very thoroughly documented and researched, i will give it that. Too detailed for its own, or the reader's, good, unfortunately. It is not a history of the samurai (class) as I expected, but a collection of many histories of some samurai (men) - the big picture cannot be seen, just and endless stream of repetitive small pictures of individuals. The author also dwells way too much into the literary/poems sources (famous for the Japanese, I think, and for him, but not for the ordinary reader), even though he admits they are not reliable historical sources.
The fact that so many Japanese names are very similar (must every samurai have a name starting with Y, damn it!?) and difficult to remember for a European is not the authors fault, but it sure does not help.
The book is too detailed and sinks too much into the individual, personal stories, failing to provide a clear history of the class itself or of the social phenomenons. And, frankly, is also very boring. I am fascinated by the samurai and read a lot about them (both historical and literary works), or zen, or bushido, but this one I just could not finish. ( )

A decent, very general overview of the history of the samurai. Too general in some ways but if you're looking to get a quick overview this is the book.

I'd rather have a series of in depth books that cover certain areas or time periods or even certain clans, people, etc. I'm sure there are books out there like that so I'll have to hunt for them. ( )

This is absolutely the book I wanted, but I can imagine how it might disappoint other readers who pick it up with false expectations. This is significant Japanese military history featuring samurai, with only a few details about how the samurai came to be and where their traditions originated sprinkled here and there. It is not the place to look if you want to know how their weapons and armour evolved, or learn about their fighting styles and the bushido code, etc. in any in-depth way (although it will help point you to those sources).

The various incidents and battles this work highlights are those central to Japanese history, including the Heiji Insurrection, the Genpei War, the Mongol invasions, the Korean invasions and Sekigahara. The historical record of earliest eras is shrouded in mythological retelling, making it interesting to observe in the early chapters which details have been preserved and which lost. The author shares multiple tellings where the records disagree, and challenges the traditional telling if it seems unlikely. He clearly loves his subject, and there are some fun asides and helpful observations along the way. This provides a solid framework in which I can find and fit all other reading on the topic, aided not a little by other works mentioned in the final chapter and appendix. ( )

Perhaps I would have enjoyed this one more if I knew more of the historical context around the developments presented here. Unfortunately, without that, this book is difficult at times to really follow. Nonetheless, it does provide useful and critical insight into the development and eventual disintegration of the samurai within Japanese history and culture. I'd like to think I'll return to this at some point, after reading more about the history of Japanese culture and society, but I suspect that's unlikely. ( )

This is an excellent, concise history of the samurai. Clements' scholarship is impeccable as always, but what I like best is his even-handed handling of the subject matter. Whenever there is competing or conflicting sources, schools of thought, or opinions (myths, Mongol invasion/kamikaze, Mishima, etc.), he clearly states them all and maintains his balance as he swiftly moves on to cover all the historical ground thoroughly. A must for any historian. ( )