MESSAGE BOARD

TalkThe Global Challenge

Join LibraryThing to post.

MESSAGE BOARD

1labfs39
Mar 15, 2022, 5:56pm

The message board is for use by members to post general messages to the group, such as links to new group threads, announcements, questions, offers, invitations to local discussion...etc.

2rocketjk
Edited: Jan 6, 5:29pm

Hi, I've just become aware of this group. I'm curious about what the general qualifications are for including books. The group description says "Global Challenge is a place to track your reading from countries around the world." So, does that mean that a book must be written by someone from that country in that country's language? Suppose a book is written in English by an American, but it takes place in France. Would that qualify the book as being "from" France for the purposes of this challenge? I think I discern an informal "to each his/her/their own" philosophy to the proceedings. I'm interested, though, in learning what the general inclination of the group is along these lines. Either way is fine with me; just trying to get a fix on the lay of the land, as it were. Any thoughts?

3RidgewayGirl
Jan 6, 5:33pm

Jerry, I'm only counting authors from the country in question, but that really is something each reader gets to make their own decision about. Since there's no time limit and not many people watching, I'm enjoying the opportunity to set my thread up that way. But to each their own, obviously.

4AnnieMod
Jan 6, 5:44pm

>2 rocketjk: Basically - make your own rules. If you want to count that book for France, you can. If you want to count it for USA, that also works. If you want to ignore it, you can do that as well. :)

My own challenge requires local author (regardless of the language they write in - and with a bit of a wiggle room to allow the interpretation of "local" - someone who fled the country can still be considered local for me) and either a book at least partially set in the country or a speculative novel set on the secondary world/in space and so on (as I read a lot of SF/Fantasy and I don't want to exclude these). Plus I only allow 1 book per author.

Everyone has their own interpretation of the rules based on their own reading patterns, wishes and what they find doable for them.

5rocketjk
Jan 6, 6:02pm

3> & >4 AnnieMod: Thanks! That was my expectation. One more question: fiction only? Or, again, is it up to the individual?

6AnnieMod
Jan 6, 6:22pm

>5 rocketjk: Up to the individual. I allow both fiction and non-fiction (and poetry and drama) (the non-fiction and drama under the same rules as the fiction - needs to be related to the country - so local histories and memoirs work but a math textbook is out; any poetry by local poets is in).

7labfs39
Jan 6, 7:27pm

>2 rocketjk: I'm only counting authors from that country, unless they emigrated but the book is set in the home country or in that language. Like Annie, I'm counting memoirs and local histories, but not generic nonfiction. I'm not counting a lot of Holocaust memoirs, unless a significant portion of the book is about life before or after. One way in which my challenge differs is that I'm not restricting myself as to number of books for each country. Also, I have broken out Canada into Provinces, the UK into Scotland/Wales/England, and added several places like Palestine, Tibet, and Taiwan.

I think this group is what you make of it, but mostly it's a great place to keep your list and get ideas for books from hard to find countries.

8Willoyd
Edited: Jan 6, 8:09pm

As others have said, it's very much each to their own. FWIW, i'm trying as much as possible to go for prose fiction set in the country by an author from the country. That's just not going to happen though, particularly as I'm restricted to reading English, French or German. So I'll accept non-fiction or poetry, or a book by a local author but set elsewhere, or a book by a non-local set in the country etc etc where I have to. The aim though is to find a book that, closely as possible, is a decent representative of the literature of that country, or at least reflects the nature of it. Thus, of the 16 I've read so far, I've included at least 2 non-fiction (Michel the Giant for Togo, The Republic of San Marino for that country - both by native authors. Another example: my book for Antarctica (yes I've included it) is currently set as a piece of fiction set in the continent, but I might change that to a book of exploration or one about living there.
I'm currently only going for one book per country - any more will be noted but aren't part of the project.
My most interesting challenge may well turn out to be England (I've split the UK into 4)! That's because I'm only allowing books I haven't read. Finding a book that represents England and English literature from those is not difficult, but it's a tough decision deciding on which one (for me at least)!

9ELiz_M
Jan 6, 9:40pm

>2 rocketjk: echoing what others have said: it's your challenge, your thread, so your rules.

I want to read the literture of other countries. So, for me a book must meet two of the three following criteria:
B - author was born in the country
C - author is a citizen and/or lives in the country for at least 10 years
S - book is primarily set in the country

10MissBrangwen
Jan 7, 2:30am

>2 rocketjk: I am in the minority here, but I do count other books as well: Histories of a country written by authors not from the country, and also travel books and even novels. However, I have decided on a rather complicated system of how many books of which qualification are allowed to count or not, and it is my ultimate goal to read five books by authors from the country.

11Jackie_K
Jan 7, 2:00pm

Adding to the discussion, I think I'm similar to >10 MissBrangwen: in that I do allow books set in a country but by a non-local author - but I also want to read local authors, so if (say) I had already read 5 books for a country by a non-local author, and then read one by a local author, I'd either add them as a #6, or bump one of the non-local authors off the list.

I think ultimately my aim is to learn more about each country, however that's done. Ideally it would be from authors from that country, but I'm not going to exclude visitors.

Also, as per my ROOTs/Category Challenge/personal reading preferences, my reads are quite heavily skewed towards non-fiction. I wouldn't count a text book, but other academic books, such as research on an aspect of life, history, politics, etc in a particular country, would count for me.

12rocketjk
Jan 7, 4:41pm

Thanks, everybody! I appreciate all the feedback. I have added a thread and populated my list from the entries in my annual Reading Globally threads, beginning in 2010. Cheers!