, since I have more books than years left to read, I rarely reread. So, I will read a volume I have in my house right now called The Gift of Asher Lev. I am also fairly certain I have a copy of Davita's Harp somewhere in this house but for the moment, I have not been able to locate it.
Thanks again for setting this all up Linda.

Dec 26, 2018, 5:53pm Top

>2 jessibud2: I read several of his novels long ago too, Shelley. But I'm not sure I ever got to The Gift of Asher Lev. I am going to re-read The Chosen, because I remember being so impressed and moved by it the first time, but do not remember a lot about the story.

Dec 26, 2018, 6:23pm Top

I'll be reading My Name is Asher Lev for January. It will be my first Potok.

Dec 26, 2018, 7:54pm Top

>4 Caroline_McElwee: I plan to read that as well. I read The Chosen ages ago, possibly in my teens. At some point more recently, a number of LTers were reading My Name is Asher Lev, and praised it highly.

Dec 27, 2018, 8:30am Top

Sadly, I have not read Potok, but this looks like the perfect opportunity to do so. I want to finally read The Chosen, but I have My Name is Asher Lev on shelf, so I will start with that one. I hope to get to The Chosen later in the year.

Dec 27, 2018, 9:36am Top

>6 msf59: I love Potok, but The Chosen is probably my favorite.

Dec 28, 2018, 12:19pm Top

The Chosen was one of my favorite books when I was a teen (a long time ago!) I think I need to read it again, as an adult. And I'm hoping to fit in a few more Potoks in January. Looking forward to it!

Karen O.

Dec 30, 2018, 9:51am Top

I’ve read five of Potok’s books:
The Chosen, The Promise (a sequel to The Chosen), My Name Is Asher Lev, The Gift of Asher Lev, and In the Beginning. All are heart-breakingly beautiful. I’m not sure if I’ll do a reread or try a new one.

Dec 30, 2018, 10:07am Top

>9 bohemima: There is also Davita's Harp, I believe. I have it but have not yet read it.

Dec 30, 2018, 10:42am Top

I read The Chosen some time ago and absolutely loved it. I enjoyed the sequel, though not quite as much. Tried My Name Is Asher Lev about ten years back and just couldn't get into it. I'm waffling between a reread of The Chosen and reading Davita's Harp, which I've never tried and have on hand. Leaning slightly toward the one that will be new to me, I think.

Dec 30, 2018, 11:00am Top

What a grand mix we have of people who already love Potok, and people who have never read him at all. For those with several of his novels under their belts already, I can recommend the collection of short fiction, Old Men at Midnight in which Davita Chandal reappears and is the common denominator, as well as the excellent non-fiction piece of Russian history, The Gates of November.

Dec 30, 2018, 12:07pm Top

>12 laytonwoman3rd: thank you! I am going to check our library system for those.

Dec 30, 2018, 5:17pm Top

I have read almost all of his fiction (The Chosen is my favorite), so I am going to try nonfiction for the challenge and read The Gates of November (at least, I think it is nonfiction!)

Dec 30, 2018, 6:26pm Top

I have ordered a copy of The Chosen and I should have it by the weekend. Surprisingly, it wasn’t available on kindle or audiobook. I haven’t come across Chaim Potok before, but it sounds interesting.

Edited: Dec 30, 2018, 8:38pm Top

>13 fuzzi: I hope you can get one or the other.

>14 alcottacre: I'm pretty sure it's non-fiction, Stasia, although I see some people have tagged it fiction. Some of the people in it are listed as co-authors, and I understand it is based on Potok's interviews with them in Russia.

>15 SandDune: Good. I really think you'll enjoy it.

Edited: Dec 30, 2018, 9:40pm Top

>16 laytonwoman3rd: I have a reserve in for Old Men at Midnight!

Dec 31, 2018, 9:36pm Top

>17 fuzzi: Old Men at Midnight was just 'ok' for me. I will be interested to see what you think of it.

From The Gates of November: "The atmosphere in the room was disquieting; it seemed to quiver with barely suppressed apprehension. Someone once said that the only true question we ought to ask one another is: 'What are you going through?' Probably in the course of this evening the question would be answered without ever being asked. It was a desperate way for people like these to sustain life and hope: through strangers dropping in from the sky."

I do so love the way that Potok writes! He paints such a vivid picture in my head.

Dec 31, 2018, 10:29pm Top

>18 alcottacre: - Hmm, interesting to hear this. I am still looking for my copy (that I know is somewhere in this house!) of Davita's Harp but instead I found Old Men at Midnight and have decided to read this one instead of the one I originally planned to read, (The Gift of Asher Lev), mainly because Old Men is paperback and The Gift is a heavier hard back and I am travelling on Thursday and don't want to lug a hardcover on the train and home again.

Jan 1, 2:03pm Top

I'm another who has not read Potok. I have a copy of My Name is Asher Lev on my shelves, so I'll be joining in with those reading it.

I'm having a strong burst of my usual January resolution - to read more of the books already sitting on my shelf (and maybe not purchase quite so many .....)

Edited: Jan 1, 5:09pm Top

>20 streamsong: hahahahaha!!!!!!!!!

(I'm that way, too)

I loved Asher Lev when I read it a few years ago. My mother was a big Potok fan but I'd not gotten around to checking out his works until then.

If I recall (without peeking), I gave Asher Lev either 4 1/2 or 5 stars.

EDIT: I peeked, I gave it 5 stars back in 2014.

Jan 1, 6:51pm Top

I read My Name is Asher Lev in 2017 and gave it five stars. I highly recommend it.

Jan 1, 7:05pm Top

I love Chaim Potok. The Chosen is my favorite of all that I've read. I have had Old Men At Midnight on my TBR pile for ages. I am going to read that one.

Jan 1, 8:30pm Top

I’ve never read anything by Potok but I’m planning to read The Chosen which has been on my shelf for about ten years.

Jan 1, 9:24pm Top

I'm nearing the end of The Chosen. Although I know I read it and was impressed with it decades ago, I find I remember very few details, just the overall sense of friendship overcoming differences. I am once more very impressed with the story, and marveling a bit at what I must have made of it in my early 20's, when I had a much narrower grasp of the historical and philosophical issues embedded in it.

Jan 1, 10:52pm Top

I have not read Potok before, so I plan to start with The Chosen, and maybe My Name is Asher Lev.

Jan 2, 7:47am Top

I started My Name is Asher Lev this morning, and fell quickly into its rhythms. I ordered a copy of The Chosen too, so I may actually manage 2 books for this month's challenge!

Jan 2, 7:50am Top

>19 jessibud2: I do not blame you! I would not want to be lugging around heavy hardbacks while I am traveling either.

Edited: Jan 3, 9:22am Top

I requested My Name is Asher Lev as a library Kindle loan yesterday; it was checked out at the time so I thought it might take a week or more. But no, I got it later in the day. Okay, so, I guess that's what I'm reading now. 😀

I started reading last night and am quite intrigued. A few years ago, quite by accident, my husband and I found ourselves walking through a Hasidic neighborhood in Brooklyn. It was our first visit to Brooklyn and we were actually a little lost. Now we know the area a bit better, and this book makes me want to know more about Brooklyn's Jewish community(ies). I'm off to do some Googling ...

Edited: Jan 3, 2:02pm Top

My Name is Asher Lev is set in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, and Asher's family is described as "Ladover." I found a source describing Ladover Hasidism as a fictional sect, bearing the most resemblance to the Lubavitch Hasiddim, "one of the most open and worldly of the Hasidic groups." The Lubavitch hasidic movement was based in Crown Heights.

I found more context about the Lubavitch Hasidim and Crown Heights in this primer on Brooklyn's Jewish Communities:

Crown Heights
While the Crown Heights area north of Eastern Parkway is known for its bars and restaurants, the area south is home to a large Jewish community. Middle class Jews started moving to the neighborhood in the 1940s through the ’60s. The area became home to a number of large synagogues including the Bobov and Chovevei Torah, as well as prominent Yeshiva elementary schools.

The historic building at 770 Eastern Parkway was established as the central location for the Chabad sect during the 40s, and Crown Heights still has a large Hasidic Jewish population. The Chabad movement is known for its outreach activities, spreading the word to Jews of all denominations through everything from one-on-one street interactions to the roaming truck with loudspeakers affectionately known as the Mitzvah Tank.

Today 770 Eastern Parkway serves as the central headquarters of the Chabad-Lubavitch Hasidic movement, considered to be an iconic site in Judaism. The movement’s last Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, is considered by some members of the movement to be the long-awaited Jewish Messiah (or Moshiach), though this is a very controversial idea. Accordingly, there are replicas of his Crown Heights home in Jerusalem, Los Angeles, Australia, Italy, Brazil, and Argentina.

The Jewish Children’s Museum is also located in the neighborhood, the largest Jewish-themed children’s museum in the United States.

I assume the "outreach activities" are the reason Asher's father travels so much for the Rebbe?

Jan 3, 2:38pm Top

>25 laytonwoman3rd: I started reading the first few pages of The Chosen yesterday and all of a sudden old synapses clicked. Robby Benson. I read the book and saw the film in the early 80's. I don't really remember the story but as soon as i started reading it was all completely familiar. I suppose I wasn't overwhelmed with it back then because i certainly don't remember it as a favorite. I may or may not get back to it at the end of the month to re-read. I don't have an urge to, but I'm glad everyone seems to be enjoying it.

Jan 3, 2:56pm Top

>30 lauralkeet: Very interesting! Thank you!

Jan 3, 3:31pm Top

>30 lauralkeet: fascinating Laura, thank you.

Jan 4, 10:53am Top

I am about 2/3 through The Chosen. I got the copy at a library sale (where else?!). I also have My Name Is Asher Lev, also a library sale find, and I just might read it too.

Jan 4, 11:15am Top

I picked up a copy of The Chosen for 50 cents at a used bookstore. I'll be reading it.

Jan 4, 1:42pm Top

I loved The Chosen and My Name is Asher Lev, and this month I plan to read his The Promise.

Jan 4, 3:18pm Top

I started Old Men at Midnight last night and so far, so good. One of the main characters is Davita and the *harp* is already manifesting as a major *thing* for her so I will assume she is the same character as the one is his Davita's Harp, which of course, I will now have to find and read. Maybe I should have found a copy before reading this one but since I am not at home at the moment, I will just finish this one and find Davita later.

Jan 4, 4:09pm Top

>37 jessibud2: Davita is definitely the same character in both books, Shelley. I don't know that it matters a lot not to have read Davita's Harp first...I read it so long before reading Old Men at Midnight that I didn't even make the connection at first. I think the latter can stand alone.

Jan 4, 4:34pm Top

>38 laytonwoman3rd: - Thanks, Linda. That's good to know.

Jan 4, 10:12pm Top

Chaim Potok is the author who made me love books. I picked up a copy of My Name is Asher Lev at a second hand bookshop when I lived in Australia (there were many copies of it, it must have been prescribed reading for a school), and I think it's fait to say it changed my life. It remains my favourite book of all time.


Jan 5, 7:21am Top

^Very little reading yesterday but I did manage to start My Name is Asher Lev. I have a feeling this is going to be a good one. My very first Potok.

>30 lauralkeet: Interesting info, Laura. thanks for sharing.

Jan 5, 10:39am Top

>40 LovingLit: I think every one of us has a story like that....I love hearing them.

Edited: Jan 6, 5:23pm Top

I finished Old Men at Midnight. In fact, it is really 3 novellas, linked by one common character who appears in each, at different ages. I liked the first and the third sections well enough, did not like the second at all. The bulk of Potok's writing, in this book at least (I read most of his others too many years ago to remember them in this way) seems to be more tangent than straight storyline. An interesting construct but it sometimes felt awkward. I wish the first novella had been longer, and more developed. I felt left hanging when it was over, expecting the second section to pick up the story but it didn't. I think this reinforces for me precisely why I generally do not enjoy short stories.

Oh well... win some, lose some.

I must say, though, that I think I will find my hidden copy (somewhere in my house) of Davita's Harp as it is her character that appears in each of the 3 sections of the one I just finished and Davita's Harp, as far as I know, is a full length novel.

edited to add in a line I underlined; couldn't help myself:

"In my world we sized people up by the books they read and the libraries in their homes."

Hehe, Potok could have been an LTer!

Jan 6, 8:37pm Top

I loved The Chosen so much I gave it 5 stars!

Jan 7, 6:14pm Top

I am halfway through The Gates of November and really enjoying one of Potok's forays into nonfiction. I suspect though, that unless you are interested in Russian history post-revolution, the book might not catch you up as it has me. The writing, as expected from Potok, is excellent and the story is well-told.

Jan 9, 6:29pm Top

-Guernica, Pablo Picasso 1937

^This painting is featured prominently in My Name Asher Lev. I am not sure what is exactly happening in this painting but I still find it intriguing. I am well into the second half of the novel and truly loving it. I am so glad I finally pulled this one down off the shelf:

"Those mornings, the beach was my synagogue and the waves and the gulls were audience to my prayers. I stood on the beach and felt wind-blown sprays of ocean on my face, and I prayed. And sometimes the words seemed more appropriate to this beach than to the synagogue on my street."

Jan 9, 6:55pm Top

>45 alcottacre: That landed on my mat today Stasia, though probably won't be read this month.

>46 msf59: Darryl read about this painting last year, and I think has seen it, he might be able to give you some info that will help you understand it Mark.

I'm on the last ten pages of My Name is Asher Lev and will finish it before bed. A brilliant read. I've ordered the sequel: The Gift of Asher Lev. In the meantime I may read The Chosen in the second half of the month.

Jan 9, 7:19pm Top

>47 Caroline_McElwee: Thanks for the Darryl tip, Caroline. I did not realize there was a sequel to Asher Lev! Hooray!!

Jan 9, 7:53pm Top

My Name is Asher Lev (Chaim Potok) (09/01/19) *****

A wonderful novel on so many levels. The writing is fine and vivid. You can feel what it is like living in that family, in that community. Every character has depth.

I learnt about Judaism, art and art criticism. I learnt about the problems art can create in such an environment. I understood better the power some art can have.

Even some of the finest art historians can struggle to describe for you the image they can see, but I saw all Asher Lev's paintings, even though he rarely offered up the colours.

This 320 pages are epic.

I am looking forward to the sequel The Gift of Asher Lev landing on the mat.

Jan 9, 8:26pm Top

>46 msf59:, >49 Caroline_McElwee: Don't forget to visit Potok's own painting, Brooklyn Crucifixion, in >1 laytonwoman3rd: above.

Jan 10, 7:39am Top

I also recently finished My Name is Asher Lev, and agree with Caroline's sentiments (>49 Caroline_McElwee:). It was an amazing book. The climax is intense and emotional, and Potok takes his time building up to it. I kept hoping there would be a way to avoid the inevitable. It was really powerful.

>50 laytonwoman3rd: thanks for the reminder, Linda. That's a very good representation of what he describes in the book.

>46 msf59: Mark, Guernica is one of Picasso's most famous works. I had the opportunity to see it last year when visiting Madrid. It's huge, with much to explore, and you can't help but feel its impact. I found this source with more background on the painting. Here's a snippet from the opening paragraphs:
Probably Picasso's most famous work, Guernica is certainly the his most powerful political statement, painted as an immediate reaction to the Nazi's devastating casual bombing practice on the Basque town of Guernica during Spanish Civil War.

Guernica shows the tragedies of war and the suffering it inflicts upon individuals, particularly innocent civilians.

Jan 10, 7:44am Top

>47 Caroline_McElwee: I hope you like it when you get to it, Caroline.

The Gates of November is a terrific nonfiction book by Potok. The story is told about a father and son, who are fundamentally different. There is no favoritism shown by Potok as he writes first of the father and his experiences, mainly post-revolution, and the son, who becomes the opposite - fighting for the right to leave Communist Russia and emigrate to Israel. I found the book well worth the read and gave it 4.5 stars.

Jan 10, 9:11am Top

>49 Caroline_McElwee:, >51 lauralkeet: I am clearly going to have to revisit My Name is Asher Lev; I know I read it years ago, but I don't remember being as impressed as you two have been with it. That tells me that I may not have been "ready" for it at the time, and it deserves more of my attention. Thank you for your excellent reviews.

>52 alcottacre: I thought The Gates of November was very powerful, Stasia. And I loved this quote from Potok's epilogue: "Can we learn something from these chronicles about iron righteousness and rigid doctrine, about the stony heart, the sealed mind, the capricious use of law, and the tragedies that often result when theories are not adjusted to realities?"

Jan 10, 9:52am Top

>53 laytonwoman3rd: I think I might be in the same place with The Chosen. I read it either in my teens or in college, and I'm sure it would make a different impression now.

Jan 10, 10:09am Top

>31 RBeffa: You know, I don't think I ever saw the movie. I wonder if it did justice to the book. Anyone else remember it?

Jan 10, 10:27am Top

>55 laytonwoman3rd: I recall I liked the movie a lot. I believe I read the book after the film (I have a few penciled notes in my paperback that suggest that). I haven't gotten back to the book yet but I still have a lot of month to go! Potok's books are sure getting a lot of praise here.

Jan 10, 11:05am Top

Jan 10, 7:12pm Top

I'm just finishing The Chosen and I found it just as compelling and well-written as I did when I was a teenager (long ago and far away). I've just requested the movie version because I remember it as being a great visualization of the book. I'm reading Old Men at Midnight during the rest of the month.

Chaim Potok for the January AAC seems a solid "win" for me!

Karen O.

Jan 10, 8:17pm Top

>58 klobrien2: - I will be interested to hear your impressions of Old Men at Midnight, Kathy. You may be the only other person besides myself who has chosen that one for this month. My review is somewhere up there in this thread.

Jan 11, 2:17am Top

Like Mark and Caroline and others my AAC will be My Name is Asher Lev which I am starting today.

>1 laytonwoman3rd:

By the way, Linda, your introduction of the author was informative and an excellent way of setting up the month's challenge.

Jan 11, 8:35am Top

Thank you, Paul.

Jan 11, 8:33pm Top

While waiting for a copy of Old Men at Midnight to arrive at my library, I picked up The Chosen again and I'm hooked. Maybe I will read both.

Jan 11, 11:12pm Top

>53 laytonwoman3rd: I agree about the epilogue, Linda. Potok certainly makes some good points in it. The part where he discusses America was, I thought, very telling especially given the current political climate.

Jan 13, 7:44am Top

>59 jessibud2: I also have Old Men at Midnight for my read in January, but due to personal reasons I am deep in a comfort reread right now.

Group: 75 Books Challenge for 2019

213 members

13,087 messages


This topic is not marked as primarily about any work, author or other topic.

About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 131,611,094 books! | Top bar: Always visible